Role Madness One Piece Mash 2.0

[MangoSenpai]

i've saw your read lists and you've had 4 people, me included, as remaining scum

according to census there are 4 mafia members

well unless census is fake, but still, as town you wouldn't know that

What kind of backwards logic is this, Charlie?

Unless you're saying that I am indeed correct in putting you there, then there's absolutely no reason for you to say that me being town requires you to be scum. I mean this doesn't even make sense, no?

It's a reads list, I'm not a clairvoyant?

I'm honestly really confused as to why or how my reads list has any relevance to me being framed

 

[Charlie]

What kind of backwards logic is this, Charlie?

Unless you're saying that I am indeed correct in putting you there, then there's absolutely no reason for you to say that me being town requires you to be scum. I mean this doesn't even make sense, no?

It's a reads list, I'm not a clairvoyant?

I'm honestly really confused as to why or how my reads list has any relevance to me being framed

no, no, no, i mean that if your way out of getting lynched is that, it's not good enough for me (welp, in this situation idk if there's a way, but still)

 

[bittersweet]

there're another 24hs right?

I think so. I wish this had a timer like OLF. Would make it easier. Can we early lynch?

 

[Charlie]

if somehow you're town after all, really sorry, but i'm not moving

actually i'm sorry even if you're scum, it's really shitty to just wait for eod knowing you're getting lynched

 

[Charlie]

I think so. I wish this had a timer like OLF. Would make it easier. Can we early lynch?

technically but it would be nice if everyone had a chance to say sth before that

unless that already happened

 

[MangoSenpai]

according to census there are 4 mafia members

well unless census is fake, but still, as town you wouldn't know that

You know, reading this again, something about the way you've worded this doesn't really sit quite right with me.

It kind of sounds like you know something that I don't, and at the same time taking quite an accusatory tone to imply guilt.


IDK, either I'm being paranoid, or you know more than you let on..

 

[MangoSenpai]

if somehow you're town after all, really sorry, but i'm not moving

actually i'm sorry even if you're scum, it's really shitty to just wait for eod knowing you're getting lynched

I'm not asking you to move, I have no expectations to live past this DP.

But your unwillingness to explore different angles and complacency with the situation is not lost on me.

Maybe I'm looking too deep into things, but in my mind you really did incriminate yourself with that read list point that you made

 

[Flower]

Things I want to note:

I don’t like Hayumi implying one of Orca/Michelle has to be scum. It reminds me of what he did as scum in the Pokemon game to a TvT argument in order to chain miskills. I think it’s quite easy to reconcile their interactions as TvT because it seems like both sides believe what they are saying. And won’t back down.

Now the lie detect is an issue as it seems like a Town ability, but if anyone can check Hayumi, would be appreciated.

 

[Flower]

@Dr_Professor83 would be cool if you helped out a little today. It’s a bit annoying you can probably solve the game if you’re Town and don’t do much so far.

 

[MangoSenpai]

3. you're doing exactly what i've been doing in that one game where i got guilty checked as mafia

And just to adress this point; I am not you. You are not me.

I have contrary to your comparison, not actually have any guilty checks or otherwise damning mechs on me.

So not only is this a false equivalence, but you are drawing parallells where there are none.


Which is to say that the 3 points you conjured up to me boils down to
1. Circumstancial evidence
2. Irrelevant argument
3. Conjecture based on your own experience

 

[Charlie]

I'm not asking you to move, I have no expectations to live past this DP.

And just to adress this point; I am not you. You are not me.

I have contrary to your comparison, not actually have any guilty checks or otherwise damning mechs on me.

So not only is this a false equivalence, but you are drawing parallells where there are none.


Which is to say that the 3 points you conjured up to me boils down to
1. Circumstancial evidence
2. Irrelevant argument
3. Conjecture based on your own experience

What I've been doing that game was just trying to "help town while i'm still here" and "not asking anyone to move", and just kinda hoped they'll be like "idk, maybe let's lynch someone else, it's too convenient" or sth.

 

[The Orca]

it's literally 99% just for fun, you can break it whenever you want

real downside is that giving up is lame



haven't been culted in years and it hasn't changed this game either (at least for now :o ) do you want double action :o i'm going to assume someone can use it since i got it

Yeah ill take it

 

[Jaguark101]

Things I want to note:

I don’t like Hayumi implying one of Orca/Michelle has to be scum. It reminds me of what he did as scum in the Pokemon game to a TvT argument in order to chain miskills. I think it’s quite easy to reconcile their interactions as TvT because it seems like both sides believe what they are saying. And won’t back down.

Now the lie detect is an issue as it seems like a Town ability, but if anyone can check Hayumi, would be appreciated.

I mean, I got a an ability that can confirm if someone is town or not, but its a double edged sword kind of ability

 

[Flower]

I mean, I got a an ability that can confirm if someone is town or not, but its a double edged sword kind of ability

How does it work?

 

[Charlie]

I mean, I got a an ability that can confirm if someone is town or not, but its a double edged sword kind of ability

you mean vig shot?

 

[Jaguark101]

How does it work?

I have to actually post the ability in the game thread it self in front of everyone so I can use it anytime even during the day. Essentially I tell Fuji that I want to shoot someone and if they are non town then they die, but if they are town then I will die instead. Hence it being quite risky

 

[Jaguark101]

Its a good way to clear or confirm someone at the risk of the user

 

[Flower]

I have to actually post the ability in the game thread it self in front of everyone so I can use it anytime even during the day. Essentially I tell Fuji that I want to shoot someone and if they are non town then they die, but if they are town then I will die instead. Hence it being quite risky

Uh, probably use that on Ekko tbh.

 

[Hayumi]

Things I want to note:

I don’t like Hayumi implying one of Orca/Michelle has to be scum. It reminds me of what he did as scum in the Pokemon game to a TvT argument in order to chain miskills. I think it’s quite easy to reconcile their interactions as TvT because it seems like both sides believe what they are saying. And won’t back down.

Now the lie detect is an issue as it seems like a Town ability, but if anyone can check Hayumi, would be appreciated.

I mean I said I could be wrong if I’m mis town reading someone outside of the POE list I mentioned.

It’s solely based on the POE narrowing and their interactions implying there’s no way they are aligned. You know I solve by forming a town list and going off that for my scum reads every time so that shouldn’t be weird to you.

A bit late if this is some mislynch chain attempt as I hardly get listened to much here lmao. Agree to disagree about both appearing townie.

 

[Charlie]

I have to actually post the ability in the game thread it self in front of everyone so I can use it anytime even during the day. Essentially I tell Fuji that I want to shoot someone and if they are non town then they die, but if they are town then I will die instead. Hence it being quite risky

culted town counts as non town, right? so it's like, almost 50/50 even if you picked blind at this point

Uh, probably use that on Ekko tbh.

or mango