Role Madness Elden Ring
- Thread starter Fujishiro
- Start date
VC2 D2
New
VC2 D2
Charlie - 5
Saber - 4
RippedCal - 2
Baudib - 2
York - 2
Worst: Charlie
Bittersweet: Yoho > Saber
Flower: Yo Tan Wa> Charlie > RippedCal > Saber
RippedCal: Charlie
Stargate: Charlie
Peroroncino: Charlie
Saber: Charlie
AM: Jaguark > RippedCal
Ratchet: Saber
Lord Melkor: RippedCal
Orca: Baudib
Polar Bear: York
Charlie: Baudib
Baudib: York
Ratchet - from my experience, he's way more active as town and tries to lead. he hasn't so far. Also he voted Yoho super early, but unvoted after worst said to trust his read. He was convinced too easily and too fast imo.
Charlie for obvious reasons
Bitter - He said he targeted Cal with a prevent tampering. From my understanding, that means he suspected/thought someone could tamper with Cal. But he never town read or scum read Cal at all. Cal was in the middle unconfirmed pile in both of his lists. Why would he use that on Cal?
Cal - Should have claimed that stuff on him would have 50% chance of being redirected. It would have served to prevent town wasting stuff on him, and discouraging mafia or sk from using stuff on him on account of it missing.
Melkor - Is claiming Vig this early a good idea? And shooting a supposed indie who's claim melkor said he believed?
Jag - Said he got scarlet rot. i did too. it's basically really strong poison. Can roles poison two people at the same time? i played sk with poison ability in a game previously and could not use it twice in one night.
Kweh/york - Jag invested them. And he supposedly got scarlet rot and 2 stacks of it to boot. I only got 1 stack. If his claim is indeed true, and poison role cannot usually poison multiple people, then he got the rot from visiting Kweh/york. which would make sense if they are malenia.
These are my scum reads/sus list so far
Charlie for obvious reasons
Bitter - He said he targeted Cal with a prevent tampering. From my understanding, that means he suspected/thought someone could tamper with Cal. But he never town read or scum read Cal at all. Cal was in the middle unconfirmed pile in both of his lists. Why would he use that on Cal?
Cal - Should have claimed that stuff on him would have 50% chance of being redirected. It would have served to prevent town wasting stuff on him, and discouraging mafia or sk from using stuff on him on account of it missing.
Melkor - Is claiming Vig this early a good idea? And shooting a supposed indie who's claim melkor said he believed?
Jag - Said he got scarlet rot. i did too. it's basically really strong poison. Can roles poison two people at the same time? i played sk with poison ability in a game previously and could not use it twice in one night.
Kweh/york - Jag invested them. And he supposedly got scarlet rot and 2 stacks of it to boot. I only got 1 stack. If his claim is indeed true, and poison role cannot usually poison multiple people, then he got the rot from visiting Kweh/york. which would make sense if they are malenia.
These are my scum reads/sus list so far
