Super Role Madness Yu-Gi-Oh Mafia Beyond Time

Michelle

Michelle

‎
#2,426
#2,426
Ratchet said:
@Michelle Let me hold up a mirror to your reasoning.

You're claiming that I'm too involved for an indie. But there would be no value in me as scum, fake claiming indie, if I'm not going to cash that in by playing into being an indie. It gives me ample room to not scum hunt, so you never get to catch me pushing the wrong directions nor pushing you towards my scum mates. I don't have to live up to any standards you may have of my general game so that's out too. And I would join the mass of players who offer little to be readable - a fact you already accept by your complaints of the gamestate. So you'd have nothing to read me from and would have no choice but to accept my claim.

Instead, I'm offering positions. So you're going to give some reason as to why, as scum, I bother fake claiming only to not try and reap any of the benefits that fake claiming would give me, and this, after my claim gets accepted.

You can't do it. And your refusal to concede any ground is what looks bad to me, because as town you should be open to new information. Instead you're picking a direction and sticking to it and you can't defend your position. Feel free to take this as a prompt to do so. I doubt you will.
Click to expand...
If you are indie you don't need to act like that to convince me
The simple fact you are arguing puts you in scum category.
 
Ratchet

Ratchet

The End and the Beginning
‎
#2,438
#2,438
Michelle said:
If you are indie you don't need to act like that to convince me
The simple fact you are arguing puts you in scum category.
Click to expand...
Well flesh this thought out. Why does me arguing make me scum? Should I just accept bad faith BS because I'm indie? Is that your position Michelle? Or is it that you can't defend anything you say, you sinply don't have the arsenal to do so, so you're left with sticking into your position and deflecting? Because that's what it reads like. Let me be frank for a moment Michelle - I have respect for your town game. This isn't up to scratch. So if this is your offering as town, it's below par to me.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top