Flower - Revived and we know their role-sheet. Only question remaining is the question is if they came back corrupted. I'm almost certain it would not be a mafia reviver even if that were true.
Worst - Was caught driven with Polar on N1 by a scum bus-driver and was the strongest advocate and push for killing Melkor all the way back on D1 when nobody else was looking at him.
CrownedWitch - People reading too deep into the mechanics of how she survived. It seemed pretty clear to me looking back in the previous phase that a lot of mafia were probably on that effort to lynch CW in order to save Melkor and that eliminates her from being scum team in my books.
GalaxyShanks - They've been going hard against Melkor the entire game and were responsible for his lynch when things were on the fence. I don't think he's bussing because a scum double-vote would have to play things safer against his own, and I doubt they had two of them.
Alwaysmind - Only really made troll posts so far with nothing to read, but I don't know what sort of scum game would entail just popping in to lynch out your own dude in a close race.
Michelle - I certainly like her posts a whole lot more than I like Orca.
bittersweet - Their claimed role kind of gives them an excuse to coast and be useless this game, but they have been consistent in that department. Difficult to get a strong read on them because their ability and play just tied them to Jan, but they have plausible deniability if their claim is true.
SakazOuki - They haven't been making good decisions this game. Voted on the Dio wagon D1 and jumped ship off Melkor onto CW D3. However, I'm more inclined to believe that the scum team would not have both a bus-driver and a redirect working in tangent, and there was a point where he was trying to pressure others to get onto the Melkor wagon even if he then ended up doing a rallying call later to get people to jump off of it onto CW. I also think his read lists have been mostly terrible. A messy game, but slightly better than some of the worse options.
gingerbread - Kind of neutral on ginger right now. They did run a pretty decent amount of defense for Melkor throughout the game which is a bad look, but they also went very hardball against Polar very early in D2 which was like the sparking vote for that wagon which is a good look. If they had the foresight to hardcore bus Polar would they attach themselves so readily to Melkor? Maybe, but it gives me some doubts and makes me question that his opinions on Melkor may have been legitimate. I don't like how he's avoided getting involved in some of the more crucial phases by placing his vote on nothing wagons though. I believe that we are still missing a claim from them though, which is putting them in a worse light right now.
Orca - He's the most scum player in the game based on posting history and behavior. He is the one that drove the Dio counter-wagon against in the first phase that combatted Melkor and later Polar. His subtle shift from Melkor to Dio looks far worse in hindsight with the knowledge that Melkor was scum. He spent D2 mostly making tinfoil conspiracies trying to shade our cop, and then in D3 he scrambled to save Melkor with a counter-wagon by jumping on CW despite that he supposedly had Melkor read as one of his top scum. The only thing that potentially clearing is mafia having a scum vs scum wagon that they did not put great resistance too, but I think we are dealing with a scum team that has limited thread sway this game.
Charlie - I don't for a single second believe their nonsense ability that they've spent about their entire game blabbing about and trying to sell us on is actually legit, and all of their behavior has been super scummy. Spent the entirety of the game avoiding lynches on scum. Refrained from a vote D1, dodged the Polar wagon D2, and then did a lot of talking about Melkor being suspicious D3 only to vote for everyone except for him.
Mr. Reloaded - A terribly scummy game so far. Voted for Dio on D1 over the Melkor lynch, covered Melkor with an alibi on D2, refused to vote in the Polar lynch, and scrambled to the CW lynch at the end of last phase in an attempt to save Melkor. That is his entire game spent bailing out Melkor and avoiding scum. We still don't have an explanation for Flower's failed watch on N1 and this guy just happens to be a claimed role block.
Yo Tan Wa - Outed themselves as indie, but I'm thinking probably not a malicious one.
RippedCal - They are probably my top suspect for Night King at this stage.
