Role Madness Overlord Mafia Game Thread

Do you wish for Plurality+hammer option if majority of votes are reached?

  • Yes

    Votes: 9 52.9%
  • No

    Votes: 2 11.8%
  • We want to shorten this day phase to 34 hours

    Votes: 6 35.3%

  • Total voters
    17
  • Poll closed .
My take on the message, it‘s either exactly from Ekko or from somebody unrelated to the Favs game. It‘s just unnecessarily outing if you can narrow down the culprit to only a few people.
 
My take on the message, it‘s either exactly from Ekko or from somebody unrelated to the Favs game. It‘s just unnecessarily outing if you can narrow down the culprit to only a few people.
How would the person in question even know to bring it up if they didn't play, seems dumb
 

Yoho

✌𝓣𝓱𝓮 𝓢𝓲𝓶𝓹𝓵𝓲𝓬𝓲𝓽𝔂 𝓸𝓯 𝓛𝓲𝓯𝓮✌
Why did you out these people, who says Ekko is town
He may or he may not be idk, but on the off chance he is town one of those four are likely scum shines a light of suspicions and doubt on them

And if he's not town one of those four can share what they learned and if they suddenly die it'll only serve to reinforce the idea he's scum

I can garner more information sharing what I learned than I would keeping it to myself

Basically just condensed today's POE into 5 possible suspects

Why are you against me sharing what I learned to the class?
 
How would the person in question even know to bring it up if they didn't play, seems dumb
Just search Ekko's past games -> find one where he was scummates with another player -> make sure enough people played in that game and this one to make a lot of probably suspects -> send message to Charlie.

I could easily see a dedicated scum team setting something like that up, especially if it has the chance to get town focused on the people instead of them (plus high chance for multiple miselims).
 

EkkoLoJinx

me devour you...
How would the person in question even know to bring it up if they didn't play, seems dumb
well there r 2 elements to this,
1. a person who has the range/cunningness to write the message in my style, and
2. a person who has the context/can do the research needed for the context.

both 1 and 2 can be the same person, or 2 different ppl in the same scum chat

i have shortlisted it to these basically:

what is this drivel




pretty much what i shortlisted it to. here's my list:

yo tan, Michelle, alwaysmind, charlie were in that game but i dont think they r the type to make that sort of play

now for the remaining:

soul - he was directly involved in that game as has the range and cunningness to make that play

flower - pretty much same as soul

hime - same as the above regarding the cunning and writing the message part except she lacks direct context of the game. however the game is public knowledge and me/soul talked about it alot so its not improbable that she heared it. that, or she has a teammate that has context of the game.

lanji - he was actually a teammate of soul and I in that game so he does have the context. Now i dont know if he has the range or cunning to do this. leaning towards no but its possible he and soulkiller met in the scum chat and talked about that game since thats pretty much the only game they played together iirc

worst - doesnt have much context but definitly has the cunning to try and do something like this. more or less like hime

crying - similar to worst and hime except he actually does the homeworks pretty well. hed be willing to research that game if anyone brought it in scum chat and would write a message like this

kiku - she has the ability to make the fake messages like this for sake of trolling, but i dont think she has that much context. i do find it funny she spent alot of time trying to find a post where
i said "rdy". seems too invested into it to be its sender. typically the senders will wait and bit and see how its received or be all slimy about it. she was pretty direct and focused on the most inane parts. she currently sits in too obvious culprit to be a culprit. im including her here because she had fooled me before with shit like making herself seem too scummy to be scum.

ratcher - for argument sake i can also add ratchet to the list since he can also make up a message like this but its not his style typically nor does he need to do it in his position unless he's saving a teammate or something. he can provide the needed context to an enthusiastic message writer though

mango - lastly mango shud have some context and troll ability to write a message like this or be part of the conspiracy. i didnt like how he approached me vs soul so im including him in the list
alexis fits enthusiastic writer and will be willing to do something like this but he needs support from someone that has the context. and similar to ratchet he has really low stakes in this unless saving a teammate or smth

im also noticing that flower's activity mostly diminished after sending the message. my main suspect list for the message is in that order of tiers:

top possible sender - soul/flower
next level - hime/crying/worst
next level - lanji/kiku/mango

anybody else falls below those tiers. can easily see people from different tiers coming together to write it
 
Top