Questions & Mysteries Kaido not inluding Garp and others makes sense

[Tai long]

kaido not including garp in his top 5 makes sense since he never saw garp fighting.

1. roger- he is roger, and he rivaled his captain
2. rocks- he is rocks
3. wb- was in the same crew and probably did/showed why he deserved to be there
4. shanks- probably showed something on his way to Marineford
5. oden- scared him, and it was his arc (he had to be included)

Not included
1. saturnmu- probably did not see him after getting knocked out, so didn't know how strong it was since they easily destroyed it with thier attacks
2. bigmom- after getting his fruit, he must have thought he was stronger
3. garp- did not see him fight (since he was knocked out).
4. harald- didn't know him properly and probably never saw him fight (he wasn't in part of the group that went to elbaf). he also was defeated easily on their way to gv
5. Mihawk- never met him (might be a weakling like doffy for all he knows)
6. admiral- never met them (might be weaklings like vice admirals)

 

[Bad English]

 

[Sir Yasheen]

Roger sees Saturnmu easily take down his captain.

Kaidos top 5 is not a power scaling metric it’s just people Kaido respect. Stop trying to force it as anything else

 

[Cruxroux]

Have said this before, kaidou top 5, is just a handful of people, people connected to those are already their superior or equal.

• Roger
  • Garp, Was called his equal.
• Xebec
  • Includes Harald as his on par character.
• Whitebeard
  • Includes types of Roger only.
• Oden
  • Fought him directly, and has legends with both Roger and Whitebeard.
• Shanks
  • Mihawk is called outright superior.

Out of these names,
Roger~Garp, Xebec~Harald, Whitebeard, Oden, Shanks~Mihawk.

None has the chance of being stronger than him.

 

[Yo Tan Wa]

It doesnt but it is perfect manga to you guys, so eventually you'll find ways to cope with everything.​

 

[SkySanji]

Garp is weaker than those five.

 

[Tai long]

Have said this before, kaidou top 5, is just a handful of people, people connected to those are already their superior or equal.

• Roger
  • Garp, Was called his equal.
• Xebec
  • Includes Harald as his on par character.
• Whitebeard
  • Includes types of Roger only.
• Oden
  • Fought him directly, and has legends with both Roger and Whitebeard.
• Shanks
  • Mihawk is called outright superior.

Out of these names,
Roger~Garp, Xebec~Harald, Whitebeard, Oden, Shanks~Mihawk.

None has the chance of being stronger than him.

and why would kaido include mihawk or harald

Post automatically merged: Wednesday at 3:58 PM

Roger sees Saturnmu easily take down his captain.

Kaidos top 5 is not a power scaling metric it’s just people Kaido respect. Stop trying to force it as anything else

respect because they are strong. that is kaidos character if you are not as strong as he is he does not respect you. why would he respect rogers or shanks when he doesn't know them

 

[Cruxroux]

and why would kaido include mihawk or harald

Oda hyped those who he intended to.
Not those who he has plans for future.

- Garp showcased in hachinosu.
- Harald made appearance in Flashback.
- Mihawk is yet to do anything.

Rocks was hype, rest all of them were well established in manga Power wise.

 

[Elder Lee Hung]

1. saturnmu- probably did not see him after getting knocked out, so didn't know how strong it was since they easily destroyed it with thier attacks

3. garp- did not see him fight (since he was knocked out).

2. bigmom- after getting his fruit, he must have thought he was stronger

I mean she fought him to a stalemate 24 hours before without access to 2 of her 3 homies lmfao

 

[Tai long]

It doesnt but it is perfect manga to you guys, so eventually you'll find ways to cope with everything.​

explain why any other top tier not included should be in the first place

 

[Sir Yasheen]

and why would kaido include mihawk or harald

Post automatically merged: Wednesday at 3:58 PM

respect because they are strong. that is kaidos character if you are not as strong as he is he does not respect you. why would he respect rogers or shanks when he doesn't know them

Kaido literally respects Jack… he will respect people weaker than him. These are just individuals who he fought that has personally earned his respect as rivals.

It’s not some “These Five People are the strongest in the world” panel

 

[Tai long]

Oda hyped those who he intended to.
Not those who he has plans for future.

- Garp showcased in hachinosu.
- Harald made appearance in Flashback.
- Mihawk is yet to do anything.

Rocks was hype, rest all of them were well established in manga Power wise.

why would he include harald or mihawk. when he doesn't know them or how strong they are

 

[Cruxroux]

why would he include harald or mihawk. when he doesn't know them or how strong they are

That's why oda gave us top 5 dude.

We can relate other characters to those 5.

 

[MonsterKaido]

The logic is he was thinking of strongest of pirates he has faced.

 

[kekaro]

Some people should just read MHA op is too complex for them

 

[Shanal]

It's 2025. People need to stop implying those 5 are top 5. They were never even implied to be so. Just really strong people who had big impact on Kaido.

Implying Oden > Prime Garp is insane

 

[Cruxroux]

Some people here calls Roger Fraud.

 

[kekaro]

*call

 

[Cruxroux]

 

[kekaro]

You can quote me little mindbroken bro, as opposed to you, as the whole forums knows, i can read english.
I called Dodger a fraud longer than you probally are allowed to legally smoke as you are underage