Role Madness Jojo's Bizzare Adventure Mafia
- Thread starter Fujishiro
- Start date
I am half-way through reading (Page 13) and already have a ton of thoughts that I don't want to let go.
I have genuinely zero history with everyone on this forum aside from Sky, so while it sucks for meta-reads, I can think pretty logically outside of previous game context, which can poison some pots.
@Flower raised my eyebrows at the initial hard read of Naomi as town. I get it completely, again I have no meta-knowledge for this game so Nao could act like a sore sack whenever they draw scum, but still. However the eyebrow was lifted higher when Flower started turning eyes on Muugen and Ali for pocketing... Okay isn't that literally the same thing you did with Nao from the jump? Why should we look at Muu and Ali any differently than you and Nao from the jump, when you hard town read off a silly welcome gif.
Also claiming SK is so anti-town and solving that it's like what are we doing here.
My one gripe against flower as scum is the location bait. There's just not a shot they would be so bold to suggest an idea like that if they were scum right? Like it's such a "hey let me strap a 5 foot target on my back". It's actually the more town / indie read I have on them, which is funny because more people are condemning them for it. Just a bizarre (no pun) thing to say
My hardest town read so far is @GalaxyLevelShanks, it's still far too early for me to feel confident in any reads, but Shanks admittedly and confirmed by other peeps is a brand new player and them going out and breaking out Jojos with context for us, has been the most town read I have had. Incredibly helpful for town on that post, me included who has limited knowledge of JJBA.
Okay back to reading...
I have genuinely zero history with everyone on this forum aside from Sky, so while it sucks for meta-reads, I can think pretty logically outside of previous game context, which can poison some pots.
@Flower raised my eyebrows at the initial hard read of Naomi as town. I get it completely, again I have no meta-knowledge for this game so Nao could act like a sore sack whenever they draw scum, but still. However the eyebrow was lifted higher when Flower started turning eyes on Muugen and Ali for pocketing... Okay isn't that literally the same thing you did with Nao from the jump? Why should we look at Muu and Ali any differently than you and Nao from the jump, when you hard town read off a silly welcome gif.
Also claiming SK is so anti-town and solving that it's like what are we doing here.
My one gripe against flower as scum is the location bait. There's just not a shot they would be so bold to suggest an idea like that if they were scum right? Like it's such a "hey let me strap a 5 foot target on my back". It's actually the more town / indie read I have on them, which is funny because more people are condemning them for it. Just a bizarre (no pun) thing to say
My hardest town read so far is @GalaxyLevelShanks, it's still far too early for me to feel confident in any reads, but Shanks admittedly and confirmed by other peeps is a brand new player and them going out and breaking out Jojos with context for us, has been the most town read I have had. Incredibly helpful for town on that post, me included who has limited knowledge of JJBA.
Okay back to reading...
"tunnel" i literally listed 5 players in a pool of who can/should be lynch candidate for the day, then you somehow turned this into a pick me moment.
only voice that is important thats funny i forgot i asked for input and questioned players on their thought process, you seem hurt I called you a betatier player. the thing is i can actually make a wagon into existence. oh i was unaware you had meta and MO on me, i dont ever recall playing with you but sure, i believe i called 1 person scum and their name was york not sure where i have ever actually labeled you as such but your hard defense on yourself rather than answering the questions or being productive is any better for you. you "town" read me but want to shit talk and critique my thread play from your first post against me.
i gave questions for you to answer since you took upon yourself to go out of your way and begin shit talking lol oh wait you also said this yourself: "pointed out the flaws of your actual play" have you answered any of those questions no you havent, thats quite scumindictive, avoidance, deflection, easily triggered, these are not qualities of a townie
the thing is i didnt at first i had you as a possible lynch candidate based upon the AM read/vote which you only did after rat called you out on it, if you werent confident in your read then the after vote was null and forced to me, quite certain i stated this earlier as well.
only voice that is important thats funny i forgot i asked for input and questioned players on their thought process, you seem hurt I called you a betatier player. the thing is i can actually make a wagon into existence. oh i was unaware you had meta and MO on me, i dont ever recall playing with you but sure, i believe i called 1 person scum and their name was york not sure where i have ever actually labeled you as such but your hard defense on yourself rather than answering the questions or being productive is any better for you. you "town" read me but want to shit talk and critique my thread play from your first post against me.
i gave questions for you to answer since you took upon yourself to go out of your way and begin shit talking lol oh wait you also said this yourself: "pointed out the flaws of your actual play" have you answered any of those questions no you havent, thats quite scumindictive, avoidance, deflection, easily triggered, these are not qualities of a townie
the thing is i didnt at first i had you as a possible lynch candidate based upon the AM read/vote which you only did after rat called you out on it, if you werent confident in your read then the after vote was null and forced to me, quite certain i stated this earlier as well.
I think that's indefensible from Melkor to be honest, that's an absurd angle to justify any sort of town read on York for, much less "likely". Would say it's unlikely to come from him being paired with York too, don't think I've ever seen Melkor with that clumsy a town read over a scum mate.
Vote: Lord Melkor
Vote: Lord Melkor