Super Role Madness Pokemon: I choose you!

So a problem I have with Gingerbread is he is talking a lot about how he cases me having bussed Rej, but he kept ignoring my defence of that and he can't possibly have missed it, I prodded him directly to respond to it. He just pretends it's not there. Feels like he's getting greedy with it but doesn't want to have to defend his position.

@Crying bc no Cryo Can you talk me through how exactly I made it into your PoE? After you were town reading me for most of the game, where did the transition come from?
Yeah it’s literally the fact that Jan died with you in POE and that I generally believe that the longer i live in a mafia game, the more wrong I am. Unironically I think we vote out you GB and Hayumi last in my POE and that’s if I’m right about the rest. That’s how I’m justifying putting you and GB in POE without also being possibly detrimental to town if I’m just being stupid. But again Luka and Jan died with you two in POE so I probably need to reconsider
 

Ratchet

The End and the Beginning
Yeah it’s literally the fact that Jan died with you in POE and that I generally believe that the longer i live in a mafia game, the more wrong I am. Unironically I think we vote out you GB and Hayumi last in my POE and that’s if I’m right about the rest. That’s how I’m justifying putting you and GB in POE without also being possibly detrimental to town if I’m just being stupid. But again Luka and Jan died with you two in POE so I probably need to reconsider
I think Luka had me as town if I'm not mistaken. To be clear - is this PoE a solve in your worldview or strictly just individual names without consideration for whether they work together?
 
I'm not certain on Yoho's alignment but the way people are treating him reminds me of how people were testing both Pot Goblin and repot.

"Could be scum, might wanna vote there, oh but look here's someone what I might want to vote too", and frankly if feels like trying to keep him on the back burner while having justification to vote him if it looks like a wagon might take off.

If Yoho flips town, these are the players that will go into my PoE.
 
@Ratchet it looks like Jan was more unsure about you than anything. I guess I just assumed it was a scumread cuz I don’t know why they would be so mad that I didn’t have a good read on u. I also have the reading comprehension skills of a 4 year old sometimes
Do me a favour.

Get a read on Ratchet.
A real read.
Okay, the poe is too big to be a lot of value (11 people fits 2 scumteams, but it is better than nothing)
The less confident spew is sadly the only people (ratchet/reloaded) that are useful for me.
Ratchet only came out with the "yeah rej is scum" after people agreed with lucas push (and flower and hime voted him)

In addition, his turnaround was at the same time Rej switched his avatar and(arguably) went into antispew.

It is a bit awkward because Hime jumped on it without conviction.
Flower was mostly sheeping.
And then Ratchet jumps on, saying "rej is scum".

Dunno. If he had a similar conviction before Luca started the push, then it is fine.
Very different vibes. Not damning, but I have to doublecheck Ratchets read on rej before this happened.
 

Ratchet

The End and the Beginning
@Ratchet it looks like Jan was more unsure about you than anything. I guess I just assumed it was a scumread cuz I don’t know why they would be so mad that I didn’t have a good read on u. I also have the reading comprehension skills of a 4 year old sometimes
The "unsure" part is what I was getting at and also why I'm not a fan of Ginger trying to use Jan's read as a crutch to sell his worldview. Otherwise I accept your reasoning here, more or less.
 
I think Luka had me as town if I'm not mistaken. To be clear - is this PoE a solve in your worldview or strictly just individual names without consideration for whether they work together?
I mean it’s a mix of both

I started with a town pile and a POE pile, and then I looked for unpairings to see who works together as partners and who doesn’t. In fact, that’s why York, LM, and Cal are “clear” bc they don’t fit on any possible teams. I ended up with a team of you, GB, Charlie, PB, Orca, and possibly Hayumi strictly because you were all in POE AND all had nothing strongly unpairing you. Unless you disagree with my trs somewhere OR you believe there’s something you did that a mafia partner would never do to Rej or any of the ppl in POE, then please point it out. OR if you have a town case for someone in my POE then make it

cuz if there’s one thing I know: I’m dumb and wrong and loud so I’m trying to at least give u a fair shot

also I’ll check back in later I have therapy soon
 
Top