Spoiler One Piece Chapter 1165 Spoilers Discussion

[comrade]

Xebec being the predominant force in the sky split isn't far fetched. It happened the moment he Shinra Tensei'd them away in an outburst of Haki.

Yet Roger and Garp won, yes, because they poured their everything into their moves.

 

[Bad English]

Xebec is simply weaker than the Yonkos.

 

[Phoenix D. King]

Rogers haki comes from his inherited sword, just like enma with Zolo

 

[Wh1p]

Maybe Roger was the skills man all along

He used his skills to fight against Xebecs haki

 

[Ice devil slayer]

The crash caused the skysplit.

Xebec is simply weaker than the Yonkos.

Yet he toyed with Roger

 

[HA001]

Brago already gone from shanks > mihawk to mihawk beats shanks but people should believe what they want.
Morj about to concede too.
The victory lap is insane

 

[ZenZu]

When you have people saying 1026 Pre G5 Luffy > 40 year old ACoC veterans Roger and Garp. When you have people saying Harald is weaker than 1026 Luffy cause he didn't split the sky. When discussions are centered around who got more ink blots on page, and whose ink blots led to which outcome...instead of discussing the actual content....you know you failed as a mangaka.

 

[Phoenix D. King]

Brago already gone from shanks > mihawk to mihawk beats shanks but people should believe what they want.
Morj about to concede too.
The victory lap is insane

One by one they will admit it

not a hill worth dying on anymore, there is nothing to gain in a losing fight. It will only be worse if you do not admit to being wrong.

 

[Shimotsuki Fenaker]

@Blazing Lion @nik87 @L57 @HA001 @Cruxroux @CbShadow @comrade @HeroesNZ @Sentinel @Tyki_Mikk @Kurozumi Wiwi @mly90 @grey matter @ShishioIsBack @Lor D. Coast @ZenZu

Don't fucking tell me that Dr'ed Xebec is forging a black blade on the process :

 

[pg13]

From what I can tell Garp is punching Xebec in the Face, Roger is clashing Blades with Xebec, then it seems they are Blown away by Xebec and the Sky Splits in the Process. There’s lines on Xebecs Sword indicating a swing. And you can tell they were blown away because they were close to Xebec in one panel and then blown away in the next. What is the controversy here?

 

[sanjikun]

First it started out with, DR Xebec actually gets 0 boost from his base. He just becomes 10x bigger and gets demon wings. 0 boost in strength.

Now, it's oh, you see that clash between Xebec and Roger/Garp that caused a skysplit? It's actually just Xebec, even though Garp/Roger literally defeat in the next page.

Never seen this level of cope lol. It's crazy.

 

[RyoQ]

@Blazing Lion @nik87 @L57 @HA001 @Cruxroux @CbShadow @comrade @HeroesNZ @Sentinel @Tyki_Mikk @Kurozumi Wiwi @mly90 @grey matter @ShishioIsBack @Lor D. Coast @ZenZu

Don't fucking tell me that Dr'ed Xebec is forging a black blade on the process :

No, it's just a blue moon and Oda just remembered how to draw coa hardening

 

[ShishioIsBack]

@Blazing Lion @nik87 @L57 @HA001 @Cruxroux @CbShadow @comrade @HeroesNZ @Sentinel @Tyki_Mikk @Kurozumi Wiwi @mly90 @grey matter @ShishioIsBack @Lor D. Coast @ZenZu

Don't fucking tell me that Dr'ed Xebec is forging a black blade on the process :

Seems like regular Haki coating

Post automatically merged: Nov 6, 2025

First it started out with, DR Xebec actually gets 0 boost from his base. He just becomes 10x bigger and gets demon wings. 0 boost in strength.

Now, it's oh, you see that clash between Xebec and Roger/Garp that caused a skysplit? It's actually just Xebec, even though Garp/Roger literally defeat in the next page.

Never seen this level of cope lol. It's crazy.

Xebec low diffs either individually anyways

 

[Phoenix D. King]

When you have people saying 1026 Pre G5 Luffy > 40 year old ACoC veterans Roger and Garp. When you have people saying Harald is weaker than 1026 Luffy cause he didn't split the sky. When discussions are centered around who got more ink blots on page, and whose ink blots led to which outcome...instead of discussing the actual content....you know you failed as a mangaka.

Not Odas fault his fanbase has an average IQ of 86. The smart fans dont waste their time, panels have literally never meant anything. Next chapter, Oda could say that haki means nothing, and it will.

 

[TheAncientCenturion]

When you have people saying 1026 Pre G5 Luffy > 40 year old ACoC veterans Roger and Garp. When you have people saying Harald is weaker than 1026 Luffy cause he didn't split the sky. When discussions are centered around who got more ink blots on page, and whose ink blots led to which outcome...instead of discussing the actual content....you know you failed as a mangaka.

Just ignore Sanjikun and the haki scalers. Oda's never gonna elaborate on any of this shit and there's no point in arguing headcanon

 

[Definitivo]

Luffy 1026 >> Xebec

COPE

 

[Shiroyru]

Looking at the raws it seems that Xebec solo sky split by pushing them off of him

It took getting Domi Reversi’d for Xebec to pull off a JB/Shanks level Haki feat

 

[Ice devil slayer]

Luffy 1026 >> Xebec

COPE

 

[kekaro]

Luffy 1026 >> Xebec

COPE

Prime shit right here

 

[Welkin]

Oldbeard > Rocks according to people with Haki PHD’s