I feel left out of this conversation between you two. Is there some knowledge you both are privy to?
this should explain your question
ROLE: Executioner
FACTION: Executioner
ALIGNMENT: Neutral Evil
ABILITIES:
Your target is:
*Your target will always be town.
*Your target will not be a Town Power, Amnesiac, or Catalyst.
*You also win if your target is Prosecuted or hanged during a tribunal.
*If your target is killed without being hanged you will become a Jester
*You will leave the town when you wincon is met
DEFENSE: Basic (for two nights)
WINCON: Hang your target by any means necessary.
INVEST RESULT:
SHERIFF: Seems suspicious!
POTION MASTER: (Player's name) wants someone to be hanged at any cost. They must be an Executioner.