ONE PIECE CHAPTER: 1156: IDOLS

[vikas]

Fck me! Some Japanese Youtubers are theorizing that the treasure that the "Rocks Pirates Treasure" everyone fought over on God Valley was Shakuyaku and they make some good points but I really hope not lol
Imagine waiting all that time for God Valley and find out all of those big names fought over fcking pumpum and in Roger's case imagine, fighting over that pumpum and still losing out to Ray who wasn't even interested.

I don't know if it's just a cultural ting with regards to how Japanese people view idols but please Oda

Do it oda

 

[PuckTheGreat]

I was wondering how that would even work, but then remembered that BB was into Boa, which means there's a possibility that Oda might want to do a generational parallel lol

Probably won't happen though. Probably.

Their reasoning is that if you fit Shakky into the snippet of the conversations we got from the Rocks Pirates and also the Roger Pirates on God Valley it fits.

Roger saying that his one year wait for xxxx was a painful one
Stussy getting mad at Newgate and telling him "Not you too!?"
Glorosia's argument with Stussy
Kaido telling Linlin that said ting would be of no use to her anyways (*for me this is clearly referring to a DFs but those guys are interpreting it differently for some reason - not all japanese people feel this way btw, some folks in the comments are in line with my take)
Shiki saying he's going to claim said ting as his
Gaban telling Roger that there's no Captain privileges on "something" (i.e. think this is referring to actual fights against Rocks pirates considering we've seen Roger steal the march on Ray and Scopper when they were about to fight Oden in Oden's flashback but the Japanese youtubers seem to be tying it to Shakky)

Also one of them tied an SBS we got about Shakky recently to it, will have to watch the vid again to be sure which as I can't remember tbh.

Hope they are wrong, I really do lol

 

[The White Crane]

Insane line-up.

A little OOT, but let's be honest here, EoS SH isn't gonna win against Prime Rocks Pirates. Just outright impossible. Rocks Pirates are probably the strongest group in the story.

Post automatically merged: Aug 6, 2025

Wait, Shakky is known for her beauty and Rayleigh landed her.

Zoro also landed someone known for her beauty in Wano.

 

[Bisoromi Bear]

Wait, Shakky is known for her beauty and Rayleigh landed her.

Zoro also landed someone known for her beauty in Wano.

Rayleigh = Zoro parallel
Roger = Sanji parallel

Rayleigh > Roger

 

[Polishit]

Xebec when talking about Harald:
“With you at my side we can rule the world!”
“Put some respect on his name you stupid kid!”

Xebec when talking about Loger:
“Get outta my way you bum!!

We can now safely add Harald to Roger’s list of 158 equals or people that surpass him

xebec when talking to bitchbeard

"SHUT UP"

 

[Sir Yasheen]

Their reasoning is that if you fit Shakky into the snippet of the conversations we got from the Rocks Pirates and also the Roger Pirates on God Valley it fits.

Roger saying that his one year wait for xxxx was a painful one
Stussy getting mad at Newgate and telling him "Not you too!?"
Glorosia's argument with Stussy
Kaido telling Linlin that said ting would be of no use to her anyways (*for me this is clearly referring to a DFs but those guys are interpreting it differently for some reason - not all japanese people feel this way btw, some folks in the comments are in line with my take)
Shiki saying he's going to claim said ting as his
Gaban telling Roger that there's no Captain privileges on "something" (i.e. think this is referring to actual fights against Rocks pirates considering we've seen Roger steal the march on Ray and Scopper when they were about to fight Oden in Oden's flashback but the Japanese youtubers seem to be tying it to Shakky)

Also one of them tied an SBS we got about Shakky recently to it, will have to watch the vid again to be sure which as I can't remember tbh.

