CW was leading by 2 votes officially but:
1. Melkor voted CW and had 2vp.
2. Tayenne voted CW and in case of draw, she had deciding vote.
So irl it would have to be lynch dodge, redirection or somehow someone placed extra 4 votes on Melkor (2 to draw with CW officially, 1 more to draw considering extra vp from Melkor, 1 more for Melkor to have more because in case of draw, CW gets lynched)