Theory Polo Graham as the burn scar man

[Monkey D Theories]

Wanted to talk about the possibility that Graham is the burn scar man.

Graham seems to be WB’s original right hand man. He is evidently very strong, fighting Silver Axe, who is Shiki’s rival.

The oddest part of this character is his complete absence from the Oden flashback. Why introduce him in GV but have him absent in the Oden flashback? I think there is a decent chance Graham has a role in the story Oda is yet to explore.

The old legends have been routinely featured throughout the manga as guides and allies to the SHs. Crocus, Rayleigh, Gaban… Graham could easily fit this mold.

 

[Zoinks52]

Well it could be a hasty unplanned addition by Oda purely to set up WB's future crew.

But I could also see how the father of a phoenix could work as the man with the burn scar.

 

[moreha9685]

No.

Also, jeez, are you quick with these bullshit threads.

 

[SkySanji]

Every new character is burn scar

Much more likely, Pinmarco died at some point and Whitebeard adopted his son

 

[sanjikun]

I think Marco like Teach and Ace was left an orphan, and WB took them in.

Same deal with Hanafuda and Page 1/Ulti.

 

[Monkey D Theories]

Every new character is burn scar

eventually one of them will be

WB’s old rhm is a decent candidate

 

[barai]

Very doubtful, but not completely impossible.
The last missing Road poneglyph was on Fish Man island which was Whitebeard's territory. On WB's orders, he might've split from the crew to hide it elsewhere and protect it from anyone getting close. But the timeline doesn't match up. It was still there for Roger to be found. Making Graham absent from the crew at this point for "no reason". For it to go missing after means that Teach was with the crew by this time, yet he has no idea where it is. WB could've kept it secret which feels like a stretch, but then again he never revealed the Ace Roger connection to Squard.

The question remains that if Graham is still alive surely avenging Whitebeard's death would be top priority over everything else.

 

[Yoho]

Every new character is burn scar

Much more likely, Pinmarco died at some point and Whitebeard adopted his son

Whitebeard murdered Polo and kidnapped his son

 

[GrandmasterChef Zonji]

Imo
Polo Graham is Marco but after Phoenix "rebirth" Cycle.
WB knew about this after Polo saying this thing before he "died", and after he "Died" He became Polo Marco, and didn't had any memories of his past self.
Hence why, WB became his "Father"

 

[Yoho]

Imo
Polo Graham is Marco but after Phoenix "rebirth" Cycle.
WB knew about this after Polo saying this thing before he "died", and after he "Died" He became Polo Marco, and didn't had any memories of his past self.
Hence why, WB became his "Father"

His awakening is him remembering all his past lives stretching all the way back to the void century

 

[Mr. Reloaded]

The man with the burn scar is a different person every week