Chapter Discussion ONE PIECE CHAPTER: 1156: IDOLS

[Dragon777]

@Dragon777
Ngl, as good as Garp looks here, it is still a couple years before GV, I think WB became his major rival after that point, which is why Buggy says only Whitebeard had equally matched Roger, because that´s all Buggy ever saw. I could be wrong though, but even Shiki hypes up Roger above Garp and Sengoku

That's because then Oda was trying to hype WB. In this chapter for example we had Garp, Roger and Xebec mentioned as the greatest and fuck WB:

We have multiple statements, even by Roger himself.

Garp was simply him.

 

[Monster Zoro's Tesla Supplier]

Roger and Rocks were making island sized black lightning streaks at GV. Yeah, Roger’s not in his prime yet this chapter @EmperorKinyagi @HA001 @soupongo

Why does no one talk about the fact they seemingly split the skies there

 

[HA001]

Roger and Rocks were making island sized black lightning streaks at GV. Yeah, Roger’s not in his prime yet this chapter @EmperorKinyagi @HA001 @soupongo

That's just rocks

 

[Kurozumi Wiwi]

"we nearly killed each other dozens of times"

How does that not outright imply equality

Oda literally shafted WB to hype up Roger, Rocks and Garp through the narrator lmfao
If Roger and WB are 100, Garp is like a 99.5 at worst.

 

[Etzel Andergast]

 

[Shiroyru]

That's just rocks

 

[kekaro]

Shakkys is doing this without boas fruit btw

? Shakky didnt do anything boa cant do without her fruit this chapter what lmao

 

[Garp the Fist]

Garp was clearly on par with them. After this chapter It amazes me still reading this bias.

I’m not saying he’s not on par with him lmao. I’m saying he’s not Dorry Broggy, Roger Whitebeard equal to him.

Same way Rocks is stronger than Harald, even though they clashed the same way

Or Whitebeard is stronger than Oden, ditto.

How many times did we get Luffy clashing with Kaido like this lmao?

And Kaido did the same with Big Mom, and Shanks did the same with Whitebeard.

There’s been a mass loss of critical thinking in this place where anytime two characters clash it’s seen as a sign they are absolute perfect equals, which is patent nonsense.

Roger vs Garp is obviously extreme diff, Roger vs Garp is also obviously Roger’s win.

 

[MonochromeYoru]

That's just rocks

look at the dialogue

it a clash

 

[Worthy Man]

Very good chapter... many interesting points, but I didn't like Roger being made an idiot by Shakky, this takes away a lot of his "status" as Pirate King, we project so many absurd things onto Roger, but Oda is giving much more attention to Xebec.

 

[Dragon777]

Roger and Rocks were making island sized black lightning streaks at GV. Yeah, Roger’s not in his prime yet this chapter @EmperorKinyagi @HA001 @soupongo

This is a progress.

 

[NicoRobinIsQueen]

Who's that again?

 

[DarkWitch]

they look fine but i ain't fan of the bimbo lips

Young OG Stussy>Young Gloriosa and Young Shakky.

Too bad OG Stussy aged horribly.

 

[MonochromeYoru]

If Silver Axe didn't die in Gv, then he's the man with the burn scar and has the final road poneglyph

 

[Dragon777]

Roger vs Garp is obviously extreme diff, Roger vs Garp is also obviously Roger’s win.

Probably. As Mihawk vs Shanks, as Akainu vs Aokiji; doesn't mean they are not on par.
Roger Is 100 and Garp 99.99.

P.S.

WB is atomizing Lolden, as Roger.

 

[Kurozumi Wiwi]

Young OG Stussy>Young Gloriosa and Young Shakky.

Too bad OG Stussy aged horribly.

Newgate should have given her the D.

 

[Shiroyru]

I’m not saying he’s not on par with him lmao. I’m saying he’s not Dorry Broggy, Roger Whitebeard equal to him.

Same way Rocks is stronger than Harald, even though they clashed the same way

Or Whitebeard is stronger than Oden, ditto.

How many times did we get Luffy clashing with Kaido like this lmao?

And Kaido did the same with Big Mom, and Shanks did the same with Whitebeard.

There’s been a mass loss of critical thinking in this place where anytime two characters clash it’s seen as a sign they are absolute perfect equals, which is patent nonsense.

Roger vs Garp is obviously extreme diff, Roger vs Garp is also obviously Roger’s win.

This forum reinvents its powerscaling every time two characters have a one panel clash. There’s people out there who unironically believe Fruitless Luffy = Hybrid Kaido because they sky split

 

[Grotesque]

Who's that again?

The Obliterator of Near-Term Mothers
The Decimator of Elderly Book Readers
The Ruiner of Marine Vice-Admirals Standards.

 

[Etzel Andergast]

Young OG Stussy>Young Gloriosa and Young Shakky.

Too bad OG Stussy aged horribly.

Stussy > Miss Buckinham Stussy

 

[Monster Zoro's Tesla Supplier]

Young OG Stussy>Young Gloriosa and Young Shakky.

Too bad OG Stussy aged horribly.

Primebeard was on to something..