I think you’re both Town. I don’t wanna doom either of you.
I think BTAM is likely town and I have a sneaking suspicion that Goblin may be too.
However, Goblin has been in several PoEs today, and several people have said they would be willing to lynch him.
I suspect that if BTAM loses the duel, Goblin will simply me mislynched tomorrow. Unless he can clear himself, but his ability to body-guard the night kill has been suspiciously lacking so far.
In terms of damage control I would rather see how people scramble for new scum-reads tomorrow if Goblin flips town today.
(and if doesn't actually flip town, we at least have BTAM cleared).
Sometimes damage control feels bad, but it's all we can do.