[FNZ] Super Role Madness Pokemon: I choose you!

Status
Not open for further replies.
gingerbread

gingerbread

‎
#3,222
#3,222
ThatAverageGuy said:
That makes sense, thanks.

With that in mind, do you think York is in the "potential survive to LyLo" category? Or just town refilling town?
Click to expand...
Could be "potentially survive to Lylo", yeah, but gotta keep in mind, that it's still early in the game, so it's not like such split is fully determined.

As I said before, I played with scum Yoho once and he played shitty but nevertheless he refilled Town first night.
 
ThatAverageGuy

ThatAverageGuy

‎
#3,228
#3,228
Ratchet said:
Also I can't quite put my finger on it but I have a jard time trusting Jan so far. There is a sense I'm getting where they feel "held back", like they're being really careful with what they say and how they say it in a way that feels positional.
Click to expand...
ThatAverageGuy said:
Strange that you say that, because I had that feeling as well. I wasn't able to verbalise it adequately in my own mind, but this does encapsulate my feelings quite well.
Click to expand...
I just wanted to expand on this thought while it's still active in my mind. The word "positional" that Ratchet uses with regards to Jan's play resonates specifically with me in this post:

Jan said:
Here we are.

Ratchet is not the most agreed with read after his drop off, why is he town to you exactly?
(I had him as town early, but I am curious about your take)

What baout york did you like? she has way less activity and without meta knowledge, is an odd pick for a townread.
Click to expand...
What I felt here is that Jan was trying to present that idea that I have more information that I should. In particular, drawing attention to the fact that I have a town read on York "without meta knowledge" feels like an attempt to imply that I do have TMI on York's alignment, and that nobody *without* meta knowledge of York could possibly reach that conclusion on their own.

With regards to the Ratchet read, in hindsight it also feels odd for Jan to call out the "drop off" in activity. I am not somebody who believes very much in "activity reads", and it feels as if Jan is attempting to influence my thoughts in drawing attention to this drop-off and pointing out that many players are disagreeing with my take on Ratchet here.

I just wanted to get this off my chest, and point out why I think Ratchet's "positional" statement hit a strong note with me.

(Also if Jan is scum, you can *probably* clear both York and Ratchet off this right away)
 
gingerbread

gingerbread

‎
#3,230
#3,230
Ratchet
Hayumi
Shiujing
Yoho/tepig
Rej
Juliet
Orca
Jan
York
bittersweet

That's where I see the majority of mafia this game, assuming Flower and Pot Goblin mech looks valid enough and not giving a fuck about 0 posters (420 and Juice).
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top