Role Madness Elden Ring

[Peroroncino]

or like at all

 

[Lord Melkor]

technically Melkor isn't in LotR

He is the rightful Lord of Arda though, creator of orcs and dragons. Sharon was just his servant.

 

[Flower]

or like at all

Yeah, in Fate. It’s doable, but it’s a chore.

 

[Lord Melkor]

He is the rightful Lord of Arda though, creator of orcs and dragons. Sharon was just his servant.

"Sauron"

 

[Jaguark101]

You have any thoughts besides flavour solving? Fuji usually designs his games so that they are not easily solved this way?

Not got anything yet. I know that's not really helpful.

 

[Flower]

Annoying part is literally nobody who is in the consensus PoE is giving us much to work with.

 

[Worst]

Kind of obvious reads. Why Ratchet?

His overall posts are good and he seems more willing to listen and follow others opinions I feel like if he was scum he would've been more proactive in trying to lead the wagons

 

[Worst]

I still think @Ratchet is sus

from a quick look at his posts, his only scum read had been Yoho and Cal. and he reversed on yoho fairly easily, but still felt the need to say he's not completely flipping his opinion on yoho and is just trusting worst. seems like some early bussing and then distancing while still leaving behind an excuse.

@Yoho has done nothing either. most of his posts are just bickering with flower. i don't think he has given a single read so far. i don't mind voting for him either.

@Alexis2282AE came in guns blazing accusing flower for a "slip".
he has polar as scum because polar did not react to this supposed slip, but then also has me as scum i assume because i did react to it?
that doesn't track at all. i asked him why he put me as scum and didn't get a reply.
He also gave Ratchet town nod for whatever reason.


I feel like those 3 are connected in the background and nobody else is seeing it.

@RippedCal i don't know if he and flower are bickering because flower being flower or cal being scum. but he did mention something about being mates with Noami. that would make him a 3rd indie. do games of this size have that many indies?

@Worst went for charlie out of the blue and seems sure of that. i would like him to explain why. charlie claimed indie and somewhat hostile pretty early. i do agree that we should keep an eye on him, but going for an indie d1 seems like what scum would try to do for cred.

@Polar Bear seems a bit townish cause he been asking some questions and lots of fluff. super carefree. i did want to ask him what he thought of Melkor of his town core sheeping flower his top scum read tho. But he seems to have cooled off on flower.

@Flower claiming early, lots of posts and bickering with lots of people, is what i remember from the few games i played and she was town.



Null on the others so far

I think I said why, I just don't like how he is gravitating around his claim what I'm saying is that I don't truly believe he's indie but a fully fledged mafia members also he seem to have been keeping distance from everyone showing that his claim is likely weak

 

[bittersweet]

I would say give Ratchet the benefit of the doubt, he's been doing more solving than Yoho at least so I would give him a pass till D2, see what happens then. Get rid of the chaff preventing town from solving the scum.

Still null on Ratchet though, so I'm not clearing him. Just feel people might think I'm 'traumatized' from our last game.

 

[Flower]

I would say give Ratchet the benefit of the doubt, he's been doing more solving than Yoho at least so I would give him a pass till D2, see what happens then. Get rid of the chaff preventing town from solving the scum.

Still null on Ratchet though, so I'm not clearing him. Just feel people might think I'm 'traumatized' from our last game.

He‘s not doing much honestly.

 

[Flower]

He said he‘s sick, so I‘m not holding it that much against him, but when he‘s around I hope he gets to do…more if he’s Town.

 

[Flower]

Since people barely bother playing I‘m off to enjoy my afternoon tbh.

 

[Lord Melkor]

I think AM should be added to the POE then, interesting that he is being omitted as was briefly mentioned by some

 

[Charlie]

not really it's just my read i feel like looking at his posts he's playing like someone you should have 0 thread expectations from ( hmm i've heard that before somewhere ) which are usually scums, meanwhile from a town / town aligned you'd expect that they are trying to game solve or something so yeah it's just a read nothing mech ( for now )

I mean i'm not town though. My wincon has nothing to do with any other role or faction.

 

[Charlie]

Worst lied about being a rabbi

 

[bittersweet]

Since people barely bother playing I‘m off to enjoy my afternoon tbh.

It's morning on a Sunday, I imagine people in the states are sleeping in or are having breakfast or going to church. They'll probably be on more this afternoon. We do need to decide on a lynch before our time runs out here in a few hours.

 

[Charlie]

you ever seen ratchet lynched D1 here?

Pretty sure we've had Ratchet lynched D1 on first game we've played together on nf. I mean scum for Town Ratchet mislynched. I remember thinking it's someone new to mafia simply because ive never seen him before. How that happened, no idea o:

 

[Hayumi]

Based on Sigi’s somewhat defensive responses to Jan I’d tend to lean slight town. Already a bit effort compared to what I’d expect from him as scum early.

 

[Hayumi]

Other than putting me as scum not a bad list.

You did not list AM though despite asking someone else for a read on him? (I think i quoted that post)?

AM still kind of just null, GTH maybe scum tho. I didn’t mind his earlier postings but hasn’t done anything since

 

[Hayumi]

Vote Lynch Kweh