Current Player List
hime
gingerbread
bittersweet
BigTimeAnimeMan
Charlie
York
RippedCal
Crying bc no Cryo
Polar Bear
Mr. Reloaded
Flower
The Orca
Ratchet
Hayumi
My Town Reads
hime
gingerbread
BTAM
Charlie
Crying
Flower
My 'Revise' Reads
York
Polar Bear
Ratchet
Hayumi
My PoE
bittersweet
RippedCal
Mr Reloaded
Orca
Town
hime is town because I feel that although their thread presence is quite low, their actual ratio of contribution/solve is quite high. Many of their posts come across as uninformed
gingerbread is town because he has been consistently poking at the entire player list in a way that does not make him any friends, calling out inconsistencies even in the people he town-reads, and overall approaching the game from a 'solve' POV. I think his play here would be incredibly difficult to replicate as scum.
BTAM is town because at first I town-read Shui, who turned out to be the CW to Rej. Since subbing in, BTAM has been consistently active in a way that I think is pro-town.
Charlie is town because Cop. I struggled to get a read on him all game, and if he's been playing low-key to avoid drawing the NK then this would explain why. I have no reason to doubt he isn't a cop.
Crying is town because he comes across as alone and unsupported - even when gingerbreads (and myself at times) have spoken in his favour, we have been largely ignored. Also I feel if he was truly scum, he would have been lynched by now.
Flower is town because of the amount of town-siding they're doing this game. Post feel natural and not calculated. Don't know her range, but I get the feeling she's a little outside it.
Revise
My town-lean on York is fading. Tonally I liked her on D1 and a little on Day 2, but since then her sparkle has gone. RL/medical issues are at play, so I'm accounting for that. But those issues did not cause her to shoot my top town, so I'm waning on this read now.
Polar Bear was trending down for me on D3, but he's started trending up a little on D4. I need to revise and try to get a more solid read.
Ratchet was an early TR for me, but as with York, that read is going a little stale now. I played devil's advocate a few times when ginger was sussing Ratchet, but I'm not TRing him as strongly as I did earlier.
Hayumi was trending up for me D2, but started trending down again on D3 + D4. It might just be because it feels at times like her votes lack conviction. I need to re-read at some point.
(As a side-note, yes, I'm aware that both Hayumi and Polar are cop-checks. But I have to accept there is a very small possibility that he may twice have been redirected, or hit a godfather once and been redirected once. Overall I would say Polar has given me the most town vibes between the two, but my reads on these two players have fluctuated all game, so take with a pinch of salt)
PoE
Bittersweet is making those sorts of posts that I feel are "too scummy to be scum" but hasn't done anything that I consider town, and several things that I consider scummy (saying Rej was PoE but "not the best" direction for lynching... SMH, as the kids these days say)
Cal was a town-lean earlier in the game, but my read there has tanked faster than my read on Ratchet (who occupied a similar slot) since there are very few interactions I've had with or seen from Cal since Day 2 that have given me reason to continue town-reading him. Perhaps I should have him as 'Revise', but the way others are playing around him makes me put him in PoE for now.
Mr Reloaded has been a non-entity since his D1 claim. I pinged both him and Goblin, our other D1 claim, on D3 and asked them to make best use of the fact that we lynched AM to give these two more time. Goblin obliged. Reloaded did little.
Orca perspective-slipped on the day we lynched Rej, but I'm apparently the only one who sees it. I'll just keep pushing this until we lynch him or I die.
