[FNZ] Super Role Madness Pokemon: I choose you!

[Yoho]

I'd love to continue this but I must sleep now I got another 12 hr shift later

I'll answer any inquires upon my return

 

[Jan]

It was a response to a question I was given. And I think Ginger is town otherwise I wouldn't bother. I don't agree with your characterisation of it being "busywork" - of course it's not going to be relevant to everyone unless they happen to share the same sentiments as Ginger did. It was a response to Ginger, for Ginger. If your expectation is that I make every single post apply to the whole game and not who I'm quoting, then shrug I guess.

I was just very amused. A single post does not a scum make.

I felt last game that a lot of your post were trending more in a seem busy and getting into unproductive discussions direction.
This game you started out with no nonsense solving, which was a breath of fresh air in comparison.

 

[bittersweet]

Who do you think would be the 'best' target for a lynch today?

Possibly Shu or Marimo maybe. I would say York but she could just be avoiding the thread. Having read up on the current thread state, I'm not sure. There's a lot of players this game who have been ghosting for whatever reason.

Juliet had a really strong thread presence in the first day phase but it feels like she's faded into silence with this one. Yoho is playing like his typical self lately, neither giving strong town or scum vibes. Could be either or indie again.

Rej not defending their slot or claiming could be them giving up or something else.

Not sure if the lack of thread presence of Orca or Polar is a good thing either. It feels like we have a small presence of possibly all town and maybe one or two scum all pointing fingers at each other while dancing to the tune of the scum team, again.

It looks like Rej is going to be the winning wagon at this rate. Not sure why Marimo is getting such a pass other than they're inactive at the moment.

 

[Jan]

I will veto Juliet today.

She was vocal that her active days are on the weekend and Thursdays.

Voting her out today for lower activity is a no go.
If her game does not pick up tomorrow we can talk.

But for now this is a big no go with how many other targets we have to dine on.

(This is based on people pushing her for inactivity not for people thinking she is scum based on her posting)

 

[bittersweet]

I will veto Juliet today.

She was vocal that her active days are on the weekend and Thursdays.

Voting her out today for lower activity is a no go.
If her game does not pick up tomorrow we can talk.

But for now this is a big no go with how many other targets we have to dine on.

(This is based on people pushing her for inactivity not for people thinking she is scum based on her posting)

She's not in my top three right now anyway. I would rather go Rej, Shu or Marimo.

 

[Luka]

Wolfreads are kind of lazy. Bitter will annoy flower, but for the most part nobody will complain about them.

why would you ascribe them as lazy

 

[Jan]

She's not in my top three right now anyway. I would rather go Rej, Shu or Marimo.

Just making sure my reasoning is clear after I saw your read.
I think it is the second time I saw a similar reasoning.

 

[RippedCal]

@JustJuice Replaced by @hime (Magikarp, Metapod) - scum side of null
@Naomi Replaced by @Lord Melkor (Banette, Lapras) - strong town
@gingerbread (Scyther, Magmar) - town side of null
@Yoho (Gengar, Mewtwo) - scum side of null
@bittersweet (Mega Blastoise, Lugia) - null
@Shuijing (Giratina, Shaymin) - null
@Charlie (Espeon, Minior) - scum side of null
@Marimo_420 (Jigglypuff, Onix) - scum side of null
@York (Mimykyu, Floragato) - scum side of null
@Jan (Meowth, Primeape) - town side of null
@Pot Goblin (Azumarill, Cinderace) - town side of null
@Juliet (Blissey, Audino) - null
@Crying bc no Cryo (Furfrou, Lilligant) - scum
@Polar Bear (Snorlax, Beartic) - town
@Handium Replaced by @Luka (Simipour, Simisear) - town
@Mr. Reloaded (Gardevoir, Loppuny) - null
@Flower (Hydreigon,Bulbasaur) - town
@The Orca (Volcanion, Tornadus) - scum side of null
@Michelle Replaced by @ThatAverageGuy (Pikachu, Vulpix) - town
@Ratchet (Rampardos, Leafeon) - town side of null
@Rej (Tatsugiri, Ogerpon) - scum
@Dr_Professor83 Replaced by @tepig19283 (Honchkrow, Corviknight) - who cares/vig fodder
@Hayumi (Gyarados, Stufful) - town side of null

 

[Jan]

why would you ascribe them as lazy

Because they are uninspired and slots people will mostly just nod along and not care.
It is not bad, but not inspiring either. Just bland.

 

[York]

@York Please could you give me your thoughts on the main wagons, which are currently Rej and Shuijin?

Would be perfectly fine to see either of them go, but would rather go Shui at the moment because he's less of a LHF than Rej, which makes his current position all the more damning

 

[Crying bc no Cryo]

I could see this list be anywhere between 1 and 4 scum.
0 technically, but I don't want to be rude.

