You could not defend the claim it doesn't make sense if you tried.
Zoro received Shusui and uses it for damn near 500 chapters. He was a good swordsman before he received it.
I didn't say about a random samurai. Who's to say it was a samurai at all? They're not the only ones with black blades. Who's to say there isn't a specific lore about that sword yet to be addressed?
Your assumptions don't make sense, because they're not rooted in reason. They're rooted in dislike for the notion Aramaki didn't forge the black blade himself.
Just say that you don't like that idea instead of pretending you any thought into it.
Zoro received Shusui and uses it for damn near 500 chapters. He was a good swordsman before he received it.
I didn't say about a random samurai. Who's to say it was a samurai at all? They're not the only ones with black blades. Who's to say there isn't a specific lore about that sword yet to be addressed?
Your assumptions don't make sense, because they're not rooted in reason. They're rooted in dislike for the notion Aramaki didn't forge the black blade himself.
Just say that you don't like that idea instead of pretending you any thought into it.
I said the exact opposite.

.
.