Notice it’s Always equal to roger or Roger’s rival and not the other way around Roger was the standard not garp Harold no matter how strong he was had no influence on the world like xbec
Shanks is by far the most glazed person in the new gen by FAR.
Oden had the pk and wsm begging for him to join them.
Two ppl who were strong not being there doesn’t invalidate the top 5 most talked about and glazed charters in this manga for 20 years.
Again ppl don’t like that their favs are irrelevant to those 5
From a story perspective it make sense to compare Garp to Roger since Roger is who had the biggest influence story wise and not the other way around .
Still that list can't even be use as most glaze character when Garp was getting glaze for decade plus in manga before we even had Oden or Rocks and still get glaze to this day in flashbacks and taking on half BB pirates with Kuzan .
Also Oden had roger begging him to join but Wb never beg him to join it was the other way around and then Oden have to prove him self to WB .
People like to use that list to power scale which to me never made sense when there fucking Imu and Joyboy and no one in manga has more influence on the world than Imu .