Role Madness Elden Ring

@Jan

Any initial gut reads?
I liked flowers read on robin hood avatar.
I had a similar reaction, but my thought was more in line of "keep a lookout if the guy follows up on the ideas part of that post".

Flower has given some townreads that I didn't see. Could be meta, but made me scratch my head.

Orcas reaction to being pushed was good. No fear and a healthy confrontation.
No omgus, but the more you read me, the more I can read you.
Could simply be his playstyle, but if it is, you guys will likely yell at me for being stupid.

I initially thought Indigo was slightly scummy because his response to indie roles in the game had more annoyance than anyone else.
Looking back to his reaction (to my silly puppet question), it makes sense and is likely nai.
 
Ratchet - hasn't played anything like town ratchet, probably asleep so not a super hard read right now
Alwaysmind - made an asinine statement about him missing a post on the first page bc he's on his phone, total lie, strongest gut read
bittersweet - hasn't been able to explain reads or thoughts adequately

Flower - hasn't peacocked town yet

Hayumi - town hayumi would have already been here and maybe even pushing flower
RippedCal - similar to hayumi

Charlie - id expect more by now (some lee way for the rest of d1)

Lord Melkor - same
KWEH - same


Naomi - indy claim, I believe it

Yoho

Peroroncino
Jaguark101
Indigo
Random Asshole
baudib1
Yoshi
MonochromeYoru
Yo Tan Wa
Worst
ConquistadoR
Marimo_420


The Orca - too care free, pushing, and the Bobbie Ann Mason post

Jan - only one of the new guys to respond to my post, felt he would not respond the way he did about his game if he were scum (not a hard read as their play later becomes more telling apparently)
 
bittersweet - hasn't been able to explain reads or thoughts adequately
Okay. How am I supposed to explain my reads when it's a general vibe right now and your brother has...let me check 12 posts to evaluate. He's already playing more active than his scum game, which leans good in his favor.

Ratchet is probably asleep and is still recovering from being ill so I'm mostly voting as a placeholder until tomorrow when the rest of the game participates.
 
Top