Chapter Discussion ONE PIECE CHAPTER: 1156: IDOLS

[Dragon777]

Garp is 100% weaker than Roger.

And this is coming from me.

As Mihawk Is stronger than Shanks. Doesn't mean they are almost the same level and the winner would be definitely more dead than alive.

 

[The DevilMaster]

He’s not even 21.

This is 15 year old Kaido.

What makes Kaidou even more insane

 

[KINGKONGGUN15]

They saying Kaido tanked a hit from Rocks better than the admiral could

 

[soheilhazrat]

Yeah bro garp is weaker oda wrote it his era alongside rocks and roger for....... idk shits and giggles

 

[Garp the Fist]

How do you still think this after this chapter? Oda literally introduced them as equally matched in a clash, not to mention Garp previously said they both nearly killed eachother multiple times.

Because Oda has also made it abundantly clear for decades that Whitebeard was the only man who was as strong as Roger.

Roger and Whitebeard draw with each other, both extreme diff Garp. Nothing in this chapter changes that. Oda just wants them both to look good.

I can throw a scan of Whitebeard and Oden being equally matched in a clash, it doesn’t make them equals either.

 

[Shiroyru]

Meteor impact is him throwing a canon ball moron he still does it now

Lew and Ledon lied to me Btw that opens up the possibility that Wild Soul isn’t a sword attack

 

[soupongo]

@Dragon777
Ngl, as good as Garp looks here, it is still a couple years before GV, I think WB became his major rival after that point, which is why Buggy says only Whitebeard had equally matched Roger, because that´s all Buggy ever saw. I could be wrong though, but even Shiki hypes up Roger above Garp and Sengoku

 

[EmperorKinyagi]

Because Oda has also made it abundantly clear for decades that Whitebeard was the only man who was as strong as Roger.

Roger and Whitebeard draw with each other, both extreme diff Garp. Nothing in this chapter changes that. Oda just wants them both to look good.

I can throw a scan of Whitebeard and Oden being equally matched in a clash, it doesn’t make them equals either.

"we nearly killed each other dozens of times"

How does that not outright imply equality

 

[HA001]

Lew and Ledon lied to me Btw that opens up the possibility that Wild Soul isn’t a sword attack

Nope it's naming scheme matches zoros attacks

 

[The DevilMaster]

Xebec destroyed a freaking wall of justice i think they are more concerned about that

They used the plural in their speech, they said both(two) of you, which means that the destruction would not come from just one side.

It clearly seems to me that Xebec could not deal with Kaidou easily and the confrontation of the two would leave the island in ruins.

 

[Monster Zoro's Tesla Supplier]

Because Oda has also made it abundantly clear for decades that Whitebeard was the only man who was as strong as Roger.

Roger and Whitebeard draw with each other, both extreme diff Garp. Nothing in this chapter changes that. Oda just wants them both to look good.

I can throw a scan of Whitebeard and Oden being equally matched in a clash, it doesn’t make them equals either.

Sure, but we know Whitebeard > Oden because we're shown that multiple times. We're never shown Roger > Garp, otherwise Garp wouldn't be consistently chasing Roger around the sea and nearly killing him as well

 

[Shiroyru]

Nope it's naming scheme matches zoros attacks

 

[Kurozumi Wiwi]

Shakky is supposed to clear Gloriosa in-universe by a mile but art wise they look kind of the same aside from the hair color? Maybe I have facial blindness idk

 

[Dragon777]

Garp downplayers are wild bro

Nah he definitely is a Garp fan and he doesn't need to put Garp above or equal to Roger for him to be a Garp fan
But he's still incorrect

And tbh I can't even say that he wants Oda to spell It out because Oda already did spell It out.

Garp and Roger were on par.

 

[NicoRobinIsQueen]

Am I the only one seeing the parallels between cavendish and John?

 

[MonochromeYoru]

Shakky is supposed to clear Gloriosa in-universe by a mile but art wise they look kind of the same aside from the hair color? Maybe I have facial blindless idk

oda can't draw beautiful women lol

 

[Grotesque]

That boa x luffy agenda boutta cook bro finally

Doesn't this chapter prove the opposite? Gloriosa was obsessed with Roger like Boa is with Luffy. Roger ended up with Rouge.
If I was a BoaLu shipper right now I'd be seething. Help me see the positive for that agenda

 

[Shiroyru]

Roger and Rocks were making island sized black lightning streaks at GV. Yeah, Roger’s not in his prime yet this chapter @EmperorKinyagi @HA001 @soupongo

 

[Kurozumi Wiwi]

oda can't draw beautiful women lol

they look fine but i ain't fan of the bimbo lips

 

[HA001]

Shakkys is doing this without boas fruit btw