When I was reading back, I saw Melkor was accused of being scummy because he gave York, an easy town read. What else is there?
I did find this curious, but not actually in a bad way for Melkor, because my overall read for York, is lean scum. I'm not familar with their play or style, but very similar to reloaded their few posts give me certain vibes, not sure if they are over all scummy, or just unreadable not town/or nullish.