Character Discussion Who is stronger between Jinbe and Sanji?

Who is the third strongest of the crew?


  • Total voters
    131
#1
Who do you think is the third strongest of the crew? Sanji or Jinbe?

before going further, i'd like to emphasize that zoro is the second strongest of the crew, he is always portrayed that way and this should be obvious honestly. But i know some of you will still disagree with me, so i'll explain first why zoro is the second strongest of the crew

1.
According to Databook Vivrecard Volume 4, it states that Jinbe officially joined the strawhat in WCI, so Jinbe is already counted as strawhat's member in Wano, here i give you the proof:

[GALLERY=media, 346][/GALLERY]

Now, according to Databook Vivrecard Volume 1, it states that zoro is the second strongest of the crew. As you know, Databook Vivrecard Volume 1 came out in 2018, the year the Wano arc began, so it means Wano Zoro is the second strongest of the crew, which also proves Wano zoro > Wano Jinbe, here i give you the proof:

[GALLERY=media, 347][/GALLERY]

2. Since that databook came out during the beginning of Wano Arc, it means it was talking about Pre Enma Zoro, So with zoro having Enma as power up, Enma zoro is no doubt stronger than Jinbe. The only issue here is whether the databook points to Raid Suit Sanji or not, we know for sure Sanji already have the raid suit since the end of WCI, but had only used it later against Page One. though we must admit Sanji never trains with it while zoro was seen training with Enma, so by default it remains the same, Enma Zoro > Jinbe/RS Sanji

Now, let's talk about the main topic, who is the third strongest of the crew currently?

#Arguments for Jinbei
- Pushed back Big Mom
- Fought with Ace for 3 days straight, and it was years ago
- Tanked Akainu punch that goes through his body and didnt even faint, and even seemed fine in Amazon Lily
- Managed to block Akainu's punch

#Arguments for Sanji
- Got Raid Suit
- managed to block Big Mom's attack alongside Luffy

That are their main feats for now, so let's analyze it thoroughly
● Defense
Jinbe tanked a punch from Akainu while Sanji tanked a direct hit fron King, Admiral>YC, so this easily goes in favor of Jinbe
● Strength
Sanji with Luffy blocked Big Mom Attack, while Jinbe managed to block Akainu's punch singlehandedly, so again this easily goes in favor of Jinbe
● Speed
Not much to say, this easily goes in favor of Sanji
● Observation Haki
Not much is known, by speculation wise i'd give this for Sanji
● Armament Haki
Not much is known, but speculation wise i'd give this for Jinbe as he has some pretty good damn feats of blocking attack from Top Tiers, and such feats imo could only be achieved with the help of Armament Haki

So overall, Jinbe is stronger than Sanji

Meaning, the ranking of the strawhats currently is:
Luffy > Zoro > Jinbe > Sanji > Others

What do you think?
 

Jew D. Boy

I Can Go Lower
#6
Jinbe, but I really don’t think Sanji’s that far behind...Oda and a lot of us around here clown on him (for good reason), but he’s still gotten his Ws in the series (almost all of them coming before Marineford) and has earned his time as a member of the Monster Trio. Need to see him do something of substance in Wano to accept that this is all still true, to be fair.
 
#8
Sanji walked away without a scratch from King's attack to his stomach.

Jimbe taking Akainu's attack put him in emergency surgery, with Law saying that in spite of all of the hax at his disposal chances are slim that he will be able to save Jimbe's life.

As seen with Jimbe and Sanji escorting Luffy to the roof and both taking out Headliners with base attacks, Oda continues the parallel portrayal he's been doing since FI with Base Sanji and Jimbe.

Throw the RS in and is a wash in Sanji's favor.
 
#9
Jinbe, but I really don’t think Sanji’s that far behind...Oda and a lot of us around here clown on him (for good reason), but he’s still gotten his Ws in the series (almost all of them coming before Marineford) and has earned his time as a member of the Monster Trio. Need to see him do something of substance in Wano to accept that this is all still true, to be fair.
agree
 
#11
Sanji walked away without a scratch from King's attack to his stomach.

Jimbe taking Akainu's attack put him in emergency surgery, with Law saying that in spite of all of the hax at his disposal chances are slim that he will be able to save Jimbe's life.

As seen with Jimbe and Sanji escorting Luffy to the roof and both taking out Headliners with base attacks, Oda continues the parallel portrayal he's been doing since FI with Base Sanji and Jimbe.

Throw the RS in and is a wash in Sanji's favor.
Yeah i can see that, imo their fight could go either way, but i'd still give Jinbe a slightly upper edge, Ofc Sanji can be scaled higher but i need to see it first soon, and i hope he'll be taking Ws soon
 
#12
Yeah i can see that, imo their fight could go either way, but i'd still give Jinbe a slightly upper edge, Ofc Sanji can be scaled higher but i need to see it first soon, and i hope he'll be taking Ws soon
Well, Jimbe will defeat a Flying Six that got parallel portrayal with Franky's opponent.

Sanji and Zoro will be the only SH's to defeat All Star opponents in Queen and King.
 
#16
Well, Jimbe will defeat a Flying Six that got parallel portrayal with Franky's opponent.

Sanji and Zoro will be the only SH's to defeat All Star opponents in Queen and King.
good point, but Jinbe's possible future opponent aka Whos Who got parallel portrayal with All Star
Post automatically merged:

> Thread asks who is stronger between Jinbe and Sanji

> The poll asks who is the third strongest of SH pirates :suresure:

Zoro fans never stops being desperate against Sanji, and now apparently against Jinbe too. :steef:
Well i give you fact that zoro is the second strongest strawhat according to Databook, so the third strongest will either be Jinbe or Sanji, or do you think it is supposed to be Jinbe or Franky lol?
 
#17
good point, but Jinbe's possible future opponent aka Whos Who got parallel portrayal with All Star
Not just Whos Who, him and Sasaki both got the same portrayal as former Captains who usually don't follow orders.

So that arguably gives them better hype than the rest of Flying Six, but still less than Jack, who in turn is shown to be bullied by Queen and King.

It goes :

King >=Queen >> Jack >> Who's WHo ~ Sasanji >= Rest of Flying six
 
#18
Not just Whos Who, him and Sasaki both got the same portrayal as former Captains who usually don't follow orders.

So that arguably gives them better hype than the rest of Flying Six, but still less than Jack, who in turn is shown to be bullied by Queen and King.

It goes :

King >=Queen >> Jack >> Who's WHo ~ Sasanji >= Rest of Flying six
I can see that because we can only speculate for now, but imo Jinbe is definitely stronger than Jack and all of the Flying 6, i dont think Jack could tank Top Tier's attack without fainting
 
Top