[FNZ] Super Role Madness Naruto Shippuden: An Alternate Universe Mafia Game Thread [Game Ended - Mafia Win]

[Neeko]

Why not? People have to try and read me anyway, right? You can't go through games hoping I get solved automatically.

Definitive answers aren't always better than unclear answers, especially with stronger scum players. It can also impact people reading your legacy when you die.

 

[Ratchet]

Looking at the scum deaths so far, I'm not sure there is a competent scum team at play here. I also think it's something you would do or think to try. That's how your thought processing works. You try to take the unconventional and hard to predict route with little to no regard for the reasons as to why it's unconventional and hard to predict. Is it all generally clearing? Yes, which is why I have you as town. But a cop innocent with no godfather flip doesn't have that much value to me, as you can see by where I've placed and talked about Cadis as well as you.

@Neeko in terms of profile Alexis does fit the type of someone who would shoot a scummate. But I don't see the value in proposing a scum case on him when he has an innocent on him and his general player more closely fits his town game vs what he *typically* shows as scum. While none of these things are clearing when they're all stacked up it makes more sense to me to move him to town. He isn't cleared so if the PoE looks to be inaccurate then this is the sort of thing that would need further consideration. But with where we are in the game, doesn't really make much sense for me to ignore that all of this is working to his being town.

 

[Ratchet]

Why aren't you discussing it? And why is it to be assumed that you wouldn't look at the flip?

I don't see any reason to discuss it as I have nothing to offer the discussion, and don't think itbhelps solve the game... and the roles are too wordy for me to read them.

 

[Alexis2282AE]

@Neeko in terms of profile Alexis does fit the type of someone who would shoot a scummate. But I don't see the value in proposing a scum case on him when he has an innocent on him and his general player more closely fits his town game vs what he *typically* shows as scum. While none of these things are clearing when they're all stacked up it makes more sense to me to move him to town. He isn't cleared so if the PoE looks to be inaccurate then this is the sort of thing that would need further consideration. But with where we are in the game, doesn't really make much sense for me to ignore that all of this is working to his being town.

You will be dead soon. I will keep my focus on you as always.

 

[Alexis2282AE]

I don't see any reason to discuss it as I have nothing to offer the discussion, and don't think itbhelps solve the game... and the roles are too wordy for me to read them.

Hmm?

 

[Ratchet]

Definitive answers aren't always better than unclear answers, especially with stronger scum players. It can also impact people reading your legacy when you die.

How would it impact my legacy? If I'm dead there is no longer any ambiguity on whether my reads were genuine or not.

And yes I know it's not always better, but the process in seeking to develop an answer from unclear to definitive is generally hard to fake, which makes it a pretty good point of discussion as far as I'm concerned. You disagree?

 

[Ratchet]

Hmm?

Problem?

 

[Alexis2282AE]

Problem?

Too wordy to read? Nothing to offer?

 

[Ratchet]

You will be dead soon. I will keep my focus on you as always.

What does this have to do with the post you're quoting?

 

[Naomi]

Alright well @bittersweet if you're getting the shit end then I'd be happy to help you out... mainly because I don't have much thus far this game besides a few reads.

But yeah more than happy to help.

Town:
Flower
Naomi (?)
Hayumi
York

Did Bitter just not return to the game?

Vote: Bitter

vote near end phase.


hmmmm

 

[Alexis2282AE]

What does this have to do with the post you're quoting?

Nothing. Just repeating myself for unknown reasons.

 

[Ratchet]

Too wordy to read? Nothing to offer?

Yessir. Are you implying that those two statements must be mutually exclusive? Because they very much do work together.

 

[BoaHancocksHusband]

You will be dead soon. I will keep my focus on you as always.

Very scummy comment ngl

 

[Ratchet]

Very scummy comment ngl

Can you respond to the tags you were given please?

 

[Alexis2282AE]

Very scummy comment ngl

That's crazy. Reads?

And random question: Itachi vs. Pain who wins, what diff, how many times out of 10?

 

[Ratchet]

And random question: Itachi vs. Pain who wins, what diff, how many times out of 10?

Not him - Itachi, 6, no, 7 out of 10, 10 out of 10 times.

 

[Ratchet]

vote near end phase.


hmmmm

What's your take on it?

 

[Naomi]

What's your take on it?

scum

 

[Neeko]

@Neeko in terms of profile Alexis does fit the type of someone who would shoot a scummate. But I don't see the value in proposing a scum case on him when he has an innocent on him and his general player more closely fits his town game vs what he *typically* shows as scum. While none of these things are clearing when they're all stacked up it makes more sense to me to move him to town. He isn't cleared so if the PoE looks to be inaccurate then this is the sort of thing that would need further consideration. But with where we are in the game, doesn't really make much sense for me to ignore that all of this is working to his being town.

I wouldn't lynch him

I just cant read him and wont commit to a read on a player I frankly dont understand

 

[Ratchet]

scum

Why? I agree - the first comment reads as someone trying to be bold and openly support a scum mate in a way that would make him look bad (and thus going for the "he would never do that as scum" defence, and the vote looks like an attempt to get on the wagon for some cred. But why do you think so?

 

[Ratchet]

I wouldn't lynch him

I just cant read him and wont commit to a read on a player I frankly dont understand

I can't really fault not commiting to a read on him. I do think you would stand to consider Occam's Razor, though.