General & Others Does One Piece Peak At Marineford or Enies Lobby?

Thoughts?


  • Total voters
    32
#4
Ennis Lobby - ended in Biggest asspull to date
Marineford - By far the biggest PIS arc in the series.

I would take Wano or Egghead. But I do enjoy Luffys underdog storyline throughout ID-> Marineford more, so maybe MF.


As much as I like the narrative of W7-> Ennis Lobby, the asspull with Merry at the end is a big minus + asspull powerups.
 
#12
New powers were cool in Enies Lobby but Lucci sucked as a villain and it's kinda sad that he's been brought back just for Luffy and Zoro to shit on him.

Marineford was good if you count the overall saga, but the battle itself was mid. Pirates were too nerfed for it to be interesting and no straw hats other than Luffy who was generally useless. Blackbeard/Shanks showing up at the end was good though.

Thriller bark/Alabasta were the best arcs, Elbaph is shaping up to be competitive on a re-read.
 
#15
Ennis Lobby - ended in Biggest asspull to date
Marineford - By far the biggest PIS arc in the series.

I would take Wano or Egghead. But I do enjoy Luffys underdog storyline throughout ID-> Marineford more, so maybe MF.


As much as I like the narrative of W7-> Ennis Lobby, the asspull with Merry at the end is a big minus + asspull powerups.
"asspull powerups" lol what
anyway marineford was mostly just fighting, it's not that interesting
enies lobby stomps
 
Top