Probably Town
Ratchet - I'm going to stick with this, because I mind-melded with a couple of his Day 1 posts, and he's made a couple of micro-reads that I think are difficult (though admittedly, not impossible) to produce from a scum mindset. One example of this is his post saying he feels Jan is playing 'positionally'. If he was scum wanting to shade town-Jan, then that's an awfully specific way of doing so, and there would probably me much simpler meta-reasons for just applying a scum-read there. The only thing I don't like about him is that his focus right now appears to be on the less active players. I get the feeling from reading a couple of posts that popped up while I was alseep, that this kind of play isn't exactly outside the norm for this site, and I don't think this focus on the lower part of the postcount list is something specific to Ratchet alone.