Role Madness Jojo's Bizzare Adventure Mafia

Flower isn’t striking me as scum (although a good scum they are)

Rachet feels like the town that gets killed N1 /pos with the vibe and read im getting at the moment
sky’s posts sound like pissed off town, though i wanna see posts from her replacement first before locking that in
This is all the Handium content. (There is more non-content)

I like going against the grain on my slot.
I dislike the parts in brackets on flower. Leaves a backdoor open.

Ratchet felt like the voice of reason during the mid-day fights that would die n1 to make the thread implode again.
Pretty much agreed with that vibe read at the time.

The biggest red flag is the lack of content, when I am sure I have seen more in other games.
 
I'm sorry for my inactivity. Something really bad in real life came up. Don't want it as an excuse tho. (I know how this sounds, but it's something I wouldn't lie or joke about). I'll try to respect the host and the game and see it through. I went through all the pages, but I flew by a lot.

Zemmi - town lean. Your entry was pretty confident. The strong person at that time (Muugen) became tame all of a sudden. Don't know if you guys are really a married couple - but it would make sense by his behavior. XD
I also think you're looking outside the frame.

Muugen - town lean. As I said. Strong/aggressive. I liked his comments and questions at Flower. Also didn't go for the low hanging fruits like me.

RippedCal - scum lean. This is my strongest scum read - not because he voted me at some point, but because his Flower push isn't proportional to his stated reasoning. He essentially reaches the conclusion first and doesn't demonstrate the solving that got him there.

Lord Melkor - scum lean. I know, the last time I played is long ago. But something about LM makes me think he rolled scum again.
Something actually happening is not a excuse.
 
As of page 12 I like lord melkor and red night so far
Some people's vibes seem off to me but might be a tone issue rather than them being anti town so I shall keep an eye on that but not lock anything in yet
Rare reads- so likely genuine.

Duckt I've read all your posts. You didn't expand on the players whom the vibe felt off. Can you tell us what are you sus/what thoughts you accumulated after asking so many questions- didn't felt like they led anywhere so far.
 

Ratchet

The End and the Beginning
I don't have any strong thoughts on Reloaded. I think he's in the range of can be scum so I'm not saying we can't go there, but I don't really know how you tell the difference between this and how he plays as town etc.

I'm going to keep my vote on Worst. The problem with his gambit today is the mindset just doesn't line up. Faking mech is one thing, but to insist on doubling and tripling down even when it clearly isn't bearing fruit just doesn't make any sense. Crucially though, he never showed any inclination of actually evaluating the information he received from his gambit. What would be the point of doing that as town, if not to extract info? As much as he can say he got some and has thought about it, that's not present at all in his play. It's not so much about changing his read - he didn't show any interest in who was defending me, who was jumping on the wagon, none of it.

Lord Melkor is another one who I think is scum, as you know, but again he hasn't developed his worldview.
 
Top