Chapter Discussion One Piece Chapter 1168: ELBAF'S SNOW

Rate Chapter

  • ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

    Votes: 26 43.3%
  • ⭐⭐⭐⭐

    Votes: 12 20.0%
  • ⭐⭐⭐

    Votes: 14 23.3%
  • ⭐⭐

    Votes: 4 6.7%
  • Votes: 4 6.7%

  • Total voters
    60
the strangest thing about everything that happened... why didn’t xebec tell harald about imu???

ok harald is generally foolish and got what he deserved, but his goal was good... he managed to achieve a significant part of it (the giants are peaceful, some of them even fight alongside marines against piracy, and people’s perception has slowly changed). imu is the real problem — xebec hid that from his friend for almost no reason.

one might say xebec respected harald for the peace he wanted so telling about imu is going too far against that... however, there's no peace to begin with by having imu around.
 
Its easy to miss, but Gaban is in the chapter with Ripley and Colon paying respect to Ida after she died

It would be cool if Roger had given his crewmates a secret wish before leaving them be. But I guess he probably told them to live free which is cool in a way. Only Garp had the trust to get Ace after all... Rayleigh and Crocus are sipping whiskey all day....
 
Loki can't join the crew because he'd overshadow Zoro:believe:

The Zoro lobby needs to stand up and send thousands of letters to Oda begging him to NOT do it.
It's funny, because I just reread the beginning of Elbaf and there is this moment where Zoro Gyaban and Sanji talk about conqueror Haki.

And then there is this panel:



My headcanon is that they are actually scared that Loki is too Strong and they would lose their place.
 
It would be cool if Roger had given his crewmates a secret wish before leaving them be. But I guess he probably told them to live free which is cool in a way. Only Garp had the trust to get Ace after all... Rayleigh and Crocus are sipping whiskey all day....
They sort of did have a secret wish between them... that is to NOT tell anyone about Laugh Tale and what the OP is

None of Roger's crew have ever spoken a word about it to anyone else, which implies that they all agreed together to keep it hidden between themselves

Instead they all faded away into obscurity and lived the rest of their lives quietly and hidden away from the public
 
They sort of did have a secret wish between them... that is to NOT tell anyone about Laugh Tale and what the OP is

None of Roger's crew have ever spoken a word about it to anyone else, which implies that they all agreed together to keep it hidden between themselves

Instead they all faded away into obscurity and lived the rest of their lives quietly and hidden away from the public
Which I still dont get, to be honest. The WG is absolutely terrified of anyone finding it. Roger and his crew laugh to tears when they did but still keep it a tight secret. Somehow there is also the plot of the sea level rising, weapons of mass destruction, Loki, Nika, DEMONS and so on. Somehow the Davy Clan who got genocided but Roger and co are still tight lipped despite witnessing it.

It sounds like the greatest Rick Roll in history but on planetary scale?
Post automatically merged:

the strangest thing about everything that happened... why didn’t xebec tell harald about imu???

ok harald is generally foolish and got what he deserved, but his goal was good... he managed to achieve a significant part of it (the giants are peaceful, some of them even fight alongside marines against piracy, and people’s perception has slowly changed). imu is the real problem — xebec hid that from his friend for almost no reason.

one might say xebec respected harald for the peace he wanted so telling about imu is going too far against that... however, there's no peace to begin with by having imu around.
I see no issue with this. This is all "My closest friend" when the bottom line is they thought to be closer than they actually are. Just how Harald left his closest friend to die, Rocks didnt trust him enough to tell him the worlds secrets. Not really a plot issue but both considering each other as close friends yet both are flawed as people. They just arent good people and saw each other as more than they are. Goes double for Rocks. His entire crew wasnt built on trust but power. They all are scumbags just driven by the same goal, so you can argue Rocks saw a friend he never had but couldnt trust him as well.
 
Last edited:
Top