Salem of Lies TOS II: Salem's New Threat

[bittersweet]

You're asking questions whose answers are already in the thread. What's your theory? What are you trying to determine from those answers?

Did you miss my post about just getting home? I'm working through the thread page by page and sharing my thoughts when they happen.

 

[Fujishiro]

Do we lose since the jester was lynched? I read on the wiki that if the Jester role is day lynched, they win the game and regardless of other win conditions, we all lose in the end.

Or is that just game version dependent?

Jester isnt game ending but Rej won, we still have to but even if we lose he still has won.

 

[Gambit]

Do we lose since the jester was lynched? I read on the wiki that if the Jester role is day lynched, they win the game and regardless of other win conditions, we all lose in the end.

Or is that just game version dependent?

No he just achieved his wincon.

 

[Gambit]

Did you miss my post about just getting home? I'm working through the thread page by page and sharing my thoughts when they happen.

I've noticed a pattern. Whenever I question your reasoning, your first response tends to be dismissive ("load of horse shit", "did you miss my post?") before addressing the substance. I don't see the same approach in your interactions with others. Is there a reason for that?

 

[Fujishiro]

I've noticed a pattern. Whenever I question your reasoning, your first response tends to be dismissive ("load of horse shit", "did you miss my post?") before addressing the substance. I don't see the same approach in your interactions with others. Is there a reason for that?

He plays very scummy as town.

 

[Yoho]

Welp, it's not uniqe role


What about the rest? There are a few players barely posting who feel like they're hiding in the bushes. Any thoughts on them (Bitter, Sallu, YTW, ?

YTW has less than the required 3 post a day so Idk if he'll get mod killed or subbed out if he doesn't start being active. so imo even if he is scum we can leave him be for now at least until he starts posting since if he doesn't i suspect the hand of god will smite thee

Sally- I don't have a solid read on him just yet but his post are what the phrase yall use Nothingburgers? really no substance to it i wouldn't mind this direction but I think there's more scummy options

Bittercat- I think is likely town, imo a scum bitter would try harder to push his agenda's and have a lot more fluffy post than he does here. i think he'd me more inclined to post more if he was scum

 

[MUUGEN]

Sure jan.

 

[bittersweet]

I've noticed a pattern. Whenever I question your reasoning, your first response tends to be dismissive ("load of horse shit", "did you miss my post?") before addressing the substance. I don't see the same approach in your interactions with others. Is there a reason for that?

That wasn't meant to be dismissive. I was just answering your question. I just reached the thread pages where the discussion is taking place on my question.

 

[MUUGEN]

how does the jester role work? did Rej choose to kill Melkor or was there other mechanics at play?

i believe just that but only from the ones who voted guilty on him, we should look at those who abstained.

that would be sCumpile

 

[MUUGEN]

but g2g

 

[Yoho]

Do we lose since the jester was lynched? I read on the wiki that if the Jester role is day lynched, they win the game and regardless of other win conditions, we all lose in the end.

Or is that just game version dependent?

well my young friend and rival since the game is still going I'm gonna assume we didn't lose

 

[MUUGEN]

You suck at everything

i concur

 

[Fujishiro]

Whispering Muugen was a mistake.

 

[Gambit]

YTW has less than the required 3 post a day so Idk if he'll get mod killed or subbed out if he doesn't start being active. so imo even if he is scum we can leave him be for now at least until he starts posting since if he doesn't i suspect the hand of god will smite thee

Sally- I don't have a solid read on him just yet but his post are what the phrase yall use Nothingburgers? really no substance to it i wouldn't mind this direction but I think there's more scummy options

Bittercat- I think is likely town, imo a scum bitter would try harder to push his agenda's and have a lot more fluffy post than he does here. i think he'd me more inclined to post more if he was scum

Cool. So basically:

YTW → inactive.
Sally → nothingburgers.
Bitter → posting style.

Can you elaborate on that Bitter read? What specifically is he doing differently from his scum games? I'm not familiar with that meta.

 

[Yoho]

i believe just that but only from the ones who voted guilty on him, we should look at those who abstained.

that would be sCumpile

I personally abstained but that's just cause i wasn't here to read his case and i saw it was ending soon so I'd rather abstain than to say guilty or innocent without having all the information

 

[MUUGEN]

I personally abstained but that's just cause i wasn't here to read his case and i saw it was ending soon so I'd rather abstain than to say guilty or innocent without having all the information

he didnt plead any case.

 

[MUUGEN]

Whispering Muugen was a mistake.

cause youre scum, ill resolve you later.

 

[Zemmi]

@MUUGEN spoke softly to @Ali v2 ​

 

[Gambit]

That wasn't meant to be dismissive. I was just answering your question. I just reached the thread pages where the discussion is taking place on my question.

Cool then.

 

[Fujishiro]

Cool. So basically:

YTW → inactive.
Sally → nothingburgers.
Bitter → posting style.

Can you elaborate on that Bitter read? What specifically is he doing differently from his scum games? I'm not familiar with that meta.

That's one of the directions I want today. Don't form a wagon on Czeck this DP. If we want tp clear him, inv him. Besides, the day has just started. My opinion on him can change for sure. As for poe, I'd start with people hiding in the bushes. Michelle, Orwellian (this man keeps on coasting. Appeared today, threw fluff), AM, Hayumi, Yo Tan, Yoho. These group is like stealth. I barely notice them.

No thoughts on Sallucion?

Put him there, too.