[FNZ] Super Role Madness Game Of Thrones: A Song Of Ice and Fire

[bittersweet]

Wait but as far as I understood Dio was the Vigilante so couldn't have been him.
And also the rolecrusher, so if Flower was rolecrushed it was by somebody else, which would mean mafia has also a rolecrusher or she got roleblocked.

Robb Stark - Dio
You have the following passives and abilities for now:

You will dodge the first roleblock on you in the game.
You will learn if you were visited at night.
Target a player and kill them.[2-Shots]
Target a player and rolecrush them for the phase (they will still keep their current HP status but lose their passives and actives).[2-Shots]

Mafia could have a graverobber role.

 

[Tayenne]

Mafia could have a graverobber role.

Interesting first time hearing about that role. Can they grab the item immidiatly and use it in the same night usually?

 

[bittersweet]

None of her thought processes track in a logical manner, but I think its just because shes been emotional all game and is just saying stuff out of emotion

That's what I was assuming. The frustration to not being town read was alignment indicative in the past.

 

[bittersweet]

Interesting first time hearing about that role. Can they grab the item immidiatly and use it in the same night usually?

I'm not sure if it would be a same night ability once stolen or available the following night.

 

[Jan]

I'm not sure if it would be a same night ability once stolen or available the following night.

Strongly depends on the details of the roll.
If you backup a full role you likely have to wait a night.
If you can use a single shot of a single ability of a player it is likely that night.

There can be further restriction to balance it.

 

[Great Potato]

I'm still not liking Tayenne's posts, just the sort of questions he is asking feel like playing naive which I have a hard time buying for someone who claims to have many previous games under their belt.

Why act like Zemmi's death is a confusing choice that needs looking into when the obvious reason is that she sought out a sub because she possessed a powerful town role that she didn't want town to lose and then was voted part of an elite council that will have sway over the thread? Any non-scum members in that council have targets on their back from this point and should become priorities for any protective roles out there.

Why would a janitor kill that scrubs the identity of a killed player to deny information to the thread ever be anything other than a scum role? I don't mean to be rude if these are sincere questionings, but it keeps looking to me like fluff posting designed to look engaged without actually moving the needle in the thread.

 

[bittersweet]

I can see it, some of the questions do seem to be a stretch.

 

[Mr. Reloaded]

so you confess it was you afterall?

No. Although I wouldn't say it was a terrible shot lol

 

[Mr. Reloaded]

He hero shot town in a previous game.

OH

 

[bittersweet]

OH

Yeah, made a bunch of people mad about it too.

 

[Jan]

Yeah, made a bunch of people mad about it too.

It is rare that the townvig stacks with mafia and 3p on N1 because they shoot the most townread player/obvious villa.
Strong instincts on that one.

 

[Tayenne]

I'm still not liking Tayenne's posts, just the sort of questions he is asking feel like playing naive which I have a hard time buying for someone who claims to have many previous games under their belt.

Why act like Zemmi's death is a confusing choice that needs looking into when the obvious reason is that she sought out a sub because she possessed a powerful town role that she didn't want town to lose and then was voted part of an elite council that will have sway over the thread? Any non-scum members in that council have targets on their back from this point and should become priorities for any protective roles out there.

Why would a janitor kill that scrubs the identity of a killed player to deny information to the thread ever be anything other than a scum role? I don't mean to be rude if these are sincere questionings, but it keeps looking to me like fluff posting designed to look engaged without actually moving the needle in the thread.

you still didn't answer my question from yesterday btw
and 90% of the games I played were nothing like this game, I played mostly vanilla games with only a few power roles and also open setup, thats why I am not familiar with a lot of roles and ye in general how you have certain game mechanics and have to ask about them

if I want to solve this game I have to understand how to play it, nothing fluff about it
you think it might be obvious that the way you are used to playing games here is how everybody plays it but let me tell you it is not played like this on other communitys, even small things like the lynch tallys here are noted is not what I am used to at all

what do you think about me getting poisoned btw?

 

[bittersweet]

It is rare that the townvig stacks with mafia and 3p on N1 because they shoot the most townread player/obvious villa.
Strong instincts on that one.

It was a once in a lifetime event, I agree.

 

[Great Potato]

what do you think about me getting poisoned btw?

Not much honestly. I don't think that it speaks for anything alignment wise in any case.

Only question is if somebody had that in their role sheet or if they had enough money to nab it off the black market, but it's not the most pertinent question to the game state.

 

[York]

Wait but as far as I understood Dio was the Vigilante so couldn't have been him.

It's likely that more than just one member of town will have kill power(yes i'm softing, no it wasn't me)

 

[Tayenne]

Not much honestly. I don't think that it speaks for anything alignment wise in any case.

