[FNZ] Super Role Madness Pokemon: I choose you!

[Lord Melkor]

hime (Magikarp, Metapod) scum lean trending up
Lord Melkor (Banette, Lapras) town
gingerbread (Scyther, Magmar) scum lean
Yoho (Gengar, Mewtwo) scum lean
bittersweet (Mega Blastoise, Lugia) unsure
BigTimeAnimeMan (Giratina, Shaymin) unsure
Charlie (Espeon, Minior) scum lean
York (Mimykyu, Floragato) indie
Jan (Meowth, Primeape) town lean
Pot Goblin (Azumarill, Cinderace) town
Juliet (Blissey, Audino) unsure
Crying bc no Cryo (Furfrou, Lilligant) town lean
Polar Bear (Snorlax, Beartic) town
Mr. Reloaded (Gardevoir, Loppuny) unsure
Flower (Hydreigon,Bulbasaur) unsure trending down
The Orca (Volcanion, Tornadus) scum lean
ThatAverageGuy (Pikachu, Vulpix) town
Ratchet (Rampardos, Leafeon) town
tepig19283 (Honchkrow, Corviknight) unsure/pls vig
Hayumi (Gyarados, Stufful) unsure

So why do you have Ginger and Charlie as scum?

 

[Jan]

I will definitely agree that tepig's defense is better than the lazy responses before when prompted. It lends credence to the plausibility of town. Not sure why Orca does that. If you want me to firmly slot you town, convince me why you think those on your list are possibly scum.

What do you think of the list drop and departure @Jan?

I think the list is not so good.
But I wouldn't call it opportunistic.
Most of those kills are unlikely to happen today.
And the LHF town slots like yoho and York are not on it (that got pushed by others)

Leaving is not all that relevant to me.
Sometimes life gets in the way.
I would only read into it if it is a repeated offense.

 

[bittersweet]

Hmm, I guess. I'll drop it for now.

Vote Lynch Hayumi

 

[Hayumi]

Good morning Hayumu!









I know some of these posts are from several days ago, but I'd like to know if your reads have changed here, given that:

Yesterday, both you and ginger was voting Shui
Shui was the counterwagon to Rej

Do you think Shui is town now? Were two scum up for the chop? If you still think Shui is scum, if gingerbread town for voting him alongside you? If you think gingerbread is scum, then how does being on a wagon yesterday with him make you feel overall?

I think Shui/Poyser’s slot is more likely town now. Not a fan of Ginger’s claim to start the phase but as I’ve touched on he is way more try hard comparative to last game which gives me pause there.

Honestly GTH would say he still has higher chance of being scum then Poyser

 

[Hayumi]

Did I miss anything noteworthy since last night?

 

[Hayumi]

@Flower Generally from role claims that's towny for York, but what's scummy is lack of progression, until the post above, actually, that what was missing.

I'm not saying she has to land on me being town again, it's not about me at all, but when someone is not progressing on their reads at all, then it's suspicious for me.

Like, Town person changes their mind, doubts, then comes back to a read etc. York was extremely scarse with reads, and the main read was me which didn't move at all.

Scum creates a tierlist and moves along with it for better part of the game, Town has shifts everywhere.

***

I agree that protein to townlean Hayumi is diminishing. Was enough for d1, d2 (that post "why you ain't talking to me when I'm here?!" was cool), but he needs to do more stuff, he's becoming a camping background character without development now. Although I think he was saying in sign up thread that his activity will be lower? You have to check. But I think that he knows how to make himself more... likeable in the thread? That's my impression from Cross Community and last game. Here he seems to not play towards that.

I feel like any assessment towards my slot being suspicious based on not being here enough for my normal standard is getting a bit redundant.

If somebody doesn’t like my actual posts or has a case other then my activity being too in the background for them then by all means bring it to the table. Every single time I’m able to post I’m actively trying to solve.

And yes, I literally said in sign ups I wouldn’t be active people.