Hope they are wrong, I really do lol

Big mom was the only one fighting for the fruits in Kumas flashback wasn’t she…

 

[Kurozumi Wiwi]

If God Valley was a bunch of simps fighting, One Piece would undeniably be a gag manga first

 

[Sir Yasheen]

If God Valley was a bunch of simps fighting, One Piece would undeniably be a gag manga first

Is this not common knowledge

 

[PuckTheGreat]

What scares me the most about this Shakky ting is that it’s a very Oda ting to do
Who would think that all those titans on God Valley were fighting to clap one woman’s cheeks
Plus the whole Shakky ting last chapter felt forced as fck to me personally but would actually work as setup for this shit

 

[HA001]

So Ray is top 1 then @ZenZu

 

[Tyki_Mikk]

What scares me the most about this Shakky ting is that it’s a very Oda ting to do
Who would think that all those titans on God Valley were fighting to clap one woman’s cheeks
Plus the whole Shakky ting last chapter felt forced as fck to me personally but would actually work as setup for this shit

I hope not.
God valley sounded pretty dark and brutal to end happening because of a women. That would be the worst choice Oda did for his manga if that is the case.

 

[Sir Yasheen]

I hope not.
God valley sounded pretty dark and brutal to end happening because of a women. That would be the worst choice Oda did for his manga if that is the case.

Xebec and Shiki fighting for a woman I can see. But Whitebeard? Idk.

 

[EmperorKinyagi]

Lmao Oda casually fucking up the god valley incident after 6-7 years of build up you LOVE to see it

 

[MonochromeYoru]

Lmao Oda casually fucking up the god valley incident after 6-7 years of build up you LOVE to see it

?

oda is giving Rocks all the hype and trashing Loger. That's extremely good.

 

[ElderOnitar]

Stussy being upset at Whitebeard and saying “not you too,” is the biggest evidence for this.
@PuckTheGreat, what was the Shakky sbs?

 

[Sir Yasheen]

?

oda is giving Rocks all the hype and trashing Loger. That's extremely good.

i think he’s referring to the theory that the reason everyone was fighting was the winner gets to kidnap Shakky.

 

[Knocking Master]

The fight they had a year prior to GV was because of the Kuja pirates imo.

Rocks beat them in a davy back and took Gloriosa.

Shakky asked Roger to help get Gloriosa back but the Roger pirates failed.

One year later, Roger pirates wanted payback + finish what they started so they went to GV where they heard Rock pirates were gathering.

And then Garp follows to capture Roger, while the holy knights were already there cus of hunting competition.

So everyone there for their own reasons but the Kuja connect Roger pirates to GV.

 

[Tyki_Mikk]

Xebec and Shiki fighting for a woman I can see. But Whitebeard? Idk.

It is Oda, he maybe find it funny.
I was wondering why he suddely brought the Kuja pirates into the story but it make sense now... build to show us what caused the event: Shakky...

I would hate it, the love for Shakky feels sooo forced. At top it would make the reason why God Valley started(not because of a unique df), ridiculous... I would hate it.
It would make God Valley event a joke because of what caused all that shit.

 

[Sir Yasheen]

It is Oda, he maybe find it funny.
I was wondering why he suddely brought the Kuja pirates into the story but it make sense now... build to show us what caused the event: Shakky...

I would hate it, the love for Shakky feels sooo forced. At top it would make the reason why God Valley started(not because of a unique df), ridiculous... I would hate it.
It would make God Valley event a joke because of what caused all that shit.

Yeah it would definitely feel unnecessarily light hearted. Like the CDs having a woman slave as the ultimate prize for their hunting competition makes sense.

A single woman who we’ve known for 700 chapters being the cause for arguably one of the biggest moments in OP history and this never being alluded to until right before we see it? Feels like just bad writing

 

[MonochromeYoru]

i think he’s referring to the theory that the reason everyone was fighting was the winner gets to kidnap Shakky.

That's obviously retarded and dumb

rocks was there cause they stole his treasure which are most likely the DFs. And Roger was there specifically to fight Rocks because of their history. And the CDs were there to hunt.

None of this indicates shakky being there. Retarded zolotards propping up Shakky to be more important than she actually is. That's all it is.

And ngl, Shakky looks mid as hell in her prime. She's supposed to be rivalling Boa. But she not even above most of the random girls in op.