[FNZ] Super Role Madness Pokemon: I choose you!

Status
Not open for further replies.
JustJuice Replaced by Hime (Magikarp, Metapod)
Naomi Replaced by Lord Melkor (Banette, Lapras)
Alwaysmind (Mew, Misty's Psyduck)
gingerbread (Scyther, Magmar)
Yoho (Gengar, Mewtwo)
bittersweet (Mega Blastoise, Lugia)
Alexis Replaced by Dr. Watson (Arceus, Zacian-Crowned)
Shujing Replace by AnimeMan (Giratina, Shaymin)
Charlie (Espeon, Minior)

Marimo_420 (Jigglypuff, Onix)
York (Mimykyu, Floragato)
Jan (Meowth, Primeape)
Juliet (Blissey, Audino)
RippedCal (Vaporeon, Dragonite)
Crying bc no Cryo (Furfrou, Lilligant)
Polar Bear (Snorlax, Beartic)
Handium Replaced by Luka (Simipour, Simisear)
Mr. Reloaded (Gardevoir, Loppuny)
Flower (Hydreigon,Bulbasaur) - Watcher
The Orca (Volcanion, Tornadus)
Michelle Replaced by ThatAverageGuy (Pikachu, Vulpix)
Ratchet (Rampardos, Leafeon)
Rej (Tatsugiri, Ogerpon)
Dr. Prod Replaced by tepig19283 (Honchkrow, Corviknight)
Hayumi (Gyarados, Stufful)
Can you give me your juliet and your charlie read?
(or tell me if you have given it already)
 
Probably GTH town but not as confident as some other reads. Her scum range has massively improved and she’s fooled me before while being hyperactive.

She was null on Rej and refrained from giving an opinion there initially until Luka lead the wagon IIRC. Not damning by any means but I’d say alignment wise not clearing.
Okay, that feels like just shade. I didn’t refrain from giving an opinion, I had him as absolutely null. Then went straight to ISO‘ing him and clearing people based on interactions with him. Unless you think Juliet or York are scum, which you don’t at least in York‘s case, tell me how that’s ever teamed.
 
Noted your Yoho read @Jan . I‘ll try digging deeper myself tomorrow if I get around to it. I can see where you’re coming from, but it’s just that the strong feeling I usually have is missing, but it might very well be a me issue and you could be right.
 
Can you give me your juliet and your charlie read?
(or tell me if you have given it already)
Mostly meta, I've played with those fellas alot so I feel like I can read them pretty well
Nothing they've put out has ready overly pingy to me, though I will say with Juliet I feel like it's been a while since we've last seen her
 
@ThatAverageGuy
My response to the list (plus reaction to bitter):
I think the list is not so good.
But I wouldn't call it opportunistic.
Most of those kills are unlikely to happen today.
And the LHF town slots like Yoho and York are not on it (that got pushed by others)
It is certainly an interesting list, to be sure. And I very much look forward to unpicking it if Orca flips scum, as I believe.

Though, I did want to ask about your usage of "LHF" in relation to Yoho and York. I was given to believe that "LHF" means that somebody is new, inexperienced and an easy target to mislynch.

I recall (maybe incorrectly?) that Yoho will be playing in a championship game this year? (please correct me if I'm remembering the wrong name)

And I don't exactly get the feeling that York is new, inexperienced or unable to defend herself.

Unless I'm mistaken, these players are very capable of putting in effort to both get town-read, and defend themselves from suspicion, if needed.

I've never considered either of them LHF. Granted, I don't know them outside of this game, so first impressions is all I have to go off.

Am I wrong, players?
 
@ThatAverageGuy

I think that solidly unpairs Jan with Yoho, that read is too detailed and person who made it clearly believes in it.
I will be honest with you... the unpairing readings I make are far more accurate when made on Day 1. This is the day when everybody is "new" to the game. The towns are feeling each other out, and the scum are feeling the towns feeling each other out. There's generally a lot of feeling going on, and *generally* speaking, if the scum are thinking about anything, it's about making themselves look paired with a town, not making themselves look unpaired with fellow scum.

After Day 1, when a lynch has happened and suspicions are starting to fly, I find that scum generally start to think a little bit more tactically about how they address certain town players in the game, and how they try to appear associated with each other. So while I do think that there is value in continuing to make unpaired reads, after Day 1, I always try to establish multiple instances of "these players are not paired" before I give that read.

So if I wanted to be sure than Jan/Yoho are unpaired, I would search their ISOs for interactions with each other (ideally on D1, but also on other days, though I consider these a little weaker) for at least another instance or two of 'not paired' interactions before I give it as a solid read for town to consider.

(As a side note, I am not particularly paranoid about a Jan/Yoho pairing right now anyway, so this only becomes a thing for me if we lynch too many towns and I need to start eliminating worlds).
 
I will be honest with you... the unpairing readings I make are far more accurate when made on Day 1. This is the day when everybody is "new" to the game. The towns are feeling each other out, and the scum are feeling the towns feeling each other out. There's generally a lot of feeling going on, and *generally* speaking, if the scum are thinking about anything, it's about making themselves look paired with a town, not making themselves look unpaired with fellow scum.

After Day 1, when a lynch has happened and suspicions are starting to fly, I find that scum generally start to think a little bit more tactically about how they address certain town players in the game, and how they try to appear associated with each other. So while I do think that there is value in continuing to make unpaired reads, after Day 1, I always try to establish multiple instances of "these players are not paired" before I give that read.

So if I wanted to be sure than Jan/Yoho are unpaired, I would search their ISOs for interactions with each other (ideally on D1, but also on other days, though I consider these a little weaker) for at least another instance or two of 'not paired' interactions before I give it as a solid read for town to consider.

(As a side note, I am not particularly paranoid about a Jan/Yoho pairing right now anyway, so this only becomes a thing for me if we lynch too many towns and I need to start eliminating worlds).
Jan claimed Vig, so he‘s probably self resolving just fyi. Fuji doesn’t give Vig fakes to scum in his games, usually.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top