Powers & Abilities Roger isn’t a swordsman

[gz89]

Most are still in denial of fruitless Fujitora > Oden

@Cruxroux said Oden mid diffs Fuji, he's always right i trust him.

 

[Sentry22]

he clearly is

Zoro EoS>>>Roger

Zoro EoS>>>

Mihawk knows Roger is beyond his reach.

 

[LolonoisZolo]

Zoro EoS>>>

Mihawk knows Roger is beyond his reach.

This flashback got people wondering if Vista >= Roger though

 

[Sentry22]

This flashback got people wandering if Vista >= Roger though

Who’s people? You mean Zoro/Mihawk fans? That’s no surprise. And yet Mihawk is the greatest fraud of all time. At least Roger has beaten top tiers. What’s Mihawk done in all his time as WSS? Sweat about having to fight a bunch of Yonko’s?

 

[Veku]

Ndule isn't a powerscaler, but a prophet

 

[HA001]

Who’s people? You mean Zoro/Mihawk fans? That’s no surprise. And yet Mihawk is the greatest fraud of all time. At least Roger has beaten top tiers. What’s Mihawk done in all his time as WSS? Sweat about having to fight a bunch of Yonko’s?

Who has roger beat ?
And weve seen nothing of mihawk

 

[LolonoisZolo]

Who’s people? You mean Zoro/Mihawk fans? That’s no surprise. And yet Mihawk is the greatest fraud of all time. At least Roger has beaten top tiers. What’s Mihawk done in all his time as WSS? Sweat about having to fight a bunch of Yonko’s?

Who has Roger beaten exactly ? Squardo ? Or maybe you meant in the race to PK (Usopp style) ?

 

[Serizzo]

This flashback got people wondering if Vista >= Roger though

No one wonders that, but watch Oda have Vista reappear in the manga at some point missing an arm and we find out Mihawk and him had that duel. The Oda offscreen special

 

[DemarIkh]

Roger fought the god of the verse with nothing but a sword hahaha

 

[Soyz]

Who has Roger beaten exactly ? Squardo ? Or maybe you meant in the race to PK (Usopp style) ?

fought WSM equelly who is cannonicly above mohawk based on title, not even prime whitebeard but oldbeard as well

 

[ImmaIvanoM]

fought WSM equelly who is cannonicly above mohawk based on title, not even prime whitebeard but oldbeard as well

Okay. And Mihawk is canonically above Shanks based on title

And you know what being stronger than Shanks means when Shanks is compared to Joyboy don’t you?

 

[Soyz]

Okay. And Mihawk is canonically above Shanks based on title

And you know what being stronger than Shanks means when Shanks is compared to Joyboy don’t you?

Shanks not stronger then joyboy clown, also title scaling is your stuff. based on real stuff like feats mohawk is not even stronger then vista

 

[ImmaIvanoM]

Shanks not stronger then joyboy clown, also title scaling is your stuff. based on real stuff like feats mohawk is not even stronger then vista

Okay. What about Zoro?

will EoS Zoro be stronger than Shanks? Or is that also unfair?

 

[Lor D. Coast]

Anyone with a supreme grade sword is a swordsman.

Thanks @Shiroyru

Kuina 2.0 says that famous swordsmen aka pirates have most of the world's best swords. Remember when pirate was a fighting style?

Another sword chooses its swordsman panel

 

[Rootbeer]

I say '' Bladesmanship ''..

Most of Roger's Sword wielding fighting style is Blunt damage, so he's not a Swordsman..

Just like you can call yourself a Swordsman and be a Swordsman while most of your fighting style is not Swordsmanship..
You can also wield a Sword as your main fighting style and not be a Swordsman..

Is this Swordsmanship?..

The answer is both, yes and no..

 

[ImmaIvanoM]

Most of Roger's Sword wielding fighting style is Blunt damage, so he's not a Swordsman..

This is a lie. Roger has two named attacks, one of which is a cutting attack

Post automatically merged: Yesterday at 9:01 PM

I

Is this Swordsmanship?..

Is this what Roger fights like?

 

[MUUGEN]

Roger doesn't even attack like a swordsman. His attacks aren't traditional cutting/slashing moves!

swordsman in one piece arent defined by their cutting/slashing techniques....

 

[Terra Arseid7]

fuck, Brook is not a swordsman either, since most of his attacks are not specialized in "cutting" but in "piercing" lol
And to all this. Who the hell said that a swordsman is the one who should use a sword to cut? Why can't they use a sword to pierce or make more forceful or heavier attacks that are less cutting? lol

and another lie from the idiot Rootber, that is to say that most of Roger's attacks are not slash xD

oh and Xebec

 

[Rootbeer]

This is a lie. Roger has two named attacks, one of which is a cutting attack

Zero cutting attack..

Is this what Roger fights like?

No, that's another example demonstrating that Swordsmanship in One Piece isn't straightforward..

swordsman in one piece arent defined by their cutting/slashing techniques....

They are.. That's the core principle of Swordsmanship.. Or should i say Bladesmanship..

 

[Sentry22]

Who has Roger beaten exactly ? Squardo ? Or maybe you meant in the race to PK (Usopp style) ?

Atleast he fought top tiers and didn't get stalled by a commander. We all saw what Roger did to Oden.