I don't have any strong thoughts on Reloaded. I think he's in the range of can be scum so I'm not saying we can't go there, but I don't really know how you tell the difference between this and how he plays as town etc.
I'm going to keep my vote on Worst. The problem with his gambit today is the mindset just doesn't line up. Faking mech is one thing, but to insist on doubling and tripling down even when it clearly isn't bearing fruit just doesn't make any sense. Crucially though, he never showed any inclination of actually evaluating the information he received from his gambit. What would be the point of doing that as town, if not to extract info? As much as he can say he got some and has thought about it, that's not present at all in his play. It's not so much about changing his read - he didn't show any interest in who was defending me, who was jumping on the wagon, none of it.
Lord Melkor is another one who I think is scum, as you know, but again he hasn't developed his worldview.