Salem of Lies Throne Of Lies: The WG War

[Ratchet]

yes, ali is claiming sheriff and he already had whispered that he was it to the king, and me, yesterday

Thanks. Though I don't think this really means anything, right? Because he has no proven results. So in theory, and I'm speaking in theory only here, I don't have the info to make further conclusions... does this not only require him to have decided to fake claim day 1? Why would the sheriff even be claiming this role? Usually you do things like this to force an alibi, whereas a sheriff with results has no need for this, the results will speak form themselves. It's like a cop trying to breadcrumb that he's a cop in mafia. It doesn't happen, because scum might catch on, and there's no real need to breadcrumb an informative role.

My current conclusion is ali is fake claiming sheriff, it's not like I'd be a hard sell when town confirmed Ekko has me in his top poe anyway. But I want to get the full picture first.

 

[Ratchet]

he caught scum who trying to wiggle out and try to indie hunt

@Worst

Don't be silly, I'm trying to understand the possibilities of what went on. If you just explain these things to me instead of leading with the conclusion, I can make progress on that. Thabks to Saber, I have a better picture than I did before.

 

[Naomi]

Don't be silly, I'm trying to understand the possibilities of what went on. If you just explain these things to me instead of leading with the conclusion, I can make progress on that. Thabks to Saber, I have a better picture than I did before.

i basically said i framed someone else, you kept jumping to the conclusion i framed you and even try to angle it as a possibility lol

 

[Saber]

Is there anything that says a played can only take one action per night? Have we confirmed this with Fuji?

that i dont know, will have to ask fuji

 

[Reborn]

that about sums it up, i was also stabbed at some point today and am bleeding i'll die in two days if not healed

Serves you right for saying Koby will beat BB

Well, orca is bleeding as well so is there anyone who can target him? I mean he didn't claim he was bleeding on day 1 so perhaps near the end he got targetted. Do we know whom he was pushing in the second half of day one?

 

[Ratchet]

Vote: Ali

I should probably just claim. I'm the Sheriff, hard claim. I checked York last night because I find her in the pool of "hard to read" players, checked her posts and found nothing from them. The results were innocent.

 

[Ratchet]

that i dont know, will have to ask fuji

Based on how Naomi reacted I think it's more likely Ali is fake claiming than it is Naomi framed twice anyway, but if it's possible it's worth considering at least.

 

[Reborn]

I have no idea what zem is saying

 

[Ratchet]

i basically said i framed someone else, you kept jumping to the conclusion i framed you and even try to angle it as a possibility lol

You need to calm down and not assume everything is an accusation. I'm simply trying to get the full picture. I need to know what is possible and what is not before I start to make conclusions. Please stop assuming that me asking questions is me jumping to conclusions. I said it was a possibility that you framed me, even you would admit it would be very in character of you to try and get me lynched or killed. Do you deny that? If you accept it, then I think you should be able to accept why I had it as a possibility.

 

[Ratchet]

I have no idea what zem is saying

Me neither fwiw

 

[Naomi]

You need to calm down and not assume everything is an accusation. I'm simply trying to get the full picture. I need to know what is possible and what is not before I start to make conclusions. Please stop assuming that me asking questions is me jumping to conclusions. I said it was a possibility that you framed me, even you would admit it would be very in character of you to try and get me lynched or killed. Do you deny that? If you accept it, then I think you should be able to accept why I had it as a possibility.

it quite annoying you think i go that far to target you every game, i got other fish to fry!

 

[Saber]

Based on how Naomi reacted I think it's more likely Ali is fake claiming than it is Naomi framed twice anyway, but if it's possible it's worth considering at least.

oh, you mean framing two different players?
no, that's impossible
scorned kinda does have a second night ability, but it would be absolutely pointless and even detrimental to not use both on the same player

 

[Ratchet]

Serves you right for saying Koby will beat BB

Well, orca is bleeding as well so is there anyone who can target him? I mean he didn't claim he was bleeding on day 1 so perhaps near the end he got targetted. Do we know whom he was pushing in the second half of day one?

Why would scum bleed Orca?

 

[Yoho]

Serves you right for saying Koby will beat BB

Well, orca is bleeding as well so is there anyone who can target him? I mean he didn't claim he was bleeding on day 1 so perhaps near the end he got targetted. Do we know whom he was pushing in the second half of day one?

You know deep in your heart Koby is the man destined to defeat Black Beard

 

[Ratchet]

it quite annoying you think i go that far to target you every game, i got other fish to fry!

Come on, you vote me every single game. There have been games where I've pretty much eliminated the scum team by myself, and you still vote me, the moment I ask a question of you, because you instantly just assume that means I think you're not town. I wouldn't even care if you did frame me, I just want it on record that it's a possibility that exists. It's not one I believe in, but one that exists. It's important to keep an open mind.

 

[Ratchet]

oh, you mean framing two different players?
no, that's impossible
scorned kinda does have a second night ability, but it would be absolutely pointless and even detrimental to not use both on the same player

Are we sure it's impossible? Her claim is that she framed Ekko, right?

 

[Naomi]

Come on, you vote me every single game. There have been games where I've pretty much eliminated the scum team by myself, and you still vote me, the moment I ask a question of you, because you instantly just assume that means I think you're not town. I wouldn't even care if you did frame me, I just want it on record that it's a possibility that exists. It's not one I believe in, but one that exists. It's important to keep an open mind.

the fact you still don't understand ritual day 1 meme vote smh

 

[Ratchet]

the fact you still don't understand ritual day 1 meme vote smh

I don't believe it's a meme, I think in almost every case you legitimately think I'm scum, and in the rare times you are scum, you have an obligation to lean into it. In fact I think I found a tell you have over it, but I'll keep that to myself.

 

[Naomi]

Me neither fwiw

[Night Active - Mind Warp] Target player will receive framed results from using investigative abilities tonight. [3-shots]

maybe there is cult, even worst thought of it.

 

[Reborn]

Why would scum bleed Orca?

Idk

It happened day 1 right? He didn't claim it during day 1. He was active during first 36 hours. So someone targeted him near the end of day phase.

I think it has to do with his reads then