You've done really well to describe the downfall. I agree with nearly everything you said here. We were fooled by sendoff tax.
Truly was Goda in Marineford.
And again, aside from the Shakky simping, I really don't see a downfall.
If anything, looking at the correct order of events, it's a massive upscale and glow up.
From a strong first mate, to becoming a pirate captain with a partner type RHM like Rayleigh and becoming equal of his captain's rival, to the defacto PK and king of the seas of the great pirate era, to Marineford war, to ushering in a new era in his dying breath.
A journey that truly defines greatness and legends. No D, no special bullshit species.
GOATbeard
