Role Madness Elden Ring

[Yoho]

🤔🤔🤔

 

[baudib1]

This post is interesting, and I would like @Flower (and anyone else who has input) to comment on it.
As context, this was post #283 and ~9 hours into d1.

At that time, several other people were still pushing orca and polar to some extent, and both of them got kind of meta cleared here.
Is melkor better than the rest, or is there slight tmi (knowing someone is town can result in giving town reads easier etc)?

I know I had both of them as townie at the time, but Flowers push and her saying that orca did not do his town tell yet happened after (this was shortly after orca posted his first reads list)

one of the towniest posts I've seen from Jan in a while

 

[The Orca]

This post is interesting, and I would like @Flower (and anyone else who has input) to comment on it.
As context, this was post #283 and ~9 hours into d1.

At that time, several other people were still pushing orca and polar to some extent, and both of them got kind of meta cleared here.
Is melkor better than the rest, or is there slight tmi (knowing someone is town can result in giving town reads easier etc)?

I know I had both of them as townie at the time, but Flowers push and her saying that orca did not do his town tell yet happened after (this was shortly after orca posted his first reads list)

In this instance, Melkor better than the rest. But in reality it is others being more brain dead for whatever reason you want to attach to it imo. I don't have tells though, so you should ignore Flower, its a dumb or scum angle from her imo

 

[Alwaysmind]

Flower is probably my top town read, wouldn't consider unless both Yoho/Cal flip town. I voted Kweh at some point off a shallow tone read and haven't seen much since then.

Flower does have a town aroma, I must agree.

 

[Lord Melkor]

RippedCal - 5
Hayumi - 2
Baudib - 2
Orca - 1
Ratchet - 1
Yoshi - 1
Charlie - 1
Flower - 1

AM: RippedCal
Yoshi: Ora
PB: Hayumi
Bittersweet: Ratchet
KWEH: Yoshi
LM: Baudib > Hayumi
Flower: Ratchet > Hayumi > RippedCal
Ratchet: Yoho > unvote > RippedCal
Baudib: PB > KWEH > RippedCal
RippedCal: Flower > Baudib
TheOrca: Baudib
Worst: Charlie
Alexis: Flower​

I need to read the last 20 pages, this is the most current vote count right?

 

[Lord Melkor]

I looked through melkor posts again and some of them are good because his townreads are similar to mine.

But the flower sheep post was so fucking bad.
His questions never went anywhere (asked people about reads, but I don't see any follow-up).

I am honestly surprised this guy is a go to lynch over here (someone said that earlier - flower, me thinks), because as much as I dislike parts of his messages, there is at least some sort of content in them. (Which is a low baseline but better than some others).

I decided Flower is town and to help her with push on Hayumi who did give me townie vibes so far. I see it did not go anywhere based on laters vote count.

And i do not know why i am often lynched here, perhaps my past as Dark Lord is controversial, even though i am reformed?

I need to check up to see about followups.

 

[Lord Melkor]

So this is a sheep, or you have more points you can articulate for a solid read on me yourself?

Mostly a sheep unfortunately.

 

[Jan]

I decided Flower is town and to help her with push on Hayumi who did give me townie vibes so far. I see it did not go anywhere based on laters vote count.

And i do not know why i am often lynched here, perhaps my past as Dark Lord is controversial, even though i am reformed?

I need to check up to see about followups.

Okay, I now understand why you die.

 

[baudib1]

Okay, I now understand why you die.

he's literally melkor

 

[Lord Melkor]

looks like not much has happened since i left

Do i remember correctly you wanted to go after Charlie? I think Charlie's Indie claim is mostly true do i wonder if you have other directions.

 

[Lord Melkor]

Place a vote on Cal please. Thank you.

Did he claim already?

Vote Lynch RippedCal

 

[Flower]

Morning.

 

[Flower]

I‘m probably never voting outside Cal or Yoho today. I feel like if he genuinely thought Ratchet was scum he would contribute much more and not roll over like that and just be like look at Ratchet when I flip .

That just feels weak.

 

[The Orca]

Did he claim already?

Vote Lynch RippedCal

Not that I remember. Should be a fun claim

 

[Polar Bear]

Rough vc, its almost 5 am and I'm headed to bed so it may not be axaxt but should be close

 

[Lord Melkor]

I'm not sure that he is, at least not yet. If I had to make a case specifically it would probably come down to the confidence in his posts

The bigger issue I have is with you at the moment. It seems your mindset isn't in a town space and you have a direct conflict in your posts and what should be a town mindset if you were town.




What gets me, is your main push here is off of an exchange that doesn't quite fit what you are framing it as and then on top of that it is a very complex thought process that you are assuming signifies Cal as scum. It takes lots of assumptions at many levels to get there that the specific reason which is very unlikely to be accurate, but that is what you are pushing...while supposedly being town. Doesn't make sense. Very scummy

This just feels like it is something you can push to appear busy over actually feeling it is likely and caught scum
What lol
This might be the worst post of the bunch. Flower is a DV at a mimum right, she as town would know she isn't long for this game. No scum would leave her alive with extra vote power and claimed more moves, but her mindset in reality here was to coast, but now she has to work. Scum slip possibly cause this and added to her thought on Cal it does not have a town mentality behind it
Then a flip to well even if they are not scum must policy them still

Overall, Flower's play, thoughts, and mindset is just not up to par here for a town Flower

I do not think that scum Flower would say that she needs to pelt you like this. I think she is usually more self concious as scum

 

[The Orca]

Rough vc, its almost 5 am and I'm headed to bed so it may not be axaxt but should be close

Lots of people not voting

Curious what happens with this Vote Lynch Flower

 

[Polar Bear]

Morning.

Good night

 

[Jaguark101]

Well, you might be the 1st person to wake this morning!

Do you have any thoughts about the game so far that are not flavour-related?
(I heard you mostly joined for that, but I would love something more to get a read on you)

Not got much thoughts on it yet, I personally think yoho is fine, poor guys seems to be targeted day one on alot of games from what I recall lol.

 

[Polar Bear]

Lots of people not voting

Curious what happens with this Vote Lynch Flower

Why the vote?