Salem of Lies TOS II: Salem's New Threat

[Gambit]

Wdym it’s not right?? I’m giving you a reason for disagreeing that someone should be town read for the specific reason you outlined. I can have that opinion lol, Ratchet themself would agree it’s not AI.

You don’t have to listen to me lmao, it’s not like I’ve flat out said Ratchet can’t be good here.

It’s the logic in your blanket statement I’m telling you is not relevant meta-wise

I’m not trying to discredit you at all and somehow taking it as me making you look bad or “building a case” on you is random af.

Fair enough. I wasn't townreading him because he made reads. I liked the way his progression developed. They're different things.

 

[Fujishiro]

If I was on a bandwagon, I'd have placed a vote - which I haven't. I don't know some of these players and I'm trying to gauge their entrances from those who supposedly do. Does that mean they're going to be accurate or not make mistakes because players can alter their playstyle? No. But it certainly seems like a plausible starting point.

Who are you talking to.

 

[bittersweet]

Who are you talking to.

Hayumi, I thought they were talking to me. Was all of that conversation in regards to Melkor?

 

[Fujishiro]

Hayumi, I thought they were talking to me. Was all of that conversation in regards to Melkor?

Yeah.

 

[Hayumi]

Fair enough. I wasn't townreading him because he made reads. I liked the way his progression developed. They're different things.

Right, which is fair, but that’s not how your original statement was phrased so I can’t read your mind.
“i’ll give Ratchet a small town cred for his early reads” feels a bit cut and dry.

Can you point me to the specific posts where you saw some progression that you liked.

 

[bittersweet]

Yeah.

But they quoted your post about me making posts just to make posts?

 

[Fujishiro]

Fair enough. I wasn't townreading him because he made reads. I liked the way his progression developed. They're different things.

Progression wise which posts pinged you positively?

 

[Fujishiro]

But they quoted your post about me making posts just to make posts?

I don’t remember that.

 

[Gambit]

Right, which is fair, but that’s not how your original statement was phrased so I can’t read your mind.
“i’ll give Ratchet a small town cred for his early reads” feels a bit cut and dry.

Can you point me to the specific posts where you saw some progression that you liked.

To end this 1v1, I wasn't town-leaning Ratchet simply because he made reads. He's Ratchet, he'll produce reads regardless of alignment. A small town cred doesn't mean strong town read.

To start, he was the first to actually move the thread forward. Instead of just throwing out a list of reads, he broke down his thoughts on different players individually and kept his reads separated rather than collapsing everything into a single scum pool. That felt like someone actively sorting the game state rather than forcing a narrative.

 

[Ratchet]

If I was on a bandwagon, I'd have placed a vote - which I haven't. I don't know some of these players and I'm trying to gauge their entrances from those who supposedly do. Does that mean they're going to be accurate or not make mistakes because players can alter their playstyle? No. But it certainly seems like a plausible starting point.

Feels awfully self conscious.

 

[Naomi]

 

[Gambit]

Progression wise which posts pinged you positively?

My boy, I don't usually form reads from isolated posts. I read progression over a sequence of posts.

 

[Fujishiro]

To end this 1v1, I wasn't town-leaning Ratchet simply because he made reads. He's Ratchet, he'll produce reads regardless of alignment. A small town cred doesn't mean strong town read.

To start, he was the first to actually move the thread forward. Instead of just throwing out a list of reads, he broke down his thoughts on different players individually and kept his reads separated rather than collapsing everything into a single scum pool. That felt like someone actively sorting the game state rather than forcing a narrative.

You don’t think my 4 vote wagon on Melkor is moving the game forward

 

[Fujishiro]

My boy, I don't usually form reads from isolated posts. I read progression over a sequence of posts.

I mean Hayumi asked you the same question and you answered, so nvm this.

 

[Fujishiro]

What’s up?

 

[Naomi]

You don’t think my 4 vote wagon on Melkor is moving the game forward

it's 48hr day phase, and the guy is sleeping. lol

 

[Hayumi]

To end this 1v1, I wasn't town-leaning Ratchet simply because he made reads. He's Ratchet, he'll produce reads regardless of alignment. A small town cred doesn't mean strong town read.

To start, he was the first to actually move the thread forward. Instead of just throwing out a list of reads, he broke down his thoughts on different players individually and kept his reads separated rather than collapsing everything into a single scum pool. That felt like someone actively sorting the game state rather than forcing a narrative.

He had a total of 5 posts before you made your read to be clear so by definition there is no “progression” at the time you’re saying u already made this conclusion but post #170 and #172 are fine takes to start a game off so I guess that’s fine and not much more to discuss here ( although still not AI.)

 

[Naomi]

What’s up?

isn't alwaysmind our time zone?

 

[Fujishiro]

@Gambit you questioned Ratchets vote while thinking he’s moving the game forward?

 

[Fujishiro]

isn't alwaysmind our time zone?

Yes.