General & Others Which Popular Theory has been Debunked but you would have liked to have been real?

[Dettles]

In the nearly 30 years of One Piece there have been a lot of theories that have come and gone. With many of them being straight out Debunked. Like Mother Caramel being Bonney. But Which Debunked Theory was your favorite and would have liked to have been real? For example that "God Valley was turned into Thriller Bark".

 

[Fn Lucci]

Arlong and Mr 1 being dead

 

[Dettles]

Arlong and Mr 1 being dead

Was that ever a Theory? We were told they had been captured by the navy.

 

[Crow]

Usop actually leaving the crew
Kaido being Katakuri's father
Imu being a parrot
Megallan becoming an admiral

 

[Mr. Reloaded]

Diamond Shiryu

 

[Fn Lucci]

Was that ever a Theory? We were told they had been captured by the navy.

The theory was that Arlong was executed. Smoker didn't mention Daz being captured, just defeated

Those were the earliest ones I can remember that didn't turn out true

 

[Warchief Sanji D Goat]

Gaban being a background character and wouldn't have a severe impact to the story.

Simps and gooners can't unlock Conqueror's Haki.

And lastly, Sanji not getting Conqueror's Haki.

All of these were agenda pushing by me since 2018 and sasuga Oda-sama, proving me wrong everytime.

 

[Loki D. Terror]

--Kaido being related to harald

--Loki having a surtur DF (Though nidhogg is a fine DF)

--Kaido having awakening

--Roger having devil DF

--Shanks having water/time DF

--Xebec having yami DF

--Roger having some next level haki above his peers

--Xebec being pure evil.

--King and queen having mythical zoans

--Kaido having typhon/Chimera DF.

--Yamato being Kaido's son than daughter

--Yamato joining SHs

 

[gz89]

I had hoped that Sabo wouldn't be alive.

 

[Monster Zoro's Tesla Supplier]

I had hoped that Sabo wouldn't be alive.

Why

 

[gz89]

Why

He plays absolutely no role in the story.
Oda couldn't bring Ace back so he simply created a blond lookalike of him.

 

[Monster Zoro's Tesla Supplier]

He plays absolutely no role in the story.
Oda couldn't bring Ace back so he simply created a blond lookalike of him.

What role did Ace serve

 

[gz89]

What role did Ace serve

So that Luffy would see him die right before his eyes.

Sabo exist simply for the sake of existing.

 

[Monster Zoro's Tesla Supplier]

So that Luffy would see him die right before his eyes.

Sabo exist simply for the sake of existing.

I mean sounds like Ace was just a plot device then

 

[gz89]

I mean sounds like Ace was just a plot device then

Obviously yes.
Sabo isn't even that.

Where exactly are you trying to get at?

 

[Monster Zoro's Tesla Supplier]

Obviously yes.
Sabo isn't even that.

Where exactly are you trying to get at?

I'm saying that I don't hate Ace but at least Sabo has the potential to be an actual character

 

[ShinichiMugi]

-Blackbeard appearing in Whole Cake,to take Big Mom's territory (At least two of them went there later!)

-Luffy becoming a woman as an effect of Ivankov's cure in the Impel Down arc. The theory was that after the cure he would wake up as a girl

 

[Kumathegoat]

Monet still alive @Tokiro Oumaga

 

[Lord Dobby]

Kaido is Meadows

 

[Cruxroux]

- Domi reversi works on people in their hometown/country only.
- Fujitora being from Wano, oda created an alternate Wano, Yano lmao.