Role Madness Elden Ring

[Jan]

If Baudib is Town nuke Cal and Saber.

Do you think Baudib is not town?

 

[Jan]

Vote Lynch RippedCal

Vote Duel Red Night

 

[Random Asshole]

Morning, what did I miss?

 

[Ratchet]

Morning, what did I miss?

Oh only 95% of the game, the usual.

 

[Flower]

Do you think Baudib is not town?

I think he is, but he’s lead wagon right now. There’s mad resistance to Cal, too.

 

[Flower]

Morning, what did I miss?

Nuke this, too.

 

[The Orca]

Vote Lynch RippedCal

Vote Duel Red Night

Why though?

 

[The Orca]

I think he is, but he’s lead wagon right now. There’s mad resistance to Cal, too.

This is so disingenuous

 

[Ratchet]

Why though?

Probably this:

Yeah - I don't know why we would kill baudib today.

Doesn't understand the scum case on baudib.

And I don't really think he is scum. He is not pushing anything outragous or anything agenda heavy.
And he has given clear town and scum reads. So I don't really know where the fence-sitting argument comes from.

Explains why they don't agree.

(And a better investigative target than lynch)

Outlines the resolution they would rather pursue for them.

All seems pretty straightforward to me.

 

[Jan]

Cal has a single town read on the last 3 pages of his iso:

I have you as lock town dw

He's obviously town lol

That is the same read on bitter. Without any reason and no other townread at all.

His two main pushes are Ratchet and Baudib, and I don't think I want to kill either of those.

I don't know what cal is doing if town.

 

[MonochromeYoru]

I have over 160 posts - is that the only part you can talk about? Is my whole play just that one thing? Got nothing else to add to anything else I've said, like, say, my reads list? My PoE? Nothing?

I talked about you in d1. Nothing has changed about what I said then.

And a lot of your posts are on the flower thing.

Your poe is pretty common

Cal and baudib are top wagons. York is sussed by lots including me, saber is involved in the flower stuff.

But it's not re-evaluating, all you're doing is shifting focus. The read isn't changing, and nothing you're doing seems to be with the goal of testing that read and potentially moving it. You're just sat still, doing nothing, and expecting... what to change, exactly?

I asked about your play to more experienced peeps. They said you prolly scum. That was me trying to reevaluate and concluding that my initial evaluation was similar to my town reads.

Sitting still and waiting can absolutely change things tho. Game will move forward. Flips and mech stuff will come out. Something could absolve or implicate you.

Even now, this is giving dimensions to you in this game. This is the ratchet I saw in my past games. Not the defeatist who votes on himself. Where was this guy and why did he appear suddenly?

 

[Lord Melkor]

Yeah - I don't know why we would kill baudib today.

There is no way rott is something good. Whoever profits from rot can get rid of baudib for us.

And I don't really think he is scum. He is not pushing anything outragous or anything agenda heavy.
And he has given clear town and scum reads. So I don't really know where the fence-sitting argument comes from.

He is still not locked town, but leaning town for sure and likely self-resolving down the line.
(And a better investigative target than lynch)

So your proposition is to lynch Ripped Cal? I actually have my vote on him if i recall correctly.

@Fujishiro vote count?

 

[Polar Bear]

I don't really clear Worst fwiw but if Charlie flips scum that obviously changes.

Explain how worst is related to a Charlie flip

Fuck me. I checked in during the morning hours, read through the whole spat between Flower and Ratchet and told myself life is too beautiful to get dragged down by whatever that was.

I know you guys represent the worst generation, but that does not mean you have to be Scratchmen Apoo.

Anyway - reading up on some utr slots and realtiming instead of catching up.

I mean according to York im part if the Greatest Generation lol

I've given reads, I've made the vote I wanted to make, I've given reasons for it... is it "not playing to my win con" if I don't lynch who you want me to lynch?

No, self voting is not playing to your wincon if town, ever

Town don't need mislynches and especially from the likes of you. We need you solving and playing

 

[Jan]

Why though?

Because baudib is town lean and + mech.

And Cal is pushing towns and ignoring 90% of the game..

(Caveat is that I have played with baudib and not with cal)

Spoiler

And I am not a great baudib reader when is not playing 100%, but his reads overlap and a couple of his comments are town!baudib.

 

[Jan]

Explain how worst is related to a Charlie flip



I mean according to York im part if the Greatest Generation lol



No, self voting is not playing to your wincon if town, ever

Town don't need mislynches and especially from the likes of you. We need you solving and playing

You are laws silly sidekick.
You make for a great pillow, but that's it.

 

[Lord Melkor]

Vote Lynch Ripped Cal

Vote Red Night to win the Duel

 

[Polar Bear]

So your proposition is to lynch Ripped Cal? I actually have my vote on him if i recall correctly.

@Fujishiro vote count?

I have one but driving, hang on

 

[Ratchet]

I talked about you in d1. Nothing has changed about what I said then.

Yeah it was the "hedging" which really only applies to like 2 reads.

And a lot of your posts are on the flower thing.

I'm willing to bet maybe 90% of my posts are not.

Your poe is pretty common

Should be indicative of something!

I asked about your play to more experienced peeps. They said you prolly scum. That was me trying to reevaluate and concluding that my initial evaluation was similar to my town reads.

Which of those do you trust to read me well and why?

Sitting still and waiting can absolutely change things tho. Game will move forward. Flips and mech stuff will come out. Something could absolve or implicate you.

Sure, but that's removing agency from yourself and hoping something else solves it for you.

Even now, this is giving dimensions to you in this game. This is the ratchet I saw in my past games. Not the defeatist who votes on himself. Where was this guy and why did he appear suddenly?

I don't really think I need to talk about my self vote yet again do I? I refer you to my previous post towards Polar Bear.

 

[Jan]

Probably this:

Doesn't understand the scum case on baudib.

Explains why they don't agree.

Outlines the resolution they would rather pursue for them.

All seems pretty straightforward to me.

I should structure all my posts for your analysis.
Makes me look so much smarter!

 

[MonochromeYoru]

Yeah - I don't know why we would kill baudib today.

There is no way rott is something good. Whoever profits from rot can get rid of baudib for us.

And I don't really think he is scum. He is not pushing anything outragous or anything agenda heavy.
And he has given clear town and scum reads. So I don't really know where the fence-sitting argument comes from.

He is still not locked town, but leaning town for sure and likely self-resolving down the line.
(And a better investigative target than lynch)

Melkor explained what his rot does.
Seems multiple uses of it on same target gives them negative effects.
I don't think there's gonna be another rot in this game.

We could potentially even catch the rotter by watching the already rotted people.