Only question is if somebody had that in their role sheet or if they had enough money to nab it off the black market, but it's not the most pertinent question to the game state.

with the way you think it is weird from me to ask questions about game mechanics and thus maybe hiding behind fake naiviety since so many things are apparantly so obvious to you

I am starting to believe it is hard that you think analysing confirmed information like who got killed and thinking why they got killed and what that could say about players is something you don't think is obviously important
same with someone possibly being poisoned

also after writing your huge list yesterday I found it weird how selective you seemed to be with whom you added to the list, like let's say you focused on analysing the most active players it was weird then how you didn't analyse Al Sama who is one of the most active for example

and it is also weird how you didn't lynch anyone after writing this list, like writing a list and not following up with an action after you spent so much time thinking about players and whom you suspect does seem to me like a way to appear enganged without actually pushing anything forward
what made you lynch polar bear in the end?

you suspecting me doesn't make you already mafia in my eyes but yes I am starting to wonder if it comes from a genuine towny place or if you are trying to find an opportunity to try for a mislynch because your focus seems very selective when you read my posts

 

[Michelle]

Spoiler

I also usually prefer townreading people and thus finding mafia by process of elimination but in this game I have so far a hard time tbh to trust many people

me
Flower
Zemmi
Ratchet
Ekko but he subbed out so it doesn't matter

if one of them is in a scum team they can make other scums active too

is my take bugging you for some reason??

@Tayenne to answer your question on who i think could be scum with Zemmi

Of the 7 people that voted her from most to least likely

Flower(tho she can clear herself tonight)
Jag
Zemmi
Saka
Cal
Bittercat
Myself

Flower- the way she claimed her execute immune felt weird and then she crashed out just cause she was being suspected she claims watcher so I wanna give her a chance to prove her claim

Reloaded- I think Scum loaded is more likely to just pop in here and there stir the pot without adding ingredients and rhen disappear again

Jag- I think Botan and Flower where softly protecting each other without going ro deep into it, i usually don't bother with connections this early but if there is one Its here

Big Momma Zemmi- As ive explained the quickness in whixh you gathered council votes without any kind of discussion seemed like Scum trying to get onw of their own in tho that is 100% a gotcha it is enough to give you a bombastic side eye 👀

Saka- not a suspect and haven't played with him enough to really build a case base on his post

Cal- town

Bittercat- town

Me- Town

I asked who wanted to be on the council and she raised her hand

Bittercat when scum usually imo tries harder to appear townie here he's kinda just here

Flower - don't know why she would claim to be immune to duels, when in doubt, throw it out
Yoho - my eternal rival, yeet him off the cliff
Jan - ride or die

The Flower one is right now, I don't trust her when she does day one claims. They aren't out of her wheelhouse but I don't like when she does it. It also seems strange for her to openly claim to be immune to duels.

Yoho is more or less our typical back and forth nonsense.

Jan is town leaning for me right now.

it could be a townie thing but I didn't like the way Flower defended Jaguark

her dip is strange too

in fact did she do anything other than creating chaos by claiming for no reason??

however Saka's push on her is starting to feel a forced even tho I suspect Flower myself

I‘m pretty confident Orca is Town this game. I know what his posts sound like, but he always says stupid shit as Town that rubs people the wrong way.

Also people have become really shit at thinking what I‘d do as scum. Starting to pmo some really insinuate I‘d be this trash as scum when the last time I was scum here I played the fuck out of people for 17 rl days.

And @Zemmi literally the last time I saw Jag as scum he subbed out because he didn’t want to play scum (that was my Bleach game on OLF). I have zero reason to believe he improved his scum play before I see that he actually can. Just having a pulse and giving thoughts feels clearing for him. If you continue pushing that angle I will have to consider I‘m wrong on you and you’re scum.

There is plenty of reason to why that happened.

Let's see what the day brings first.

n1 Lord Melkor

Just in case I die and people need the info. for mech puzzling

Got poisoned

Nothing happened to me btw. In case someone's used sth.

---

Do sallu was likely killed by mafia and yoho? Either another vig or Indie that's chosen yoho to pretend to be a vig later on?

Usually when there's town with census role that activates on DX, there's something weird going on with factions. So it's safe to assume there's one of this:
1. Cult
2. multiple indies
3. Separated mafia members
4. 2 mafia teams

That's what I was assuming. The frustration to not being town read was alignment indicative in the past.

good morninc
spoilering the posts I kept in multiquotes for further refference if needed

 

[Michelle]

I need everyone to think at a 6 people POE for mafia and 2 indies.

please quote this post and share your thoughts

Players:

1- @Flower
2- Yoho
3- Zemmi Replaced by Sallucion
4- @Jaguark101
5- @York
6- @Polar Bear
7- @bittersweet
8- @Mr. Reloaded
9- @Alwaysmind
10- @Charlie
11- Hayumi Replaced by @GalaxyLevelShanks
12- Dio Replaced by Orwellian
13- @The Orca
14- Ratchet Replaced by @Crowned Witch
15- EkkoLoJinx Replaced by @Worst
16- @gingerbread
17- @AL sama
18- Michelle
19- @Tayenne
20- @Jan
21- @Lord Melkor
22- @Yo Tan Wa
23- Elder Lee Hung Replaced by @Great Potato
24- @SakazOuki
25- @RippedCal

 

[Michelle]

if I have to start I suspect for now
Worst
Potato
YoTanWa
AM
Ripped
York

if I am wrong about anyone here please help me to find you!

i need more from @gingerbread, the posts I read are not enough for me to make a read

i need posts from @Crowned Witch and @GalaxyLevelShanks

 

[Charlie]

What is kantor? I am not familiar with that.

Also it is worth looking into the names of the kills it seems like zemmi got killed with just 'kill' and yoho with 'superkill'. In the op it said kill is 1 hp worth and superkill 2 hp. Either that means that is the max hp value they had or that means they got killed by some ability because mafia kills count as an omega kill.

Janitor

Kantor is a spot where you can exchange currencies in polish. It's autocorrection thing on my phone