Naomi was towny. (LM has not posted yet)
I don't think Charlie softs mech on me in this thread state as scum (that is me knowing I am town ofc)
I believe pg believes his claim.

PB and Yoho can go either way.
PB is gth town, but he could be pocketing me by playing to my tune.

Good luck with whatever you are doing here.


Why do you have none of
Rej
Marimo
Ratchet
Orca
in your list?

Those four slots are vastly different, but I am curious what each of them has done to make you feel warm and fuzzy inside.

Marimo feels too wolfy to be a wolf. It looks like they got signed up by accident. But literally I really don’t see how he intends to win as wolf if his strategy is to say “nah I’m just not gonna read” or to show up only at EOD to say “who are we killing?”. It just looks like 0 attempt to blend in and look town and it also looks like he’s making 0 moves to push ppl so I literally just believe he’s a checked-out town who didn’t even want to be here more than I believe he’s the world’s most obvious scum

Orca and Rej I need to look into again but so far I remember liking the fact that Orca brought up how at EOD1 it looked like the wagons weren’t moving and started drawing attention to how weird it looks, and I don’t think scum would want to draw that much attention to that fact in a time where it benefits mafia to not bring it up. And Rej I thought it was towny to put in an effort to play somewhat despite not really wanting to play. It’s day 2 so I know I need stronger reasons than this if I want to town them, so yeah I’ll take another look there honestly.

And Ratchet I know they’re a really good player and I also know that they’re gonna be difficult to read via activity or posting bc they’re good as both alignments. I’m not even gonna consider looking there unless it’s day 3 or day 4 and they’re still alive and haven’t cooked

do you have any ideas on who scum is? Cuz it looks like you’re just questioning ppl. Not that it’s scummy to ask questions but I just wanna make sure you’re not just asking questions to look like youre solving

 

[Luka]

Because they are uninspired and slots people will mostly just nod along and not care.
It is not bad, but not inspiring either. Just bland.

Maybe but thats not what lazy means. Its not as though I’m lacking reasoning for pushing any of them at the very least, nor are they particularly consensus

 

[Jan]

Yo! Cal!

Why that indifferent towards piggy?

 

[Luka]

go tepig!

I agree that tepig is correct that everybody ignoring marimo while every other lhf slot gets traction is a bad look.
I know that is not your reason for the townread because otherwise you would have Marimo as wolf
So why is piggy that high?

Is there anything specific that made you put Hime in town?
She has been fine while around, and I like that she got sucked into the game more than she intended too.
But you must have something tanginble if you have her higher than ginger or hayumi.

Why hayumi because hayumi as wolf does not call out reloaded for being in his scum meta d1 like that.
and you have reloaded as wolf (not just poe)

I don’t town read Ginger or Hayumi
Ginger I feel as though I wouldnt be suprised if they were top posting wolf & Hayumi is like whayever

The way Tepig approached flower is just not how he wolves I dont think

 

[Jan]

Maybe but thats not what lazy means. Its not as though I’m lacking reasoning for pushing any of them at the very least, nor are they particularly consensus

Disagreed but I'd rather have you answer my question about your town reads.
There is no huge point in arguing semantics.

 

[Jan]

I don’t town read Ginger or Hayumi
Ginger I feel as though I wouldnt be suprised if they were top posting wolf & Hayumi is like whayever

The way Tepig approached flower is just not how he wolves I dont think

Ah there it is!
Funny timing

 

[Crying bc no Cryo]

I don’t town read Ginger or Hayumi
Ginger I feel as though I wouldnt be suprised if they were top posting wolf & Hayumi is like whayever

The way Tepig approached flower is just not how he wolves I dont think

Hayumi feels kind of isolated/alone tho. No one is really trying to talk to them or help them get tr’d if they’re scum and I think it’s kind of a rude move if your partner is just being auto-POE’d for no big reason to not attempt to help them

 

[Crying bc no Cryo]

@ThatAverageGuy also per your request I’m just gonna idle and not use my role or participate in events

it’s already very anti-town and I assume participating in events will just make it even more anti-townier

 

[Luka]

Hayumi feels kind of isolated/alone tho. No one is really trying to talk to them or help them get tr’d if they’re scum and I think it’s kind of a rude move if your partner is just being auto-POE’d for no big reason to not attempt to help them

I think across every game of mafia I’ve player this is a view I’ve only heard in this one post

I don’t really think that means much

 

[Crying bc no Cryo]

I think across every game of mafia I’ve player this is a view I’ve only heard in this one post

I don’t really think that means much

Idk

it’s the same reasoning I give for ppl who are wagons the entire day and don’t get defended at any point and those usually end up being town.

speaking of, shui has been a wagon for at least 20-30 hours now and there hasn’t been that big of a change. Does that not worry anyone? Cuz that’s usually a huge red flag for me