Spoiler One Piece Chapter 1148 Spoilers Discussion

[kekaro]

Only the geniesues of WG can say that all the HKs will fight revos, in a arc where the Hks are not fight revos
Truely 120% of the brain is used here

 

[Kōri no kokyū]

Vague hints, you’re only saying that now in retrospect. Everybody, even Zoro fans were shocked during chapter 1010 when Kaido confirmed it. I was there during that time.

Zoro fans knew CoC was coming along sooner or later. they were much more hyped from Ashura return again.
also Ashura against kaidou was not AdCoC lol

 

[EmperorKinyagi]

I disagree. I think outcomes matter too. Like is Marco stronger than Zoro since Marco matched up with BM in Wano while Zoro matched with King?

That’s false equivalence, Marco didn’t have a singular standout major opponent in Wano whereas the admirals and Mihawk at MF did.

It’s much more analogous to SH matchups against enemy crews

 

[Monster Zoro's Tesla Supplier]

You know my stance on the subject

Shanks >= Mihawk.
Extreme diff fight like Ao and Aka but when everything is said and done it’s Shanks that will rise up

No, I mean Oda told us he's stronger than Shanks. This isn't up for debate.

.

 

[trav]

So strong that Marco sent Vista after him instead of himself lol

Being able to keep someone occupied is not the same as being able to actually win.
Vista would always lose in the end. Just not quickly.
Same as none of the commanders lost to the Admirals until WBs heartattack threw them off.
Admirals would still win even without the distraction, but it would take way longer.

 

[kekaro]

What does this have to do with me

I can put Jinbe on Fraudwatch if that's the general consensus but to me, y'all are clearly jumping the gun.

Jinbe has literally stated he's tryna think of a counter - bro is just chilling, none of the SHs took any significant damage around him; yes, Nami is mad that he's let them get captured, but that's just further proof that Jinbe's portrayal is undeniably closer to the M3's vs the mid trio's, as Nami has zero expectations for Brook.

Maybe all that thinking he doing fried his 2 fish brain cells

 

[RayanOO]

Can you explain how a swordsman can be stronger than the strongest swordsman?
This argument is really exhausting.

I explained it a lot already

do you think Mihawk is above Roger ? My answer is no. So the black blade argument isn’t that valid

Are titles absolute in OP ? My answer is no. WB had an equal (I think Roger was a shade stronger). Kaido was matched by Oden etc. You can have a WS title and still having a rival that can match you.

Do Shanks > Mihawk hurt Zoro dream ? I don’t think so. I don’t think Shanks is linked to Z dream at all. Like I don’t think Roger is linked to Z dream. They are on Luffy side of the story. Shanks bet the future on Luffy and removed himself from dueling Mihawk.

 

[Sir Yasheen]

That’s false equivalence, Marco didn’t have a singular standout major opponent in Wano whereas the admirals and Mihawk at MF did.

It’s much more analogous to SH matchups against enemy crews

But the outcome of those fights matter. It doesn’t matter if someone fought someone stronger if they failed to win.

 

[NikaInParis]

Is this the first time where we get 3 different summaries where every single on was lying? @NikaInParis i cant remember

It's a year of firsts so very fitting lol

 

[EmperorKinyagi]

But the outcome of those fights matter. It doesn’t matter if someone fought someone stronger if they failed to win.

I disagree, I think the matchup stacks matter more than outcomes. But I’ll agree to disagree for now

 

[HeroesNZ]

Maybe all that thinking he doing fried his 2 fish brain cells

Can you read?

Where in my post did I say Jinbe willingly let himself be captured i.e. didn't fight back?

I said Jinbe is chilling, thinking of a counter... which is a genuine manga fact lmfao.

I swear y'all be losing IQ points by the day

 

[kekaro]

Can you read?

Where in my post did I say Jinbe let himself be captured?

I said Jinbe is chilling, thinking of a counter... which is a genuine manga fact lmfao.

I swear y'all be losing IQ points by the day

Yes yes he thinking very hard right now how he accomplished less than a robin clone

 

[Julius]

What is my favorite whaleshark doing bruh

 

[soupongo]

His mother said he did to save those kids (for his father)

He cares about it being the hometown, but Weevil doesn't care about the random kids, Weevil is infamous for being brutal. Plus, the kids told Marco what happened but didn't mention being kidnapped

 

[RayanOO]

Again, it’s the portrayal. I don’t think there’s anything at MF suggests Mihawk was above the admirals and the matchup portrayal isn’t favorable.

It really isn’t deeper than that for me

I agree about portrayal standing supreme :

This is Mihawk portrayal :

- rival of Shanks
- Zoro endgame or point just before the endgame / extremely important character for Zoro overall
- black blade holder
- here since almost day 1 in the story

It’s above Admiral for me, except maybe Akainu

MF was a shit show with top tiers underperforming for different reasons. Mihawk had no reason to go all out and Oda wanted to keep his moveset and power for endgame. So be it.

 

[Sir Yasheen]

What is my favorite whaleshark doing bruh

“Does anyone happen to have any salt water I can use”

 

[mly90]

You know my stance on the subject

Shanks >= Mihawk.
Extreme diff fight like Ao and Aka but when everything is said and done it’s Shanks that will rise up

Nah the wss will beat any swordsman including shanks no amount of coping is changing this fact

 

[RayanOO]

Nah the wss will beat any swordsman including shanks no amount of coping is changing this fact

Like the WSM beat Roger ?

 

[warsame zaylai]

Again, it’s the portrayal. I don’t think there’s anything at MF suggests Mihawk was above the admirals and the matchup portrayal isn’t favorable.

It really isn’t deeper than that for me

He is
Shanks >the OG trio
Mihawk is close in strength with shanks

 

[omegalul]

He can’t be. The monster trio is still yet to do anything.

He might be KO’d for a chapter while Gaban frees the SHs before Gunko shows up with Colon and Gaban gets hostage diffed.

monster trio would stomp these HKs

we will see all the HKs being summoned this arc