Super Role Madness Pokemon: I choose you!

[ThatAverageGuy]

Updated unpairings:

Crying/Polar Bear
Crying/Ratchet

(not sure if I added those two yet)

 

[ThatAverageGuy]

Are you saying that Polar Bear is not ordinarily a brave player?

 

[ThatAverageGuy]

Flower/Ratchet also not paired

 

[ThatAverageGuy]

I feel like we are probably missing a high poster that is scum, most likely ginger or flower

Between the two, which do you think is the most likely to be scum, and why?

Could they both be scum?

 

[Lord Melkor]

I’d say we lynch between Yoho and orca today, which is why I want Yoho’s claim. I’m a bit more sure on orca atp but Yoho’s pop-in at the end of day yesterday was almost cartoonishly bad lmao

Do you see scum among the more active players?

 

[The Orca]

BTW why your first thought after the claim that I received something n1 was "I was blocked or redirected", not "ginger, my scumread, is lying"?

It wasn't, it was continuing your thought with further options. Also why I asked who boosted you to try and figure out what happened and get a full picture

 

[Lord Melkor]

Vote Lynch TAG

Sorry, who is Tag?

 

[Lord Melkor]

Vote Lynch Mr. Reloaded

Why not Orca or Yoho, what do you think of them?

 

[Lord Melkor]

It's a lie.

He claimed a jailkeep on ginger on N1. But I targeted ginger with an action on N1, and ginger confirmed exactly what that action was before I mentioned anything about it.

Oh and did anyone admit to tempering with Orca? This highly points to him being scum.

Vote Lynch Orca

 

[Lord Melkor]

No I meant who do u tr among Ratchet Orca GB Charlie and Hayumi and why?

Hayumi voting Relo is interesting.

Are you saying that Polar Bear is not ordinarily a brave player?

PB tends to be braver as town from my experience.

 

[Lord Melkor]

Sorry, who is Tag?

Oh the Average Guy?

 

[Lord Melkor]

Oh the Average Guy?

Propably my strongest town read

 

[Charlie]

im claiming the PR on Polar bear

I've been saying he's rown for 2-3 cycles

 

[ThatAverageGuy]

I can't reasonably iso with 0 context sorry
normally when i iso, I look at the surrounding posts and what the player is replying to as well
that is too much for me to read rn

like I said, im only subbing in as a big favor, i don't actually have time to play this game
tho im not sure how I feel abt this sub in general as juice was given 0 warning in role pm at least and he said he'd be back
wish I wasn't subbed if they were planning on playing

I vibe with this first paragraph, because I also do not ISO without context. And whilst overall I think it's NAI, I do give a slight town read because scum-hime could just ISO without context to push a few scum-reads out, and use the very convenient excuse of "I'm not fully caught up/X-player asked me to ISO, so I did" if she started to pick up heat from any pushes.

@Flower why r u acting like u care abt me isoing ratchet but proceed to not respond and not provide context when I request it?

hime/Flower unpaired.

Also, you can feel the annoyance here. Flower asks hime, who has ill-feelings about being asked to sub into that particular slot, to do some work. Hime asks for Flower to provide a little context for the "ISO Ratchet" request. Flower doesn't respond, so hime pings Flower and calls her out for not helping.

(as a side note, Flowers' response to hime was not great)

thank u very much

i read ratchets posts alone and i thought they seemed fine? Tho im not really sure what flower was expecting
I'm not some ratchet expert nor is ratchet going to be so easy to read with no context, if he was then he wouldn't be such a good player
only thing that pinged me was ratchet suggesting to lynch an unreadable player day 1 as that seems uncharacteristic but that's pretty much it

This is roughly in line with what I think a subbed-in/not caught up player should think about Ratchet who by all accounts of players in this game, is difficult to read and a good player. I like that hime didn't try to force a read, because with so many "X is scum/town because of meta" reads flying around, that would probably have been very easy to do just to be seen to have an opinion. It gives me the feeling that hime is more interested in solving Ratchet than labelling him.

problem is that its hard for me to tell since i havent been playing/reading the first 200 pages
i think u have the room to be more of an active voice tho

This feels like a subtle request for Ratchet to do more, which I don't think she would say to him if she was scum and he was town - you don't *want* strong players being more vocal. And it's also somewhat unpairing I think.

hmm not sure what to think of crying/pot

i think both could be town tbh but id wanna play live with @Crying bc no Cryo first

@hime have you had time to play live with Crying to the extent that you like, and can I ask for your D4 read on him?

