Speculations Superpositions in One Piece

#1
I will be going through a list of what I refer to as superpositions where people exist in multiple states as an exercise.

1. All Devil Fruit users exist in a Man + Thing state.
Devil fruits cause people to exist between two states that defy physical reality and include concepts that involve everything in the universe based on the Paramecia, Zoan, and Logia classifications including mythical concepts in the Mythic Zoan category. They are based on dreams of people wishing they could exist in a superstate. For example, "I wish I was a hammer, so a hammer fruit was created." This is a Meta superposition.

2. Haki Types allow people to extend their bodies, use extrasensory perception, and release spiritual pressure.
A) Armament Haki allows people to imbue their life force to an armament. The armament in question may be a body part or a weapon as long as it is defined as an armament (a weapon or piece of equipment). This is a Weapon and Equipment superposition.

B) Observation Haki allows people to extend the range of their perception beyond physical reality. The forms of Observation Haki use psychic senses to achieve this. They use the 5 senses (sight, hearing, smell, taste, and touch). This is an Extrasensory superposition.

C) Conqueror's Haki allows people to impose their will onto others. Its range and intensity is proportional to their dream and how it relates to the dreams of other people, and it requires them to have the qualities of a king which relate to a dream powerful enough to lead a nation. This is a Willpower superposition.

3) Devil Fruit Awakenings allow people to extend the effect of the Devil Fruit ability to things other than the user's own body.
Devil Fruits originally only affect the user's own body, but when they awaken they begin to affect other things. This creates an Environmental superposition.


4) Three-Sword Style
Zoro's choice of sword style uses three separate swords in combination with animal-based techniques in the material world and entity-based techniques in the immaterial world. For example, he will attack with the form of a gorilla, a dragon, or a demon. This is an Identity and Weapon or Equipment superposition.


5) Sanji's Swirl
Sanji uses the same rotational force as celestial bodies: the Sun, the Moon, and the Earth use rotational energy. He also uses his legs as a form of cooking tool which qualifies as a weapon or piece of equipment (Armament Haki). This is a Rotational and Weapon or Equipment superposition.


6) Nami's Climatact
Nami uses her Climatact to manipulate the atmosphere and create attacks that are primarily lightning based. She also uses a sentient cloud (Zeus) to redirect the lightning. This is an Atmospheric and Spatial superposition.


7. Usopp's Black Helmet
Usopp uses his Black Helmet to provide utility and range support based on adaptive plant life. He also employs misdirection and bluffs to trick opponents into false realities. This is an Adaptation and Information superposition.


Note: If we take this framework to its conclusion, we can categorize and classify almost any major character or technique in One Piece into these distinct superstates.
 
Last edited:
#3
3) Devil Fruit Awakenings allow people to extend the effect of the Devil Fruit ability to things other than the user's own body.
Devil Fruits originally only affect the user's own body, but when they awaken they begin to affect other things. This creates an Environmental superposition.
This bothers me a lot. I'd say is 34% true because it doesn't apply to Zoan awakening and we not sure about logias.
 
#5
This bothers me a lot. I'd say is 34% true because it doesn't apply to Zoan awakening and we not sure about logias.
It's only 34% true if you assume Doflamingo was giving misleading information.

If you assume he was using correct information, then when he said they begin affecting things other than the body and encompass a plethora of abilities, he wasn't lying. It was 💯

You would be actively trying to resist the in-story dialogue concerning the rules of awakenings in the perspective you're taking.
 
#6
I can't understand that
Indeed, my powerscaling metrics don't honor the same rules most people use. I don't see it the way they do and they can't see it my way.

Here's the thing with physical stats like strength or speed, though. They are classical physics models that are by definition defied by quantum physics. A superposition is a quantum model.
 
Last edited:
#8
It's only 34% true if you assume Doflamingo was giving misleading information.

If you assume he was using correct information, then when he said they begin affecting things other than the body and encompass a plethora of abilities, he wasn't lying. It was 💯

You would be actively trying to resist the in-story dialogue concerning the rules of awakenings in the perspective you're taking.
Ok you have 0 interpretation skills
 
#12

This is an example of how superposition works in Naruto. Naruto is learning the Rasenshuriken and discovers he needs to use 3 clones to handle 3 different tasks to do it. Before he learned that, he compared it to looking right and left at the same time and called it impossible. However, Kakashi demonstrated he could look left and right by using the clone jutsu. Naruto had an epiphany and completed the jutsu as a result.
 
#13
Chakra, Haki, and other forms of energy like Nen are all explainable through a quantum model rather than a classical model (classical physics denies that energy can exist this way).

Fundamentally, all of these forms of energy violate the principles of classic physics. When applied to the human body, it means a person can do things like project their will. In short, it's pseudo-science.

It's pseudo-science that blends spiritualism and science, it's a quantum model applied as the biofield surrounding a person. That's scientifically what it is explained to be. It can't be anything else or it becomes magic.

A good example of this is in Sakamoto Days where Atari used a pseudo-scientific explanation for why a sword phased through Shin's body. It was a quantum tunneling effect that used probability to bypass constraints of classical physics.
 
Last edited:
#17
You belief something manga directly contradicts
I can say the same thing about you refusing to believe what Doflamingo said is true.

It can't be "half true" just because you say it is.

I also have facts to back me up. Your position relies on saying Lucci, Kaku, and the Jailer Beasts are supposed to affect the environment if what Doflamingo said is true, and since they don't you say Zoan Awakenings don't affect the environment. The fact of the matter is that Luffy has proven Mythic Zoans can.

If the question is if it's possible Zoans can affect the environment, then the answer is a simple yes because Luffy does. What you're doing in your argument is saying some Zoans don't, and that's another discussion entirely because the state of the original premise has changed.
 
#18
Chapter 1045, The infamous "are you having fun, Kaido?" chapter... On the first page Kaido makes a distinction between Paramecia and Zoan awakenings, one affecting your surroundings and the other being a body transformation, which makes him confused about Luffy having both features.
So the current available information says: The "affecting things other than your body" is a distinct feature of Paramecia types, no mention of Zoans other than Luffy, even less for Logias (we didn't even get to see how those work on panel as of yet).
And then, if we go by the info given by Doflamingo, he says "some devil fruits" not "all devil fruits".
What would guys like Lucci & Kaku transform the surroundings into? Fur balls? Leather? Don't give lolda ideas.
 
#19
Chapter 1045, The infamous "are you having fun, Kaido?" chapter... On the first page Kaido makes a distinction between Paramecia and Zoan awakenings, one affecting your surroundings and the other being a body transformation, which makes him confused about Luffy having both features.
So the current available information says: The "affecting things other than your body" is a distinct feature of Paramecia types, no mention of Zoans other than Luffy, even less for Logias (we didn't even get to see how those work on panel as of yet).
And then, if we go by the info given by Doflamingo, he says "some devil fruits" not "all devil fruits".
What would guys like Lucci & Kaku transform the surroundings into? Fur balls? Leather? Don't give lolda ideas.
You guys are trying to say Luffy is an exception and Zoans don't affect the environment. Again, if the question is if it's possible Zoans can affect the environment then the answer is a simple yes.

You're trying to make an argument that some Zoans don't apply by that rule which is different from saying Zoans don't affect the environment. They're two separate subjects.

It's not my fault Kaido got confused and couldn't understand lol
 
Top