I'm not though, it's more that I need an explanation to rationalise his behaviour before I conclude he's scum for it. AT the end of the day any town read I give is only ever going to go so far, I find it unlikely that scum, and again I'm speaking generally here, would go after you when you have a pretty good thread standing and can very easily turn it on them. For example, my argument might get him through day 1, but day 2? 3? At some point the piper needs to be paid, it's just not a very good strategy because he's made an enemy out of you for the whole game while buying a tenuous read that doesn't really shield him for long.
That's not to say I agree with him, mind. I think the lack of you excusing yourself from the thread to lurk outside of it is a pretty clear indicator of "energy" for you, just because I don't think he has to be scum for it doesn't mean I'm going to let him lynch you.
I think AlwaysMind *can* make himself look very townie when he wants, he's closer to Pot Goblin in that respect than a Yoho or a Reloaded. Seldom he does however so I tend to agree he should be in there.