For context he destroyed one of Orca's uses of an ability, and also post-restricted Polar Bear.

im fine with supporting on rej

Vote Lynch Rej

This post is fine. Not the outstanding bury that Luke/Ratchet did, but not trying to look like voting Rej is entirely her own thought (i.e. for post-flip credit)

he always says hes a good noodle lol
its more a meme than a tell i feel

If Yoho is town and potentially lynchable because of all the suspicion on him, then scum-hime has no reason to downplay any of that suspicion. Could it be soft support of a scummate? Can't rule it out.

Perhaps a CFD on someone like Jan or Luka could be fun. Go big or go home tbhdean

this is a horrible post looking back on it

Could scum-hime with TMI of Jan/Luka be attempting to shade Hayumi for suggesting a CFD on them? Possibly. They're not paired at least. But the CFD timing suggestion (as Rej was being strung up) was not good, so I'm inclined to agree with hime on this one. Especially since CFD'ing an *active* poster over no-efforting Rej is just uh... not something that should ever be done without strong reason?

(about Rej wagon)
i have to think about it, but you have my blessings for pressure on this slot and wagoning

this is another post i noted earlier
i dont like it looking back on it

i don't believe ginger genuinely considered it
And now rej's vote at the end felt like a bad last minute ditch attempt

(to Hayumi)
if u had rej as scummy for so long y didn't u vote him up immediately?

I wondered this as well.

how come u were so quick to change ur vote earlier when rej claimed btw
got caught up in responding to hayumi that i forgot to quote it

This is fine, Jan's unvote seemed odd/quick to me too.

(regarding gingerbread)
i think he might be scum

Only issue I have with this is that it seems to come out of nowhere. Would like more context please, hime.

I'm going to have to stop reading hime here because either the forum is being wonky or my wifi connection is, and I don't have time to wait for each reply page to load, I have to start getting ready to head out.

Overall so far, hime looks town.

hime is not paired with:

Gingerbread
Hayumi (strongly unpaired)
Flower

 

[Charlie]

Aye. And only works if someone was wagon'd for 12 hrs.

So you basically need VCs to use it. But you haven't really asked for one, like, ever

 

[Charlie]

Still no idea who orca jailed

 

[gingerbread]

It wasn't, it was continuing your thought with further options. Also why I asked who boosted you to try and figure out what happened and get a full picture

what do you think happened then?

 

[Ratchet]

So a problem I have with Gingerbread is he is talking a lot about how he cases me having bussed Rej, but he kept ignoring my defence of that and he can't possibly have missed it, I prodded him directly to respond to it. He just pretends it's not there. Feels like he's getting greedy with it but doesn't want to have to defend his position.

@Crying bc no Cryo Can you talk me through how exactly I made it into your PoE? After you were town reading me for most of the game, where did the transition come from?

 

[gingerbread]

So a problem I have with Gingerbread is he is talking a lot about how he cases me having bussed Rej, but he kept ignoring my defence of that and he can't possibly have missed it, I prodded him directly to respond to it. He just pretends it's not there. Feels like he's getting greedy with it but doesn't want to have to defend his position.

@Crying bc no Cryo Can you talk me through how exactly I made it into your PoE? After you were town reading me for most of the game, where did the transition come from?

I saw it, I just disagree with what actually happened. I judged scenarios and I judge that it was more a scum play. That's what this game is about, judging probabilities. You say Rej convinced you to being 100% scum with one post, I see it as less likely. Not much to add here.

 

[BigTimeAnimeMan]

Do you see scum among the more active players?

Who are you qualifying for that exactly? I’d say most likely of the more active players would be Charlie. Possibly crying but I vibe him town just based on what I know of him as a person and a player (which is not a great deal but still)

I think gingerbread, flower and TAG are all probably town. Least confident of those 3 would be gingerbread

Not sure if I’m missing anyone active