[FNZ] Super Role Madness Pokemon: I choose you!

Status
Not open for further replies.
I have to admit, I'm not entirely sure what you're asking here. For ease of answering, I've quoted my post regarding Naomi's opening posts.



You can think of this as a sort of 'stream of consciousness' log. To clarify:

I was initially concerned by her post 52, in which she stated she would happily join a wagon on Alex if somebody started one.

I thought to myself, "if she's that concerned about Alex, why doesn't she start a wagon herself?"

Then I wondered, "what does scum-Naomi benefit from following somebody else onto Alex, after explicitly stating that she would follow somebody else onto Alex? It looks very suspicious"

Then I concluded that her saying that is more likely to come from a town than a scum, because the chances are greater that a scum would just *do it* and not *announce they will do it*

This now leads me to where I am at this juncture; suspecting that Naomi is town, and hoping that we can engage in some meaningful dialogue to properly find each other.

Does that clarify my thought process for you?
That clarified the thought process on Naomi. I can see where Naomi is coming from because you said you would catch up during day 1 and turns out you didn't. She said this in the thread and she didn't like your entrance post. I was also bothered by that post too.
 
Moved cal green early, some good and some bad. His unwillingness to assert himself and lead tends to lean town for him, as does his early mia. The rest of the day he swapped between good and questionable. Had a good thought in the 12 hour night chat about the folks bailing on reloaded looking bad bc his claim was terrible
Maybe I've died too early in games recently, but wasn't he more vocal at times as town. Definitely assertive
 
What was the origin of this question?
I noticed that yesterday she asked you specifically for your take on the game so far, specifically in posts 878 and 882 she questioned your reads on Ratchet, Jan and Flower. I wondered if there was any particular reason she singled you out, and surmised that if the two of you were friends or had a history of playing together often, she might be more inclined to trust your takes if she could find you Town.
 
I know you disagree. But his town mo imo is to go mia and not take over the thread and ans not assert himself leader. He's done those things?

What do you see that puts him as a scum read?
same as last game. and anyone giving inactive town leader title when not deserved, is questionable in itself. UwU
 
Here we are.

Ratchet is not the most agreed with read after his drop off, why is he town to you exactly?
(I had him as town early, but I am curious about your take)

What baout york did you like? she has way less activity and without meta knowledge, is an odd pick for a townread.
Regarding Ratchet:

I mind-melded with them on their post 509. I felt that their post 523 was also something less likely to come from scum, and in their post 529 they asked some questions to Cryo that I thought were quite good. I honestly was not aware that Ratchet is not "the most agreed with read", but then, I generally do not take thread temperature before making my reads. I appreciate you pointing this out, though.

What did I like about York? Pure sass. Michelle also made a very good point that York made a post in response to Alex, sarcastically saying that yes she was scum and had told Michelle to bus her. Michelle noted that it would be an anti-scum move for scum-York to clear Michelle like that, and I also agree. I suppose you might call this a tone or gut read. She was blatantly not 'farming' Alexis for content, and appeared to be taking a sort of twisted town-feeling pride at knowing that she was right and Alexis was wrong. Is this an odd pick for a town-read? Perhaps. But I didn't exactly "pick" her. She just came across as town to me. Make of that what you will.
 
That clarified the thought process on Naomi. I can see where Naomi is coming from because you said you would catch up during day 1 and turns out you didn't. She said this in the thread and she didn't like your entrance post. I was also bothered by that post too.
...I don't know what else to say except that I tried to catch but, but there were so many new posts put out *while I was catching up* that I had to split my time between keeping up in real-time, and back-reading.

I'm sorry if that makes me scum to you.

To me, it simply makes me overwhelmed by post volume. I don't usually play large/active games like this. And I probably won't again.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top