Role Madness Elden Ring

Jan rose all the way to prime suspect pool. Hes vitually become a nothing player like he said he would if scum (my take if his post)

Baudib1 has done nothing to solve but regurgitate others reads

Ratchet sounds like a whiny baby frustrated that can't take the pressure (no offense, just how those posts read). This is out of his town play style

York has done nothing at all since subbing in and kweh was a scum lean before the sub

____

Alwaymind is alwaysmind
Same with indigo/RN
Jags done nothing except claim a scum move, would be town if York is scum and vice versa

____

Pero, RA, Saber, and Worst have done nothing substantial

_____

Yo Tan, RippedCal and Mono have had some decent posts and not so good ones, but for them I think a slight town lean
___

Orca leaning towards his scum game here lately but has taken a few hard stances and had yoho as town when most everyone was the opposite and had sound logic behind. It wasn't just hey yoho is town

Stargate is gonna be confirmed or outed here with Charlie's flip

Melkor has been in his town range and claimed vig, although terrible usage

Flower, just like ratchet, played like crap lately. Start solving or its back to the suspect pool. Start working together to solve, you aren't good enough to win it without everyone working together
 
@The Orca

You think baudib1 is scum even through their semi claim of heeler and some type of protection role
I think so based on play. Doesnt match what was billed and certainly not thread wise. Seems like they are avoiding taking stances, pushing reads, making reads, discussing, etc. Healer can be anything and I'd say I've seen it maybe slightly more as scum from Fuji, but I'd say NAI. Also, tbe protection claim part seemed performative and vague...totally suspect. Let the grave digger and backup fight for their role if wrong I guess. RippedCal seems way more involved this game and has similar reads as me, so I'd like to push this one across the finish line. I think we are onto something here.. plus Baudib seems to have vanished this phase...I think it is a hit
 
I have 156 posts, I wish I was lazy. Look I've had about enough, every time I check this game I feel closer and closer to wanting to shoot myself in the head with what I'm reading and half the game came into this one desperate for me to be scum so just help them get my flip, then I don't need to bother with this any more and they can all fall over themselves or whatever it is they want to do.

@Flower you think scum Ratchet lowers himself to such ATE? I think he is too proud to act like this as scum
 
Peroroncino - Probably Town
Polar Bear - Probably Town
Ratchet - Town
Jaguark101 - Town
bittersweet - Town
Indigo - Probably Town
Flower - Town
RippedCal - Could be scum
Naomi - Indie
Random Asshole - No idea
Charlie - Indie
York - Could be scum
baudib1 - Could be scum, not with Ripped Cal
The Orca - Probably Town, not as strong as Polar
Lord Melkor - Probably Town
MonochromeYoru - Probably Town
Alwaysmind - Null
Yo Tan Wa - Town
Worst - Probably Town
Jan - Slight Town
Stargate - Probably Town
Saber - Could be scum

PoE is Cal, RA, York, baudib (not if Cal is scum), AM (slight town on the slot but trended off), Saber.

If there are scum outside of that I would start with Orca probably as I don't have a very good reason for him to be town.

Cal can easily be scum. York I sort of want to say is more townie than scummy but not many names left over. Saber I think has townie points to him as well but I don't know how much credit to give him when his play outside of it is a dead ringer for his scum game.

@bittersweet take it for whatever it's worth
So basically we should Lynch either Baudib or Cal today? I think i agree, you and Flower should be both town unless you are using ATE tactics
 
As I said

Worst
Polar
Bitter
Jan

I think are townie.

Outside of that it’s a whole lot of null, I always try and find town first.

im not giving a firm read on you nor Ratchet yet till I see more then day 1.

for now people I wouldn’t mind yeeting;


Jag
Tweet
Yohoe
Melkor

Alexis but because of policy more then anything else
I think Hayumi was highly questionable of Flower and AM as well. Worth looking back on after more flips
 
Top