Role Madness Jojo's Bizzare Adventure Mafia
- Thread starter Fujishiro
- Start date
The reasoning is what I gave you earlier, but to give you the TLDR:
-Naomi had no impetus to claim indie but did = more likely to be a genuine claim
-Fuji games, and most games even, treat an indie lynch as half a mislynch. This means that if you pursue it, you do risk advancing your condition for your own defeat. There are exceptions to all things, but it's generally only worth it if you think there is a reasonable chance that the player is scummier than they are indie-like. This means you take the "risk" of losing an indie because you think they might be scum. If you lynch someone you think is likely to flip indie, you're essentially conceding the lynch for that day. There are cases where that is optimal, but day 1? I don't think we're there yet.
-Naomi had no impetus to claim indie but did = more likely to be a genuine claim
-Fuji games, and most games even, treat an indie lynch as half a mislynch. This means that if you pursue it, you do risk advancing your condition for your own defeat. There are exceptions to all things, but it's generally only worth it if you think there is a reasonable chance that the player is scummier than they are indie-like. This means you take the "risk" of losing an indie because you think they might be scum. If you lynch someone you think is likely to flip indie, you're essentially conceding the lynch for that day. There are cases where that is optimal, but day 1? I don't think we're there yet.
my main scum suspects rn
Ali- I think he's just trying to latch onto any lynch he can get, when he couldn't get a bite on me he switched to flower and started pushing her, and he wanted to gather in Cairo which why that specific location, also haven't seen anything that screams townie from this slot
Muugen- Him and Flower play this husband wife argument game pretty much every time they play together that's not why he's on the list he's on the list because it feels like he's trying to align himself with Ali, I may have missed it but I don't recall him really pushing Flower until Ali started to.
One of the low posters- can't say which one but statiscally there's at least one scum within low posters but the vig or serial killer can handle those
Top 3 town? idk I really don't bother trying to find town, either i think you're scum or I don't i prefer to gather my suspects and investigate them than go through trying to read each indiviual person in the game.
Ali- I think he's just trying to latch onto any lynch he can get, when he couldn't get a bite on me he switched to flower and started pushing her, and he wanted to gather in Cairo which why that specific location, also haven't seen anything that screams townie from this slot
Muugen- Him and Flower play this husband wife argument game pretty much every time they play together that's not why he's on the list he's on the list because it feels like he's trying to align himself with Ali, I may have missed it but I don't recall him really pushing Flower until Ali started to.
One of the low posters- can't say which one but statiscally there's at least one scum within low posters but the vig or serial killer can handle those
Top 3 town? idk I really don't bother trying to find town, either i think you're scum or I don't i prefer to gather my suspects and investigate them than go through trying to read each indiviual person in the game.
So far the only player I'm feeling particularly co fident on being scum is Melkor. Orca I think is scummy in his own right too and could see him faking it.
By and large I'm generally more interested in my town reads than my scum ones. It's much more effective to find townies than it is to try and find scum when the overall scum play level here is... not the highest you will find to put it politely. My goal really here is, well, as the game goes on things get lost, so by explaining my reasoning now I hope later in the game someone can come back to this and find the right answers. So I would say, please do consider my scum reads, but really please do consider my town ones too.
By and large I'm generally more interested in my town reads than my scum ones. It's much more effective to find townies than it is to try and find scum when the overall scum play level here is... not the highest you will find to put it politely. My goal really here is, well, as the game goes on things get lost, so by explaining my reasoning now I hope later in the game someone can come back to this and find the right answers. So I would say, please do consider my scum reads, but really please do consider my town ones too.
Hmm, what to make of you basically having divergent reads to me completely...
I will just say, I think you are not playing as well as you can do here Yoho. Not really on my radar for today and if I try really hard I would say I'd expect a little more of a consensus table here if you were scum, but it's not enough for me to commit to any sort of town read on you. Please step it up.
I will just say, I think you are not playing as well as you can do here Yoho. Not really on my radar for today and if I try really hard I would say I'd expect a little more of a consensus table here if you were scum, but it's not enough for me to commit to any sort of town read on you. Please step it up.
Sir Ratchet always sound like a disappointed father,