Character Discussion Those complaining about Imu’s design haven’t read the story

#1
The two biggest complaints I’ve seen vis-à-vis Imu’s design are that firstly, it doesn’t fit with the the formal corporate/regal look of the Gorosei and the God’s Knight. Imu looks more like a criminal than the leader of the only institution providing order on the blue planet. But what critics fail to realize is that their complaint is literally Oda’s point. Despite all the high minded language the Celestial Dragons use, no matter how beautiful their outward forms are, no matter how much honorifics they put in front of their name, in reality they are far more base than any pirate and are infact the fountainhead from which all other villainy in the world stems from. I’m not trying to say Oda is breaking new ground and pushing the medium of manga to its limit or anything like that. It’s just that this is a pretty basic theme that most readers should get after a cursory reading.
Sabo even spells it out when attacks the Goresei. If you think of Imu as the boss of the diplomatic suit wearing Gorosei who deal with Akainu and Clover, this design seems out of place. However that version of the Gorosei has always been a mask for the most grotesque creatures in the One Piece World. If you think of Imu as the master of the odd Yokai forms we saw in egghead then it makes sense.
The second criticism is that Imu doesn’t look like a One Piece character. He looks as though he has been transported from another edgier manga into the colorful world of One Piece. This once again is intentional. Gaban, someone who is atleast partially privy to Imu’s past, even explicitly makes note of it in their first encounter.
 

TheAncientCenturion

I will never forgive Oda
‎‎‎
#9
Two things can be true at one time;

1. Imu's design is getting more demonic, brutish as time goes on. We know he has a super-massive monster form that will likely be his apex.

2. The design, despite Oda's philosophy, doesn't seem to work. Maybe it's the way he's drawn and other chapters will be more forgiving, but he looks pretty ugly right now.
 
#10
It is if the argument is that his design has actual thematic purpose and supplements his character
I'm not happy with the thematic purposes either though. Being more monstrous than any pirate can be accomplished through Zoan forms. Oda did this plot point with Saturn already in Egghead, where he looks human but has a pretty disgusting DF power. Also the idea that Oda needs to make Imu more physically ugly to represent him being base is just lol. It's the same line of thinking that led to Oda making Luffy eat the literal Nika fruit, instead of just being a similar figure. Not everything has to be literal, Imu not being a saint can clearly be communicated through what he does in the story.

Imu's design unironically could have been created by ChatGPT "make an anime/JRPG final villain".
 
#11
Appearence is Nothing That makes me makes Amazed or say wow!
:brootea:After so many Characters there isnt much Left..there were „Pretty“ ones Like lucci or Eneru and Not so Pretty more Monster Like ones Like Kaidou or magellan
 
#13
I'm not happy with the thematic purposes either though. Being more monstrous than any pirate can be accomplished through Zoan forms. Oda did this plot point with Saturn already in Egghead, where he looks human but has a pretty disgusting DF power. Also the idea that Oda needs to make Imu more physically ugly to represent him being base is just lol. It's the same line of thinking that led to Oda making Luffy eat the literal Nika fruit, instead of just being a similar figure. Not everything has to be literal, Imu not being a saint can clearly be communicated through what he does in the story.

Imu's design unironically could have been created by ChatGPT "make an anime/JRPG final villain".
Imu already is in his Zoan form he transformed as soon as he got to Elbaf. Manga is a visual medium there is nothing crude about using visual language to convey themes.
 
Last edited:
#18
You can make the same arguments about g5, it doesn't mean I'm gonna stop criticizing it just because oda is self aware about it
G5 is only bad because it makes the WG look incompetent in retrospect and it introduced key Worldbuilding way too late in the game. But conceptually there is nothing wrong with Luffy’s awakening as a power allowing him to stretch and reforge the world around him
 
Top