 

[Hayumi]

I signed up cuz Fuji wanted me to and I’m not going to sub out when I still have more posts then half the player base at my most inactive FTR

 

[bittersweet]

Luka died, Marimo died, both town.

gingerbread was supposedly targeted by York but didn't die.

 

[The Orca]

That's all you have to say? You don't have reasons for why on any of those?

I have reasons for all of them, why would you assume I don't? Do you think rainbow lists are just without reason?

I just woke up and the game im watching starts in 50 min

 

[bittersweet]

My suspicions of you have nothing to do with your activity. I have been burned too many times by underestimating you and we're beginning to get to the point where some of the 'town' read players have to be considered as possibilities for scum.

I have reasons for all of them, why would you assume I don't? Do you think rainbow lists are just without reason?

I just woke up and the game im watching starts in 50 min

I don't assume anything. I merely saw your list and pushed you on why.

 

[Hayumi]

@Hayumi do you have an updated reads list? I kinda forget you exist.

I’m about 15 pages behind so take with a grain of salt but my main town pool would look something like this

TAG
Hime
Jan
Crying
Ripped
Ratchet
Poyser
York

 

[Hayumi]

My suspicions of you have nothing to do with your activity. I have been burned too many times by underestimating you and we're beginning to get to the point where some of the 'town' read players have to be considered as possibilities for scum.


I don't assume anything. I merely saw your list and pushed you on why.

I wasn’t referring to you, although your main point being “scared to get burned” is literally no better. If you can’t articulate what’s suspect then we have a problem.

 

[The Orca]

I think Shui/Poyser’s slot is more likely town now. Not a fan of Ginger’s claim to start the phase but as I’ve touched on he is way more try hard comparative to last game which gives me pause there.

Honestly GTH would say he still has higher chance of being scum then Poyser

Is he though. I didn't last long in the last one because of some people lol, but seems to have fallen off as this game has gone on and surviving a kill is a big red flag

 

[gingerbread]

Is he though. I didn't last long in the last one because of some people lol, but seems to have fallen off as this game has gone on and surviving a kill is a big red flag

No, he didn't. I didn't post one morning and afternoon and Flower is like "he's falling off" xd

 

[Hayumi]

Is he though. I didn't last long in the last one because of some people lol, but seems to have fallen off as this game has gone on and surviving a kill is a big red flag

I agree with that. He’s scum side of null for me but not sure I’d currently vote him today essentially.

 

[Flower]

I’m about 15 pages behind so take with a grain of salt but my main town pool would look something like this

TAG
Hime
Jan
Crying
Ripped
Ratchet
Poyser
York

Lmk when you caught up.

 

[Hayumi]

Lmk when you caught up.

I won’t be fully catching up any time soon no shade lol, don’t have much time to post but when I do I’d rather it be mostly live. If there’s anything important enough to know feel free to share

 

[The Orca]

No, he didn't. I didn't post one morning and afternoon and Flower is like "he's falling off" xd

I'm confused here. Are you saying you are trying more than last game?

 

[gingerbread]

I'm confused here. Are you saying you are trying more than last game?

No, I always try the same each game.

 

[Flower]

@Flower Generally from role claims that's towny for York, but what's scummy is lack of progression, until the post above, actually, that what was missing.

I'm not saying she has to land on me being town again, it's not about me at all, but when someone is not progressing on their reads at all, then it's suspicious for me.

Like, Town person changes their mind, doubts, then comes back to a read etc. York was extremely scarse with reads, and the main read was me which didn't move at all.

Scum creates a tierlist and moves along with it for better part of the game, Town has shifts everywhere.

***

I agree that protein to townlean Hayumi is diminishing. Was enough for d1, d2 (that post "why you ain't talking to me when I'm here?!" was cool), but he needs to do more stuff, he's becoming a camping background character without development now. Although I think he was saying in sign up thread that his activity will be lower? You have to check. But I think that he knows how to make himself more... likeable in the thread? That's my impression from Cross Community and last game. Here he seems to not play towards that.

I feel that’s a bit high of a standard to have for this community. Some people tend to not shift too much unless they feel there’s a good enough reason. But understood.