Multiverse General If Hunter X Hunter is a 10 what is One Piece?

What is One Piece if HxH is a 10?


  • Total voters
    26

MUUGEN

呪のろいの王
#47
Did you watch a youtube or tik toker who told you the skypiea meme? Please name what's so amazing about Skyepia worldbuilding

In fact, Skypeia is one of early things that destroy one piece's worldbuilding.

The logue town people were treating sky island as some sort of tale that is not real, but later not only do we learn that there was some sort of common path to sky island that everyone knows and takes, but sky islands are not even a secret just few islands away like in Sabaody.
Hell, there is literally a rookie like Urouge who is known to be from sky island being in news papers and bounties, yet for some reason logue town just doesn't get the news....somehow.

Meanwhile hxh shits on one piss both in size and detail in terms of worldbuilding.

There's nothing to debate.
Oda is talentless with paneling, he only does basic panels (and even fails that).
His art went from basic to completely incomprehensible scribble trash.
Hell, I remember that it was said that since timeskip began, the hack only did 2 doublespreads up until Elbaf (grandfleet and elders).
He can only do one crying snot face for al characters.

Meanwhile Togashi:





Did you even comprehend what you've said?
Whose is it that Oda keeps bloating his series with irrelevant filler characters so much that he can't even flesh out his main cast?

Hxh doesn't have that problem in like 400 chapters. Oda has way more chapters yet he can't even flesh out his retarded mc.

I'm sorry what? How is Mereum is a carbon copy of cell? the fuck?


name them and tell me what's good about them.

So far every arc/saga from timeskip has been a joke and filler bloat.
Marineford keeps becoming a dogshit mess where marines had to be turned into retards in order for "war" to last more than 10 seconds.
ennies lobby is a meme by normies into gaslighting it's good, it's a standard arc with same glaring shitty plotpoints like assassins actually holding a fucking tournament and actually holding a real key instead of throwing it away.

Meme piece fights are such a joke that even the most normie fans and OP youtubers gave up on them, no one gets excited about meme piece fights because it's just a clash and then a billion chapters of focusing on fodders running around between fights that last 100 chapters.
Katakuri shit is prime example, lots of dogshit in between and then suddenly katakuri lost in 13 hits.
Fights also don't have anything going for them, it's just punch harder until suddenly last hit works. That's it. You can't understand when characters are at their limits because powersystem is shit and powers are made up on the spot.

Btw you literally just said powersystem in hxh is better, which automatically makes fights also better.


Because I grew up.
I used to be an NPC like you that swallowed Oda's shit writing expecting Hack's promises about the series to finally start ramping up, but it never happened.
Look at Elbaf almost 2 fucking years and nothin has happened, just fodder bloat. Fucking fodder everywhere every fucking arc.

Instead on finally focusing on real characters like Admirals, Dragon, Blackbeard...etc, this fucking hack just keeps introducing fodder and then established shitty bomb point with civilians nobody fucking cares about and then characters running around like headless chickens for whole arc.
Rinse and repeat
yawn.

ofc its kurwa

https://worstgen.alwaysdata.net/forum/threads/best-arc-saga-overall.46468/


&* yes meruem is a literal copy of cell alongside the RG they are androids 16-17 except their roles are reversed - cell is heavily focused on the cyborgs while they are in fear of him running away, meanwhile the RG wholeheartedly adore mereum but he does not give a single fuck about them.

powersystems dont make fights better lol does JoJo have the greatest fights with their power system no they dont.

you know you can also just stop reading/watching OP if you dont care or like it. its really that single and not that deep.

& look at togashis work these days fatigue and health issues cause decline in every mangakas work we seen this across every single major long story.... hell some even retired before they finish the series cause it is heavily taxing on the storyteller....
 
#50
OP is definitely a 4 or lower, especially Post-Timeskip into Goon Piece. No way we have the top tiers fighting over some cooch in a flashback.

Roger used to have an aura; now we get Luffy 0.1.


I loved OP, but it's been a drag. Bloated series, filler chapters, too many useless characters, no development for main cast, sped MC only gets worse. Worldbuilding is as wide as a lake but shallow as a puddle.


HxH genuinely beats it in almost every aspect, and I don't even like HxH that much.
 
Top